Annabeth could be under some kind of magical influence. In the Percy Jackson universe, there are many magical elements. She could be cursed or charmed without her knowledge. This would be a very interesting take in a fanfiction as it would add an element of mystery and also give her a chance for redemption once the truth is discovered. Also, it could be that she has some internal insecurities that she hasn't dealt with and they manifest in this way, making her act out of character.
It could completely change the dynamic. Percy's trust would be shattered. His character might become more cynical or withdrawn. It could also lead to a new friendship or relationship as he tries to move on.
If Annabeth cheats on Percy in fanfiction, it would shatter the trust that is a fundamental part of their relationship. Their relationship has been through so much together, and this would completely change the dynamic. It could lead to Percy becoming more withdrawn and cynical. He might question his own worth and his ability to judge people. The whole tone of the story would likely become darker and more angsty as Percy struggles to come to terms with the betrayal.
In a large number of Percy and Annabeth fanfictions, they are indeed presented as soulmates. Their shared adventures, the way they understand each other without many words, and the deep loyalty they have for one another all contribute to this perception. Fanfiction authors often build on their existing relationship from the original works and enhance it to the level of soulmates. They might show it through things like Percy being able to sense Annabeth's distress from afar, or Annabeth always knowing exactly what Percy needs in difficult situations. This soulmate - like relationship makes for very engaging and heart - warming stories in the fanfiction realm.
It could be that Annabeth has a misunderstanding about Percy. She might think he's a threat to her position or status at the camp, so she bullies him to try and keep him in check.
It could be Chiron, the centaur. He's always keeping an eye on the campers and would likely be concerned if he caught them up to something. He might give them a stern talking - to and some extra chores as punishment.
Percy might be a bit flustered and embarrassed. He's protective of his relationship with Annabeth, so having Magnus walk in might make him feel like their privacy has been invaded. He could quickly try to shield Annabeth or just look really shocked.
Their shared experiences play a big role. They've been through so much together, like countless battles and adventures. Percy has seen Annabeth in tough situations and he knows how strong she is, but also how vulnerable. So he feels the need to protect her. For instance, they might have had a close call in a previous adventure where Annabeth was nearly killed, and that memory makes Percy extra vigilant.
Their relationship is likely to be complex. They are friends and comrades who have fought side by side many times. So, there's a strong bond of loyalty between them.