webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of WickedWitch in Advent of the Archmage

Review detail

WickedWitch
WickedWitchLv156yrWickedWitch

READ OR RUN?? TRANSLATION QUALITY: Between glaring grammatical errors, names being interchanged and the structure of the novel as a whole, it creates a difficult read. The grammar is ****** which, in theory, should make for an easy and quick read, instead weakeneds the story. The simplistic style highlights all the grammatical mistakes either the author or the translators have made. To be utterly cynical, it makes no sense for there to be as many mistakes as there are due to this being written in a language that is comfortably within the compass of a 10-year-old. They either need to put in more effort, have a new team pick this up or , heck, at this point I will take a freaking editor. All the pLinKesses are making me cringe. I cry bitter hot tears every time I read certain sentences. STABILITY OF UPDATES: Personally, I do not have much of a preference on this. 10 chapters a week is neither a large amount nor a small amount. BUT, there are translators whom push out more chapters a week at a better quality then what we are reading here. If the translation was better I would be more forgiving, but due to simply mistakes I have to give them a poor rating. I am a fan of quality over quantity. STORY DEVELOPMENT: The author needs to learn how to show NOT tell. The entire plot must have been carefully outlined, which makes for an excellent foundation, but fell flat in terms execution. The only details you will get is the author waxing a poetic paragraph over certain beautiful characters' appearance. And the story so far plays out like a paint by numbers or an adventure quide: After reading to chapter 50, I found my attention slipping. I knew that A, B and C would happen and then we would see X result. Then, three chapters later, A, B and C would happen again and then X would, yet again (shocker, I know) be the result. Little to no variation. CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT: And then there is the narration. Because the writing is not enjoyable, the narration, in consequence, is not either. Plus, I feel extremely disconnected from the characters, especially the MC. I find myself not caring about the circumstances he finds himself in because there is no suspense. No chance of failure. Each step in Link's character progression is transparent and, worse yet, dull. But not all is a complete waste, the author appears to have written himself into a corner with the MC's ability, making him too OP early on. To counteract this, he creates a system of magic where just because the MC gains the ability to cast spells does not mean he understands the logic and process behind his magic, placing a decent damper on MC's ability. Unfortunately, this is short lived. The MC gains knowledge and understanding at an alarming rate. If you thought the game system, in which, he could purchase spells (Including Legendary, Hidden, ect.)was an OP ability, you are sorely mistaken. The MC's genius level intellect is in fact his largest cheat skill; gifting him the ability to process, plan and react to situations (some life and death), understand knowledge from the modern world he had difficulty understanding in his previous life and recall all information he so much had glanced at in his previous life (such as the forums). . . Relatable, right. Whatever. Part of what makes s successful fantasy is the reader being able to suspend disbelief. If the MC either possessed the genius level intellect OR the gaming system, not both. Both skills balance each other out and compliment each other TOO well. He has no weakness. No faults. Nothing terribly interesting. WORLD BACKGROUND: I find myself more interested in the world, the MC has been transported to the MC himself. Similar to the MC, the reader is drooped into the middle of the story, unlike the MC though we do not possess years of knowledge from gaming. Very little is explained unless the plot calls for it, then we are treated to an information dump on every single thing they hope will distract you long enough till MC's plot armour activates and Houdinis his way out of whatever situation of the week he has landed himself in. I still have little idea how powerful a level 1 is compared to a level 2 or even to a level 3 or 4. Levels are thrown out like yesterday's underwear and I am left with no proper explanation on how powerful someone really us, not just because they possessed a higher number. FINAL ANALYSIS: Run. I would walk across the desert while eating charcoal briquettes soaked in Tabasco for forty days and forty nights than have to read this novel again.

altalt

Advent of the Archmage

Mo Xiang

Liked by 63 people

LIKE

Replies26

Marvoch
MarvochLv4Marvoch

Sadly, these are glaring issues that many of the works here on Qidian have, the translation quality in particular. Even well-written novels, like those of Mao Ni, are being raped by the translation teams, you can imagine what this can do a novel with inferior contents already /:

Frosch
FroschLv4Frosch

I think it's pretty good \_[0_0]_/

WickedWitch
WickedWitchLv15WickedWitch

To each of their own. I love the concept just not the execution.

