How to countersue the plaintiff in a divorceThe following conditions must be met in order to counterclaim in a divorce lawsuit:
1. The person who raised the counterclaim must be the defendant of the lawsuit, and the object of the counterclaim must be the plaintiff of the lawsuit.
2. The counterclaim must be based on the existence of the lawsuit, and the object and reason of the counterclaim must be related to the lawsuit.
3. The purpose of a counterclaim is to annex or offset the claims of the main complaint.
4. The counterclaim must be filed after the complaint is accepted and before the court debate ends.
5. The counterclaim must be brought to the people's court that accepted the complaint.
It should be noted that in divorce proceedings, for some requests made by the defendant, such as child support and property division requests in the defense statement or within the time limit for evidence, although it is similar to a counterclaim in form, it does not constitute a counterclaim in the civil procedure law in essence. The court should ask the defendant to clarify its claim, and the claim should be combined and notified to pay the lawsuit fees in advance according to the relevant regulations. In addition, in some cases, although it seems to meet the conditions for counterclaims, from the overall characteristics of divorce proceedings (such as divorce proceedings is the merger of the three lawsuits of dissolving marriage, property and child support, etc.), some of the requests made by the defendant may not constitute a counterclaim. For example, the man's request to return the dowry after the woman filed for divorce does not constitute a counterclaim in a strict legal sense. However, the court may consider a joint trial to improve the efficiency of the lawsuit and reduce the burden of the parties.
<a href="/?from=ask_words" style="color:red" target="_blank">Read more exciting novels for free</a>
Can the plaintiff countersue for divorce in the lawsuit?In a divorce lawsuit, a counterclaim refers to a claim made by the defendant against the plaintiff. The lawsuit filed by the plaintiff itself was the original lawsuit, and there was no situation where the plaintiff countersued the original lawsuit. Therefore, the plaintiff could not countersue the divorce in the lawsuit.
<a href="/?from=ask_words" style="color:red" target="_blank">Read more exciting novels for free</a>
Can the plaintiff countersue after withdrawing the lawsuit?If the plaintiff had already sued and withdrawn the lawsuit, the defendant could file a counterclaim.
After the lawsuit was withdrawn, the court would usually allow the defendant to withdraw the counterclaim. Because withdrawing the lawsuit is the right of the parties involved, the parties involved in this lawsuit and the counterclaim have equal litigation rights. Since the withdrawal of this lawsuit is not illegal, the counterclaim plaintiff (i.e., the defendant of this lawsuit) does not need to review the withdrawal of the counterclaim, and the court should allow it.
Moreover, the withdrawal of this lawsuit did not affect the hearing of the counterclaim. Although this lawsuit and the counterclaim are related, they are independent of each other. After the counterclaim is raised, it will not be extinguished because of the withdrawal of this lawsuit. On the one hand, the counterclaim was independent. After it was filed according to the requirements of the lawsuit, it had its own independence, and it was reasonable for the court to continue hearing it. On the other hand, the counterclaim had a certain degree of dependence on the lawsuit. After the lawsuit was withdrawn, the counterclaim would lose its targeting but become a special form of lawsuit, and the court should continue hearing it. Moreover, from the relevant legal provisions, it could be inferred that the counterclaim and this lawsuit did not have to be jointly tried. The counterclaim could be tried separately. After the lawsuit was withdrawn, the rejection of the counterclaim would lead to unresolved contradictions and increase the burden of the lawsuit.
In addition, after the withdrawal of this lawsuit, the trial of the counterclaim will continue to use the case number of this lawsuit.
However, the counterclaim originated from the main action. After the main action was withdrawn, the counterclaim would continue to be tried within the scope of the involvement of the main action. The claim based on the counterclaim should be related to the main action and should not exceed the scope of the main action.
<a href="/?from=ask_words" style="color:red" target="_blank">Read more exciting novels for free</a>
The defendant retorted that the plaintiff had his moneyIn some legal disputes, it was possible for the defendant to accuse the plaintiff of having money. For example, in a loan dispute case, the defendant might claim that the plaintiff had extorted money from him in order to avoid repayment. For example, in the loan dispute heard by the Huazhou court, the defendant bit the plaintiff in court to extort money from him. However, the plaintiff could provide evidence such as witnesses, recordings and loan receipt to prove the existence of the loan. The court finally determined the fact of the loan through appraisal and other procedures, and determined that the defendant had to repay the principal of the loan and the corresponding interest.
In this case, the court would combine the evidence of both parties to make a judgment. The plaintiff's claims needed to be supported by facts and legal evidence, such as clear transaction records, witness testimony, etc. Although the defendant had the right to refute, he needed to have a reasonable basis to refute and could not bite back without any basis. If the plaintiff could fully prove that his claim was legal and reasonable, and the defendant had no evidence to support his claim, then the defendant's counter-bite would not be recognized by the court.
