I don't think so. Novels have the power to transport us to different worlds, make us think, and touch our hearts. However, if expectations are too high or the genre isn't a match, one could have that perception.
Depends on who you ask. Some might find it overrated because it doesn't offer anything groundbreaking. But for others, it's a beloved Christmas classic that brings back fond memories.
I think it depends. There are some amazing Harry Potter fanfictions that add depth to the universe and explore characters in new ways. However, there is also a large portion that is overrated. Some fanfictions go off on wild tangents that don't really fit with the essence of the original series. They might give Harry or other characters abilities that are completely out of character just for the sake of being different, and that's where the overrated aspect comes in.
Well, a great 'critical care FMAB fanfic' is 'A Doctor's Duty'. In this fanfic, the author takes the concept of critical care and applies it to the unique setting of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. It shows how the alchemical world deals with life - threatening situations. 'The ICU of Xerxes' is also interesting. It imagines a scenario where there is a special intensive care unit in the ancient land of Xerxes, and how characters from FMAB are involved. And don't forget 'Critical Care and Alchemy' which combines the idea of medical critical care with the alchemical principles of FMAB.
I think it's because some people expect too much from it. Maybe the hype around it sets unrealistic expectations and when it doesn't meet those, it gets labeled as overrated.
Finally, maintaining a proper power balance among Pokemon is crucial. Writers should base their ideas on the official power levels and evolution rules. If a Pokemon is going to have enhanced powers, there should be a logical explanation within the context of the Pokemon universe, such as a special training regime or a rare item discovery.