webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of Humbuub in HP: Magic Punk

Review detail

Humbuub
HumbuubLv44mthHumbuub

Thr writing is quite bad, unedited and wasn't proofread. The story ain't enticing either, with confusing timelines. Character Design is annoying, the only redeeming feature is there's a dog. I'm not sure about the updates in the long run, seems good so far. World Background is BS. Vampire wizards? arr you freaking kidding me? If vampires could be wizards then Voldemort could easily solve his immortality problem w/o splitting his soul. Also the most famous curse in HP verse reduced to a magic trick. It's Avada Kedavra, not Avra Kadavra.

altalt

HP: Magic Punk

kamidemond

Liked by 10 people

LIKE

Replies14

Owler
OwlerLv4Owler

It's Leviossaaaaaaaa

Redniro
RedniroLv1Redniro

If werewolves can be wizards why couldn't vampires? Besides according to the harry potter wiki vampires can live up to 200 years away from immortality. Or what do you mean Voldemort could solve his immortality problem?

kamidemond
kamidemondAuthorkamidemond

well I will proof read soon and when it comes to vampire thing, I have explaination but that will happen in the plot

Humbuub
HumbuubLv4Humbuub

you're wrong. Werewolf is a curse, Vampirism is a choice. Your sources are also wrong, J.K. Rowling never expounded vampire lore due to plotholes it would create so it was silently redacted. Just like Time Turners. I mostly read about vampires only on fanfics and can't find any solid canon details about them.

Redniro:If werewolves can be wizards why couldn't vampires? Besides according to the harry potter wiki vampires can live up to 200 years away from immortality. Or what do you mean Voldemort could solve his immortality problem?
Tsumihoshi
TsumihoshiLv4Tsumihoshi

True Vampires, in all Fiction, are always at least unageing as long as they continue to feed on human blood regularly. There are, of course, variations as many as there are stars in the sky, but the foundation of vampirism is blood and immortality. This has always been the case, at least in every single piece of fiction about vampires that I have ever read. It is a plothole in the Canon Universe. If vampirism worked properly in Canon, everyone able would choose to become a Vampire (at least every rich person, as it would be easy for them to procure human blood en masse). Immortality? And all it takes is a bit of human blood a day or perhaps even only once a week? One would be a fool to not take that chance.

Redniro:If werewolves can be wizards why couldn't vampires? Besides according to the harry potter wiki vampires can live up to 200 years away from immortality. Or what do you mean Voldemort could solve his immortality problem?
FinnsRevenge
FinnsRevengeLv4FinnsRevenge

How is vampirism a choice but lycanthropy a curse?

Humbuub:you're wrong. Werewolf is a curse, Vampirism is a choice. Your sources are also wrong, J.K. Rowling never expounded vampire lore due to plotholes it would create so it was silently redacted. Just like Time Turners. I mostly read about vampires only on fanfics and can't find any solid canon details about them.
Humbuub
HumbuubLv4Humbuub

werewolves can't control it, vampires need to feed and kill to turn.

FinnsRevenge:How is vampirism a choice but lycanthropy a curse?
FinnsRevenge
FinnsRevengeLv4FinnsRevenge

Can't control it? Wolfsbane potion. Also Greyback was canonically known for targeting kids while turned, thus there is conscious decision making there. As for feeding and killing to turn? that is unfortunately not confirmed in canon. Even if it was, how many times do you think newly turned vampires would have fed on someone till they died and thus turning them? They're both curses bro

Humbuub:werewolves can't control it, vampires need to feed and kill to turn.
Humbuub
HumbuubLv4Humbuub

Greyback is a Lycan not a werewolf. Wolfsbane potion just make werewolves semi conscious and too expensive, Remus still have to chain himself despite drinking the potion. So you're wrong.

FinnsRevenge:Can't control it? Wolfsbane potion. Also Greyback was canonically known for targeting kids while turned, thus there is conscious decision making there. As for feeding and killing to turn? that is unfortunately not confirmed in canon. Even if it was, how many times do you think newly turned vampires would have fed on someone till they died and thus turning them? They're both curses bro
FinnsRevenge
FinnsRevengeLv4FinnsRevenge

"A Lycan not a werewolf" that's headcanon chief, not sure what gave you the idea there's separate types in harry potter besides maybe fanfiction or some other media

Humbuub:Greyback is a Lycan not a werewolf. Wolfsbane potion just make werewolves semi conscious and too expensive, Remus still have to chain himself despite drinking the potion. So you're wrong.
Humbuub
HumbuubLv4Humbuub

like I said, Rowling never fully dived when it comes to Monster lores. She clearly got the two wrong and made Greyback a Werewolf who could control his transformation while those he bit are infected by Lycanthrophy, aka Lycans.

FinnsRevenge:"A Lycan not a werewolf" that's headcanon chief, not sure what gave you the idea there's separate types in harry potter besides maybe fanfiction or some other media
FinnsRevenge
FinnsRevengeLv4FinnsRevenge

The author of the series got her own character wrong because she didn't stick to your previously established "monster lore" Right, okay.

Humbuub:like I said, Rowling never fully dived when it comes to Monster lores. She clearly got the two wrong and made Greyback a Werewolf who could control his transformation while those he bit are infected by Lycanthrophy, aka Lycans.
Humbuub
HumbuubLv4Humbuub

now you get it.

FinnsRevenge:The author of the series got her own character wrong because she didn't stick to your previously established "monster lore" Right, okay.
image
Ravindra_Shetty
Ravindra_ShettyLv1Ravindra_Shetty

Maybe greyback was a exception not all werewolf can control their transformation and most of the wizarding world discriminates against someone who is turned into a werewolf this happened specifically towards remus even though many students knew for nearly a year but still were afraid of him when they got to know of his werewolf status soo yeahh vampire is better route to take for immortality if they are in the hp universe than werewolf because atleast they can control themself with enough blood not lose control during every full moon

FinnsRevenge:The author of the series got her own character wrong because she didn't stick to your previously established "monster lore" Right, okay.
image