webnovel
1step1kill
1step1killLv53yr
2021-06-09 00:03

Normally I just read and don't leave any comments but I had to leave a review for this one. This fanfiction started off with a decent idea, waking up in a wealthy pure blood child and practicing magic like a fanfiction addict would. The author ruined the fanfiction for me when the mc: 1. Had a magic core and goes through 'growth' phases at certain ages. 2. Chose to go to Hogwarts when as a Harry Potter fan you know the teachers suck and the standards are terrible. 3. Made wands the devil, where the mc is afraid of using a wand as it will stop his core's growth. 4. Uses and practices wandless magic in front of students and at students without a cover (his fake wand which he left in his room for some reason) while saying he's trying to keep it a secret (I guess he forgot about all the portraits spying too). 5. Reused lines from the original story even though it takes place like a year earlier (I guess Dumbledore uses the same lines every year now) 6. very bad romance with a 12 year old.

Liked by 149 people

LIKE
Replies13
lord_couchpotato
lord_couchpotatoLv3

Well it's not as bad tbh 1. Regarding the core thing it was not really used in the story afterword's to make an impact on the story and honestly how does it matters if the magic is in the core it won't impact progress rate 2. He chose Hogwarts because he knows about the benefits like RoR and castle itself. He didn't really need to fear the plot as he is pureblood and hence not a target for voldy and as long as he does not openly fight him like harry there is no risk tbh if i were in position i would also chose hogwarts 3. He rejects wand because he made connection between his body and magic and want was diverting the connection from his body to itself. Also as it made him much powerful so if he started using it it would be hard to do back(Though i agree author made it a bit dramatic) 4. He used wandless magic once outside as far as i remember and that time also he managed to trick his way out 5. Well i didn't notice dumbles speech but does it really matter and dumbles were giving general information and there was nothing plot related 6. There is no romance in the story as of 87th chapter, there has been some girls showing interest but that is just like minor crush at most.

Noel_Elitia
Noel_ElitiaLv1

try reading when i got reincarnated as a spider with my goddess you won't be disappointed

shubh_gupta
shubh_guptaLv2

The reviewer is not the mentor of the author, why are you trying to saddle him with the responsibilities of one?

The content has been deleted
KING_IN_YELLOW
KING_IN_YELLOWLv5

i think i get the guy hating the core stuff it made the novel like xianxia where if someone has higher core than you then you lose no matter what, but that rule don't apply to mc and in harry potter thats not how it works even merlin would lose to voldi if given the right prep, so yeah it isn't the best to add a core system plus in harry potter spell can be learn by anybody without needing to have a core level etc.

lord_couchpotato:Well it's not as bad tbh 1. Regarding the core thing it was not really used in the story afterword's to make an impact on the story and honestly how does it matters if the magic is in the core it won't impact progress rate 2. He chose Hogwarts because he knows about the benefits like RoR and castle itself. He didn't really need to fear the plot as he is pureblood and hence not a target for voldy and as long as he does not openly fight him like harry there is no risk tbh if i were in position i would also chose hogwarts 3. He rejects wand because he made connection between his body and magic and want was diverting the connection from his body to itself. Also as it made him much powerful so if he started using it it would be hard to do back(Though i agree author made it a bit dramatic) 4. He used wandless magic once outside as far as i remember and that time also he managed to trick his way out 5. Well i didn't notice dumbles speech but does it really matter and dumbles were giving general information and there was nothing plot related 6. There is no romance in the story as of 87th chapter, there has been some girls showing interest but that is just like minor crush at most.
lord_couchpotato
lord_couchpotatoLv3

That's now how cores work in hp fanfics it's just the capacity of magic wizard can hold and utilize, it does not make them immune to spells. Maybe it enhances body and instincts a but but that does not make them unbeatable and similar logic can be used when using magic present in environment. I prefer magic core as other wise if you are in a place with no ambient magic wizards will not be able to use magic one bit.

