Generally speaking, story titles aren't underlined. Different styles like using a different font or color might be employed for distinction, but underlining is not typical.
One great book for a stranded story could be 'Robinson Crusoe'. It's a classic about a man stranded on an island and his struggle for survival. Another option is 'The Martian'. It's about an astronaut stranded on Mars and how he uses his knowledge to stay alive. 'Lord of the Flies' also fits. It tells the story of a group of boys stranded on an island and the chaos that ensues.
'Broken Hearts and Shattered Dreams: A Breakup'. This title clearly shows the emotional turmoil of a breakup with the mention of broken hearts and shattered dreams.
The title 'The Forgotten Book' could lead to a story where a dusty old book is found in an attic. When opened, it transports the reader (or the character who found it) into different worlds or times. It's a journey of discovery through the pages of the forgotten book.