What makes a gangster novel be considered as 'top'?
A 'top' gangster novel is one that can both shock and intrigue the reader. It might shock with its violence and immoral actions, like in 'The Killer Inside Me', but at the same time, it intrigues because it makes you want to understand the motives behind those actions. Characterization is key. The gangsters should be believable and relatable in some way. In 'Get Shorty', the main character's desire to break into Hollywood while still being a mobster makes him an interesting and complex figure. The novel also needs to have a good pacing. It should keep the reader on the edge of their seat, whether it's a slow - burning build - up like in 'The Long Goodbye' or a fast - paced action - packed story like in 'Scarface'.
Well, for a gangster novel to be considered 'top', it usually has a strong sense of atmosphere. The reader should feel like they are in the dark alleys or smoky backrooms where the gangsters operate. Take 'American Tabloid' for instance, it creates a mood of paranoia and secrecy that was characteristic of the era it depicts. Also, the themes explored are important. Themes such as loyalty, betrayal, and the pursuit of power are common in top gangster novels. In 'The Friends of Eddie Coyle', the theme of loyalty among the small - time crooks is central to the story. And of course, the writing style. A vivid and engaging writing style can really bring the gangster world to life.
A top gangster novel often has a complex and engaging plot. For example, it might have multiple storylines that interweave, like in 'The Godfather' where family drama, business deals, and power struggles all come together. It also needs well - developed characters. The gangsters should be more than just one - dimensional villains. In 'Goodfellas', the characters are shown with their loyalties, fears, and desires. Another factor is the authenticity of the setting. If it's set in a particular time and place, like 1920s Chicago in some novels, it should accurately portray the social and cultural aspects of that era.