Frosch:I think it's pretty good \_[0_0]_/
Kapter
KapterLv4Kapter

indeed

TheOrigin
TheOriginLv10TheOrigin

Dang bro To actually wrote the whole essay in here Gotta respect the noLife man

WickedWitch
WickedWitchLv15WickedWitch

It was either this or homework. You can see which one won 😅

TheOrigin:Dang bro To actually wrote the whole essay in here Gotta respect the noLife man
Nasedra
NasedraLv11Nasedra

Gotta admit it saves us from stuggeling though trash tho.

TheOrigin:Dang bro To actually wrote the whole essay in here Gotta respect the noLife man
UncleKim
UncleKimLv3UncleKim

It is good novel, toooo bad I've stranded to dark side the Dao of MTL and finished this book

Brumenor
BrumenorLv4Brumenor

It is not bad, but is truly a filler fest.. 7-8 chapter were just talking about scrolls.. i mean jeez

Eee_Sss
Eee_SssLv5Eee_Sss

Although your review is quite big ,I find that it expresses my views of this novel completely .I ''abandoned'' this novel without even noticing .

WickedWitch
WickedWitchLv15WickedWitch

To each of their own. Congrats on finishing it though.

UncleKim:It is good novel, toooo bad I've stranded to dark side the Dao of MTL and finished this book
WickedWitch
WickedWitchLv15WickedWitch

Thank you 😊

Eee_Sss:Although your review is quite big ,I find that it expresses my views of this novel completely .I ''abandoned'' this novel without even noticing .
WickedWitch
WickedWitchLv15WickedWitch

I agree with you on the filler fest, snoresville đŸ˜Ș.

Brumenor:It is not bad, but is truly a filler fest.. 7-8 chapter were just talking about scrolls.. i mean jeez
Neilcervantes22
Neilcervantes22Lv4Neilcervantes22

I absulutely agree with you about this novel, you already said what on my mind right now.

Lexthorrr
LexthorrrLv4Lexthorrr

Itlog

FqQiDIEn
FqQiDIEnLv4FqQiDIEn

Yep, the disconnect is definitely there. But I don't particularly blame the translation either, the source author has made me unable to see through the eyes of the MC and that almost never happens. Can agree that this is pretty hard to find enjoyable and I just skipped chapters to see if it got better later on. Spoiler alert, it didn't.

Readingknight
ReadingknightLv4Readingknight

Yes I agreed the mc is too op the translation quality is not too good such as the somehow forget the characters names and just leave it there like there is nothing to worry about, the names of the spells is also much worse like changing the its name purposely to describe its greatness the grammar is that good either like how they translate Speak this is the most common mistake I've seen in most Chinese novel can't they change it with other words the only good thing I like about this story and still read it until now is how the story goes like how the mc change situation close to death and how I correct the grammar myself btw this is the first time I complain a mistake after reading this review

Readingknight
ReadingknightLv4Readingknight

Oh I forgot to put (author) here

Readingknight:Yes I agreed the mc is too op the translation quality is not too good such as the somehow forget the characters names and just leave it there like there is nothing to worry about, the names of the spells is also much worse like changing the its name purposely to describe its greatness the grammar is that good either like how they translate Speak this is the most common mistake I've seen in most Chinese novel can't they change it with other words the only good thing I like about this story and still read it until now is how the story goes like how the mc change situation close to death and how I correct the grammar myself btw this is the first time I complain a mistake after reading this review
Idisgustyoursite
IdisgustyoursiteLv4Idisgustyoursite

my name says it all

GrimarysRsoe
GrimarysRsoeLv10GrimarysRsoe

Indeed