<a href="/?from=ask_words" style="color:red" target="_blank">Read more exciting novels for free</a>
The plaintiff repeatedly sued the defendant for not appearing in courtIf the plaintiff sued repeatedly and the defendant did not appear in court, it would be handled according to the circumstances:
** I. Defendant's Failure to Appear in Court **
1. ** You don't have to appear in court to be sued **
- If the defendant is not required to appear in court, if he refuses to appear in court without justifiable reasons after being summoned by a summons, or if he leaves the court without the permission of the court, he may be sentenced in absentia. When the court made a judgment in absentia, it would not completely follow the plaintiff's claim just because the defendant did not appear in court. The judge needed to review the evidence presented by the plaintiff. For a case where the plaintiff had insufficient evidence, even if the defendant did not appear in court, the plaintiff's claim might not be supported.
2. ** Must appear in court to be sued **
- If the defendant is a defendant who must appear in court, if he refuses to appear in court without justifiable reasons after being summoned twice, he may be detained.
** 2. Regarding the Plaintiff's Repeating Lawsuit **
1. ** Normal case **
- If the plaintiff had legal and reasonable reasons for each lawsuit, new evidence, etc., the case would be tried according to the normal litigation procedures. However, if the plaintiff abused his right of action, such as repeatedly suing the same defendant without new facts or evidence, the court might review it and deal with it according to the specific circumstances.
2. ** False Lawsuits **
- If the plaintiff fabricated the facts of the civil case to sue, not only would the lawsuit be rejected, but it would also be fined or detained according to the seriousness of the case. If it constituted a crime, it would also be investigated for criminal responsibility according to law. In this case, even if the defendant did not appear in court, the court would not support the plaintiff's malicious litigation.
<a href="/?from=ask_words" style="color:red" target="_blank">Read more exciting novels for free</a>
In a civil suit, can a plaintiff read his story?Yes. The plaintiff has the right to tell their side of the story in court. Reading their story can be a way to provide a narrative that the judge and jury can understand. It's like painting a picture of what happened from their perspective. However, they may also be cross - examined after, to test the validity of what they've said.
What if the original plaintiff withdraws the lawsuit after the counterclaim?In a civil case where the defendant filed a counterclaim, if the plaintiff withdraws the lawsuit, the people's court shall make a ruling on the part of the lawsuit, allowing the plaintiff to withdraw the lawsuit, and continue to hear the counterclaim and make a judgment according to law. Because a counterclaim was an independent claim made by the defendant, it was independent of the complaint and could exist independently. The parties to this lawsuit and the counterclaim have equal litigation rights. The plaintiff has the right to withdraw the lawsuit, and the defendant also has the right to withdraw the counterclaim. If the defendant applies to withdraw the counterclaim, the people's court shall permit it. However, although the plaintiff withdrew the lawsuit during the trial of the case, since the counterclaim originated from the lawsuit, the counterclaim could still be tried within the scope of the lawsuit after the withdrawal of the lawsuit. Moreover, the claim made by the counterclaim plaintiff based on the counterclaim should be related to the lawsuit and should not exceed the scope of the lawsuit.
<a href="/?from=ask_words" style="color:red" target="_blank">Read more exciting novels for free</a>
Can the defendant countersue after the plaintiff withdraws the lawsuit?After the plaintiff withdrew the lawsuit, the defendant could not raise a counterclaim. The existence of a counterclaim is based on the premise of this lawsuit. The withdrawal of the lawsuit by the plaintiff means that the trial of this lawsuit has ended, and the legal relationship and facts on which the defendant raised the counterclaim no longer exist. However, the defendant may file a lawsuit in another people's court that has jurisdiction. The following conditions must be met: the plaintiff is a citizen, legal person, or other organization that has a direct interest in the case; there is a clear defendant; there are specific claims, facts, and reasons for the lawsuit; it is within the scope of the people's court's acceptance of civil litigation and under the jurisdiction of the people's court. If the case has entered the trial stage and the plaintiff withdraws the lawsuit, the defendant's counterclaim shall be dealt with according to the provisions of article 239 of the Supreme People's Court's Interpretation on the application of the Civil Lawsuit Law of the People's Republic of China. If the people's court permits the plaintiff to withdraw the lawsuit, it shall continue to hear the counterclaim. If the defendant applied to withdraw the counterclaim, the people's court should allow it, but this was only for the case that had already entered the trial stage. This provision did not apply when the case had not entered the substantial trial stage after the case was filed.
<a href="/?from=ask_words" style="color:red" target="_blank">Read more exciting novels for free</a>
The Plaintiff Has Withdrawn the Lawsuit, Is the Counterclaim Still of Use?If the plaintiff had withdrawn the lawsuit, the effectiveness of the counterclaim might be affected. A counterclaim is a counterclaim against the main claim. When the main claim is withdrawn, the court may re-evaluate the counterclaim.
In some cases, if the content of the counterclaim is closely related to the complaint and can exist independently, the court may continue to hear the counterclaim. However, if the existence of the counterclaim is completely dependent on the complaint, or if the trial of the counterclaim is meaningless, the court may not continue to deal with the counterclaim. However, this also depended on the specific circumstances of the case, local judicial practice, and relevant laws and regulations.
<a href="/?from=ask_words" style="color:red" target="_blank">Read more exciting novels for free</a>