webnovel
humpedumpe
humpedumpeLv151yr
2023-08-16 12:14

i dont agree with the negative reviews, it is a good story, what more can i say. so troll dont give negative review, it is worth the read

Liked by 4 people

LIKE
Replies3
LittleMonkey
LittleMonkeyLv14

These aren't troll reviews, but legit bad ones with purpose.Either the author lacks basic knowledge or, in the case of the translator, basic english skills. Example: they claimed in the first chapter that the n-word written with double g, as in the slur to be the latin word for black (which it is if written with only one g). This ain't a small spelling mistake. This is plain stupid. I would double and tripple check before writing something like that. But it's not only spelling. There are many concepts that are NOT from Harry Potter, which aren't explained in any way or shape. In fanfiction, you dont need to explain the source material, but everything out of a source needs a basic explanation or a description. Otherwise, nobody knows what's going on. This fact alone makes writing fanfiction easy because even if it's badly written, everyone knows the source and, therefore, the gist of the plot. Many authors, however, overestimate themselves by adding bad AU plot, OCs, and new magic systems without properly explaining or developing them. These are the really bad fictions, as it's in this case.The premise of the story might have potential, but it's not achieved due to faulty language and poorly intruduced plot points.

Bob_Uchiha_XD
Bob_Uchiha_XDLv4

Mehhh The fanfic is MTL (chinese novel fanfic)....

Duke_of_Insanity
Duke_of_InsanityLv14

too bad your opinion doesn't matter

Other Reviews
Related Stories

Reborn as Petunia Evans with a System

Anna Watson’s life was far from easy. A battle with cancer left her frail, defeated, and questioning her life’s meaning. Her final moments were filled with regret for dreams unrealized and paths untaken. But when death embraced her, it wasn’t the end—she awakened in an entirely new world: the wizarding world of Harry Potter. Yet, this wasn’t the familiar era of Harry, Ron, and Hermione. She found herself in the time of the Marauders, a generation before the golden trio. Even more shocking, Anna had a new identity: Petunia Evans, the famously non-magical, bitter sister of Lily Potter. But this Petunia is different. Born as Lily's twin, Anna retains her memories of her past life and discovers she has magic—a shocking divergence from the character she once read about. Her magical abilities open up opportunities and challenges, not only for her but for her relationship with Lily, her new family, and the unfolding story of the wizarding world. As Anna navigates Hogwarts alongside the Marauders, Severus Snape, and her own twin, she realizes that the story she once knew is shifting. Her choices ripple across timelines, altering destinies and alliances. Struggling to reconcile her knowledge of the future with her growing affection for this new life, Anna must decide: should she preserve the world’s fate or carve out a new destiny for herself and those she loves? In this thrilling twist on the Harry Potter universe, the story explores themes of second chances, sibling bonds, and the weight of choice, painting a vivid and detailed picture of what might have been if Petunia Evans had the magic to change it all.

ruokay2210 · Book&Literature
4.4
64 Chs