webnovel
WealthyRaccoon
WealthyRaccoonLv145yr
2019-06-13 15:36

Overly reliant on the source material to the point where the presence of the MC amounts to absolutely nothing, so much so that calling this fan fiction is a stretch so exaggerated it pulls your groin thrice over. Author took about 60 chapters to recount the 3rd book (at a bit under 100k words), while the original is a grand total of 107k. This alone isn't an indicator of poor quality but the fact that the only change we get is someone getting torn apart at the end, while the rest remains an almost shot for shot remake. The MCs sole purpose at this point in time seems to be snarky comments and the occasional one liners, only making any form of contribution once it's relevance to the plot has been whittled down to a finite point. Some HP fan fiction goes crazy with ideas like cultivation, dragon animagi and ancient families, but at least all of these stories have tried to inovate upon the source material, while this author is clearly far too comfortable wrapped up in the warm embrace of a pre gay Dumbledore JK Rowling. Vastly over rated and provides almost nothing of substance. Just read the originals again, after all they'll tell the same story.

Liked by 107 people

LIKE
Replies5
CrossArk
CrossArkAuthor

I agree :)

neymar
neymarLv15

I have read all those reviews that sht on your story but i never seen u lose it RESPECT

CrossArk:I agree :)
CrossArk
CrossArkAuthor

Lol, I like to think of myself as modest. ;P

neymar:I have read all those reviews that sht on your story but i never seen u lose it RESPECT
Sandwhich
SandwhichLv4

Why it say no gay but it is gay and also NTR? I am asking serious

CrossArk:Lol, I like to think of myself as modest. ;P
SevenSix
SevenSixLv1

And the man is still waiting 2 years later...

Sandwhich:Why it say no gay but it is gay and also NTR? I am asking serious
Other Reviews
CrossArk
CrossArkAuthor
Related Stories

Reborn as Petunia Evans with a System

Anna Watson’s life was far from easy. A battle with cancer left her frail, defeated, and questioning her life’s meaning. Her final moments were filled with regret for dreams unrealized and paths untaken. But when death embraced her, it wasn’t the end—she awakened in an entirely new world: the wizarding world of Harry Potter. Yet, this wasn’t the familiar era of Harry, Ron, and Hermione. She found herself in the time of the Marauders, a generation before the golden trio. Even more shocking, Anna had a new identity: Petunia Evans, the famously non-magical, bitter sister of Lily Potter. But this Petunia is different. Born as Lily's twin, Anna retains her memories of her past life and discovers she has magic—a shocking divergence from the character she once read about. Her magical abilities open up opportunities and challenges, not only for her but for her relationship with Lily, her new family, and the unfolding story of the wizarding world. As Anna navigates Hogwarts alongside the Marauders, Severus Snape, and her own twin, she realizes that the story she once knew is shifting. Her choices ripple across timelines, altering destinies and alliances. Struggling to reconcile her knowledge of the future with her growing affection for this new life, Anna must decide: should she preserve the world’s fate or carve out a new destiny for herself and those she loves? In this thrilling twist on the Harry Potter universe, the story explores themes of second chances, sibling bonds, and the weight of choice, painting a vivid and detailed picture of what might have been if Petunia Evans had the magic to change it all.

ilo1234 · Book&Literature
Not enough ratings
30 Chs