webnovel
AlfiemooonLv44mth
2024-10-22 02:04

you can tell the author is inexperienced. it's just filled with exposition dumps and poor character dialogue, and the story itself isn't breaking any records, with silly character decisions and plot contrivance's everywhere. Nobody is developed, the author relies on our knowledge of the source material for that. it's just a huge mess. it needs serious revisions from the first chapter to even be considered a 2* piece of work.

Liked by 19 people

LIKE
Replies17
HeliosTheDepressedAuthor

Well, if you say so Mr John Webnovel since you're apparently an expert at this

AlfiemooonLv4

I'm a literature and creative writing graduate, so yeah, I know a little about what I'm going on about

HeliosTheDepressed:Well, if you say so Mr John Webnovel since you're apparently an expert at this
image
BakenekonLv4

Glad I'm not the only one who thought so. Honestly, what's wrong with people.

HeliosTheDepressedAuthor

Bakenekon:Glad I'm not the only one who thought so. Honestly, what's wrong with people.
BakenekonLv4

HeliosTheDepressed:
image
Kono_TimodaLv3

Yeah, same here!!! Now and again, I see this story pop up, and I'm like, "Oh, this is new." I checked the review number, and it seems promising. Nope, it's a dumpster fire with augured writing. Usually, this gets 1 star spammed until it averages around 3 stars or so. Some way, somehow, it has a 4.5, and I'm like, "HOW!! Explain yourself."

Bakenekon:Glad I'm not the only one who thought so. Honestly, what's wrong with people.
Kono_TimodaLv3

Although I agreed initially, there is a qualitative change between chapters 1 and 10; I don't know if it is a new editor or something but it's improving.

Lucky_Cat771Lv2

Nah this one get 4-5 star because it's was good when compared to the other garbage jjk fic become pokemon catching fiction. and because the author was one of them(i mean the weird side of jjk fandom or you could say "true" jjk fans)

Kono_Timoda:Yeah, same here!!! Now and again, I see this story pop up, and I'm like, "Oh, this is new." I checked the review number, and it seems promising. Nope, it's a dumpster fire with augured writing. Usually, this gets 1 star spammed until it averages around 3 stars or so. Some way, somehow, it has a 4.5, and I'm like, "HOW!! Explain yourself."
Kono_TimodaLv3

Nvm Ch 11 has disproved this paragraph.

Kono_Timoda:Although I agreed initially, there is a qualitative change between chapters 1 and 10; I don't know if it is a new editor or something but it's improving.
HeliosTheDepressedAuthor

this is my first every fic, obviously the first chunk of chapters are gonna be trash it becomes decent at around chapter 15 the fic actually becomes good at around chapter 28 imo, so any review past that is accurate to the star rating so if you want an accurate measure of how good this fic is, read to chapter 28 and if you still hate it then idk what to tell you

Kono_Timoda:Although I agreed initially, there is a qualitative change between chapters 1 and 10; I don't know if it is a new editor or something but it's improving.
Hidden_WrathLv4

bro chill don't let them get into your head you're working on it the story isn't bad from what i can tell and you're actively trying to make it better screw the nay sayers

HeliosTheDepressed:this is my first every fic, obviously the first chunk of chapters are gonna be trash it becomes decent at around chapter 15 the fic actually becomes good at around chapter 28 imo, so any review past that is accurate to the star rating so if you want an accurate measure of how good this fic is, read to chapter 28 and if you still hate it then idk what to tell you
HeliosTheDepressedAuthor

don't worry about me my guy, the fic has already been completed and i know it's really good just annoys me to no end when people judge only the worst parts of my work and call the rest trash

Hidden_Wrath:bro chill don't let them get into your head you're working on it the story isn't bad from what i can tell and you're actively trying to make it better screw the nay sayers
AlfiemooonLv4

A piece of work is obviously going to be judged as a whole. You don't call a painting good when a large chunk of it is the equivalent of scribbles. You can't expect people to read what you deem as the "good parts" if they can't stand the start. That's such a childish mindset. Even if you weren't bias, You really can't call your own story good when It takes over 20 chapters to read a stage where, it's even just subpar to read. There's no evidence pointing towards the story being adequate enough to read if it takes you a horrendous amount of chapters to read the bare minimum.

AlfiemooonLv4

Way to many mistakes here, but then again, wasn't exactly proofread 🤷‍♂️

Alfiemooon:A piece of work is obviously going to be judged as a whole. You don't call a painting good when a large chunk of it is the equivalent of scribbles. You can't expect people to read what you deem as the "good parts" if they can't stand the start. That's such a childish mindset. Even if you weren't bias, You really can't call your own story good when It takes over 20 chapters to read a stage where, it's even just subpar to read. There's no evidence pointing towards the story being adequate enough to read if it takes you a horrendous amount of chapters to read the bare minimum.
Kono_TimodaLv3

Don't worry, we can tell, but the norm is, regardless of how good the story gets, based on the first couple chapters, the story can get carpet bombed with 1 stars.

HeliosTheDepressed:this is my first every fic, obviously the first chunk of chapters are gonna be trash it becomes decent at around chapter 15 the fic actually becomes good at around chapter 28 imo, so any review past that is accurate to the star rating so if you want an accurate measure of how good this fic is, read to chapter 28 and if you still hate it then idk what to tell you
ZeroMorningstarLv14

I think he made this story perfect and had fun doing it as you can see in his writing

Emmanuel_CapricornLv4

Oh damn. That's very cool.

Alfiemooon:I'm a literature and creative writing graduate, so yeah, I know a little about what I'm going on about
Other Reviews
Jay_SlaterLv1
Related Stories