KING_IN_YELLOW:i think i get the guy hating the core stuff it made the novel like xianxia where if someone has higher core than you then you lose no matter what, but that rule don't apply to mc and in harry potter thats not how it works even merlin would lose to voldi if given the right prep, so yeah it isn't the best to add a core system plus in harry potter spell can be learn by anybody without needing to have a core level etc.
MKA2401
MKA2401Lv1

Hm. The author was simply trying to make a comprehensible magic system.

kkkking
kkkkingLv3

that's my adoptive mother

The content has been deleted
MrPadz
MrPadzLv12

shameless plug lol

Noel_Elitia:try reading when i got reincarnated as a spider with my goddess you won't be disappointed
Kono_phineas_da
Kono_phineas_daLv2

Xiphos_Gladius_03
Xiphos_Gladius_03Lv1

Even if the teachers suck, he has the room of requirement. He can also ask flitwick to mentor him in dueling and McGonagall for help if he impresses her.

Onigami
OnigamiLv5

who is his love interest?

Mysteries_
Mysteries_Lv11

Obrigado por me ajudar a poupar tempo

CFrank1
CFrank1Lv1

Pls use a spoiler tag please, you’ve ruined it for me now

Other Reviews
Related Stories

Reborn as Petunia Evans with a System

Anna Watson’s life was far from easy. A battle with cancer left her frail, defeated, and questioning her life’s meaning. Her final moments were filled with regret for dreams unrealized and paths untaken. But when death embraced her, it wasn’t the end—she awakened in an entirely new world: the wizarding world of Harry Potter. Yet, this wasn’t the familiar era of Harry, Ron, and Hermione. She found herself in the time of the Marauders, a generation before the golden trio. Even more shocking, Anna had a new identity: Petunia Evans, the famously non-magical, bitter sister of Lily Potter. But this Petunia is different. Born as Lily's twin, Anna retains her memories of her past life and discovers she has magic—a shocking divergence from the character she once read about. Her magical abilities open up opportunities and challenges, not only for her but for her relationship with Lily, her new family, and the unfolding story of the wizarding world. As Anna navigates Hogwarts alongside the Marauders, Severus Snape, and her own twin, she realizes that the story she once knew is shifting. Her choices ripple across timelines, altering destinies and alliances. Struggling to reconcile her knowledge of the future with her growing affection for this new life, Anna must decide: should she preserve the world’s fate or carve out a new destiny for herself and those she loves? In this thrilling twist on the Harry Potter universe, the story explores themes of second chances, sibling bonds, and the weight of choice, painting a vivid and detailed picture of what might have been if Petunia Evans had the magic to change it all.

ruokay2210 · Book&Literature
4.2
46 Chs

Crimson Destiny (Fantastic Beasts Fanfic) [Temp Hiatus]

Additional Tags:- Female-MC, Yuri-Harem (6 Members), Kingdom-Building, Romance, Multiple-Point-of-View, Fantastic-Beast-Timeline, Canon-Divergent, Lawful-Evil-MC, No-Futa, No-NTR, Original-Characters, AU-Characters, Cruelty, Abuse, Foul-Language, Manipulating-From-Shadows, Fluff, Lemons, Torture-Scenes, Detailed-Magical-Application, Slow-Paced This is a Fanfic... I don't own anything!!! All the characters except the MC and the World belong to J.K. Rowling!! Even the Art of the MC belongs to their respective owners. --~Some Notes~-- 1st:- English is not my first language, though I will try my best to avoid mistakes. 2nd:- Neither the MC nor the MC's love interests would be involved in any type of sexual abuse or those type of scenarios. 3rd:- This is not your generic HP Fanfic, as it will take place in the Pre-Fantastic Beast and Fantastic Beast Timeline. 4th:- Since the whole plot about that timeline is not known the plot after the movie Crimes of Grindelwald is going to be very different. 5th:- This will be a weekly release fic so don't keep asking for new chapters. The new chapters will be published on Wednesday/Thursday. --~Synopsis (SEASON- I, II)~-- Abandoned right after she was born, the MC was left all alone to brave the cruel world on her own. That is until the day when a man saves her from a cruel fate. See how the man known as Gellert Grindelwald becomes her guide, mentor, her father figure throughout the years. This is the story of Destiny Grindelwald, the heir of Gellert Grindelwald. Follow her as she braves the cruel world. Watch her as she creates a better world for the Magical Population. --~Discord~-- If you want to discuss something or check the artwork or the character sheets then join my Discord Server. My Discord Server Link:- https://discord.gg/zdUqAGKrkm

InGlorious · Book&Literature
4.9
61 Chs