dark western novel

It isn't a dark BL like I was expecting and so far the concept is pretty interesting. I think instead of having it as reincarnated as an insignificant side character from a dark BL novel a more fitting title would be "Trying to survive in a western fantasy BL novel". The dark part usually will scare people away(and the people expecting a really dark story will be disappointed), and it's transmigration not reincarnation. Transmigration is when a soul takes over an already existing persons body, reincarnation is starting out as a baby. Besides a couple grammar mistakes here and there the story is pretty good.

Throne of the Magical Arcana is a good novel and i would recommend it to anyone who would like more western kind of novels. The story is the highlight of the novel because the mc is smart and does a lot of intriguing actions in the dark while being a musician by day. Sadly all other characters beside a certain girl are just bland and just there even the enemys are your standard enemys who act on order or because of fear. And as for the world you have your standard church = enemy (seriously, like every chinese author must hate the church) The Sorcerer society which is of course the enemy of the church. And the not to be forgotten the nobles, as a novel with western take there must be nobles who sheme in the dark. Honestly the world of this novel is so chinese generic, but the MC and the music part make it worth it. I recommend to give it a try, book 1 is really good.

If you write another novel, Please Please Please, if it western collosal novel then keep it as western novel.. When you write Eastern novel then keep it as Eastern novel.. At first it is Eastern, then become Western.. If other people can enjoy it, but sorry, I can't.. Not because the story is bad.. But Western Tradition is really different from Eastern.. Can you imagine fantasy story about India myth like gods and demons become european or american witch, ghoul, lycans, vampire?? It's about Tradition..

This novel tries, and fails to be "sophisticated". The author attempts to copy Western novels but doesn't understand that readers can just go read that elsewhere. There is no attempt at even mixing Eastern and Western styles of writing (e.g. Lord of the Mysteries), just straight up Western. If I enjoyed reading purely Western style novels so much, I wouldn't be on this platform seeking something different.

qi and blood, yin and yang in a western fantasy? Chinese people really want to occupy all kinds of novel theme like they own it. mixing eastern fantasy element to western element.