webnovel
Usiel
UsielLv131mth
2024-10-04 18:07

Pure idiocy, excellent trash, king of morons MC. Simp wuss and beta mc. Trusting bumbledork showing of his talents. Befriending the idiotic trio. Going to gryffindor instead of ravens. This sorry excuse of fiction is clearly a translation, a bad one at that.

Liked by 16 people

LIKE
Replies6
LiveandLove
LiveandLoveLv3

Yeah, stop the cap you serial hater

Celestial_Kaiser
Celestial_KaiserLv4

Nah...most of those novels are literally trash, he just like to comment on their trashy-ness. And he ain't completely wrong, this chinese version of harry potter fic is simply leaves a bad taste to HP fans like me. And if you think I'm wrong, then you might wanna try, HP: A magical journey, fic

LiveandLove:Yeah, stop the cap you serial hater
image
Diggo_Fake
Diggo_FakeLv1

I disagree, this guy simply hates any MC that isn't a Villain or evil, and puts most of the stories as trash for that reason. Don't romanticize a guy like this.

Celestial_Kaiser:Nah...most of those novels are literally trash, he just like to comment on their trashy-ness. And he ain't completely wrong, this chinese version of harry potter fic is simply leaves a bad taste to HP fans like me. And if you think I'm wrong, then you might wanna try, HP: A magical journey, fic
Celestial_Kaiser
Celestial_KaiserLv4

Well I was only talking about those visible in the picture. I don't know if that guy hates good ones too .

Diggo_Fake:I disagree, this guy simply hates any MC that isn't a Villain or evil, and puts most of the stories as trash for that reason. Don't romanticize a guy like this.
Andora_000
Andora_000Lv1

as the guy above said, he's right. About the villain, many people like to read villains because they are often smart and use their heads. And as for this fanfic, I would give it 2 stars. In my opinion, the disadvantages are: it seems to me that the dialogues are not connected, the fact that he reveals his ability to predict (he must have a hidden trump card and there is little chance that anyone will find out about his ability), the way he laughs when he first meets Hermione (I did not see anything funny in this where you can laugh), the way he reacts to the warning for thieves in Gringots (the bank that he should open the safes and invite everyone to rob him). This fanfic has potential, but it needs to be rewritten.

Diggo_Fake:I disagree, this guy simply hates any MC that isn't a Villain or evil, and puts most of the stories as trash for that reason. Don't romanticize a guy like this.
Diggo_Fake
Diggo_FakeLv1

It's not that. I wasn't giving my opinion on whether the fic was good or not, but rather on the parameters this guy uses to classify it.

Andora_000:as the guy above said, he's right. About the villain, many people like to read villains because they are often smart and use their heads. And as for this fanfic, I would give it 2 stars. In my opinion, the disadvantages are: it seems to me that the dialogues are not connected, the fact that he reveals his ability to predict (he must have a hidden trump card and there is little chance that anyone will find out about his ability), the way he laughs when he first meets Hermione (I did not see anything funny in this where you can laugh), the way he reacts to the warning for thieves in Gringots (the bank that he should open the safes and invite everyone to rob him). This fanfic has potential, but it needs to be rewritten.
Other Reviews
Yesnth
YesnthLv4

Y'know, I went into this expecting nothing. But damn did I get hooked. This story is one of the few that captivates you and pulls you in. It captures the feel of the Harry Potter books perfectly in how magical everything seems. Although this is a translated work, it does not change that it is a work that needs to be appreciated. The Writing quality, or better yet, translation quality is impeccable. you can't even tell its a translated work unless something really particular pops up. The story development is great. although hard to stick to in the first 10 chapters, when it gets rolling, oh it gets rolling. I couldn't even tell how fast I read through this and when I reached the end it left me craving for more. The Characters are very nicely interpreted. all of them capture the Essence of the originals and even the side characters feel like they're alive. although sometimes it may feel like the side characters glaze the Mc too much, that's just part of the fun and is framed as being perfectly logical. The updating stability is good. not much to say about it. There is a chapter every day. As for the World Background, this is literally the only Harry Potter fanfic I've read that takes many elements from the books too. Everyone else just watches the movies and calls it a day in terms of research. this is very well fletched out and the gaps in knowledge are allowed to be filled in by the author. all in all, 5/5. One of the best, if not the best fanfics, I've read on the platform. It simply draws you in and doesn't let go. would recommended.

Related Stories