Well, you could have a plot where Peter Pan falls in love for the first time. This could completely change his carefree nature as he tries to understand these new feelings. It might also put him at odds with the other lost boys who are used to his non - committal ways. Or perhaps a story where an adult discovers a way to get to Neverland and tries to bring the magic of the place back to the real world, but Peter Pan has to decide if he wants Neverland to be exposed to the outside world's problems.
One plot idea could be a modern - day Peter Pan who discovers the real world has changed a great deal. He has to adapt to technology and new social norms while still maintaining his Neverland spirit. Another could be a story where Peter Pan meets a character from another fairy - tale realm and they go on an adventure together in Neverland. Maybe a girl from a strict, old - fashioned society stows away on his ship and he has to teach her how to have fun and be free.
A great plot idea for Peter Pan fanfiction could be exploring the backstory of Captain Hook. What if there was a time when he was a friend of Peter's and something happened to turn him into the villain? Also, you could write about a group of lost children from different time periods coming together in Neverland. Each child could bring their own unique skills and stories, and they all have to work together with Peter to defend Neverland from a new threat, like a dark magic that's seeping into the island.
A great plot could be a time - travel twist. Peter Pan accidentally travels to the future and discovers that Neverland is in ruins. He then has to work with a group of his future fans who have studied all about him and Neverland to go back in time and fix what went wrong. They find out that Captain Hook made a deal with an evil wizard from another dimension and that's what caused the destruction. Or perhaps there could be a plot where a new character arrives in Neverland who claims to be Peter Pan's long - lost sister. She has different powers than Peter and challenges his leadership, causing a rift among the lost boys.
Here's an interesting plot. In a modern - day setting, Wendy discovers that Peter Pan is real through some ancient family heirloom that has a connection to Neverland. She then finds a way to get to Neverland herself, but it has changed a lot since she was last there. Peter is also different, a bit more jaded. They have to work together to bring back the old magic of Neverland and along the way, they deal with feelings they had buried deep down for each other all those years ago.
One idea could be that Henry discovers a hidden part of Neverland that Peter Pan had forgotten. Maybe it holds the key to a power that can change the fate of both Neverland and Storybrooke. For example, it could be a magical spring that has the power to grant immortality or the ability to rewrite memories.
One idea could be that Wendy discovers a hidden power within herself while in Neverland. Maybe she can communicate with the magical creatures in a way that Peter Pan doesn't understand at first. This new ability could lead to new adventures and a shift in the power dynamics between her and Peter.
One idea could be to have Peter Pan meet characters from other parts of the Once Upon a Time realm in a friendly competition. For instance, a race through the magical forests of Neverland against characters like Alice from Wonderland. This would be a fun and exciting story without any inappropriate content.
One interesting plot twist could be that Hook is actually a long - lost relative of Peter Pan. Maybe they are related through some ancient magic or a family secret that was lost over time. This would completely change their dynamic, from sworn enemies to having a complex family - related relationship.
One plot idea could be that a lost girl in Neverland discovers she has a special power that can break the eternal youth spell on Peter Pan. Another could be a lost girl forming an alliance with the mermaids to find a way back home against Peter Pan's wishes. And a third could be a lost girl trying to rewrite the rules of Neverland to make it a more equal place for all the lost children.
One idea could be that Wendy, after growing up, finds a way back to Neverland but discovers it has changed. Maybe Captain Hook has formed an uneasy alliance with the Lost Boys against a new, greater threat. Another plot could be Wendy's daughter finding Peter Pan's shadow and getting drawn into Neverland, and Peter has to decide whether to let her stay or send her back. Or perhaps Wendy returns to find that Peter has started to age, which is a mystery she has to solve.
One plot idea could be that the OC is a lost girl from another dimension. Peter Pan discovers her and brings her to Neverland. She has unique powers that both fascinate and worry the Lost Boys. Another idea is that the OC is a mermaid who can transform into a human on land. She meets Peter Pan on the shore of Neverland and they embark on adventures together, with her mermaid knowledge helping them in various situations. And a third idea could be that the OC is a fairy who has been banished from her own kind. Peter Pan takes her in and she uses her fairy magic to help him against Captain Hook.
The story is set mainly in Neverland, a magical island full of pirates, fairies, mermaids and lost boys. It also has some parts set in London, where the Darling family lives.