webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of dns7950 in The Magical Blacksmith

Review detail

dns7950
dns7950Lv103yrdns7950

I keep wishing for a good blacksmithing novel, unfortunately this is not it. Never thought it was possible, but it may actually be worse than Forging The Path To Godliness. It's just plain bad, ******* writing that seems like it was written by a child. Predictable and cliched. Seems like something you would expect to find in RoyalRoad, in fact there are definitely better stories there. Absolutely not worth translating at all, so I suppose it's only a matter of time before this gets picked as Editors Choice over much, much better novels like "I just won't play by the book" and "My Debauched Devotion". After seeing Forging the Path To Godliness get chosen over "I Can See The Lines Of Fortune, it's really obvious that the readers opinion and reviews don't matter at all, and the "editor" who chooses the novels is a brainless moron.

altalt

The Magical Blacksmith

Time Seaweed

Liked by 55 people

LIKE

Replies19

wryyyyy
wryyyyyLv5wryyyyy

It was meh at first, then garbage several chapters later.

dns7950:It was better than most of the trial reads we see, including many that get chosen to be translated. It was about a million times better than FTPTG
DaarkSun
DaarkSunLv13DaarkSun

search for magic smithing on royal road

SavageGamer
SavageGamerLv13SavageGamer

but I can see the lines of fortune was garbage 🗑️....

dns7950
dns7950Lv10dns7950

It was better than most of the trial reads we see, including many that get chosen to be translated. It was about a million times better than FTPTG

RexHarris
RexHarrisLv13RexHarris

Great novel just read newest chapter

DaarkSun:search for magic smithing on royal road
RexHarris
RexHarrisLv13RexHarris

Kinda dumb comment about Royal Road though, not saying its filled with great works but it does have fair amount of good novels.

Lorus03
Lorus03Lv4Lorus03

Actually "I can see the lines of fortune" is on haitus. That may be the reason they didn't picked it.

Usagi_mofu
Usagi_mofuLv11Usagi_mofu

So uhh...... Reader opinion and review indeed doesn't matter BECAUSE the one novel with the MOST coins spent on per reader (So, how many people at least spent coins on one chapter) will be chosen. With that information you can see that people who uses coins are certainly retarded, not all of them, but a vast majority.

Tim_Ber
Tim_BerLv13Tim_Ber

what if the author itself who donates his own coins in many accounts? 😂

Usagi_mofu:So uhh...... Reader opinion and review indeed doesn't matter BECAUSE the one novel with the MOST coins spent on per reader (So, how many people at least spent coins on one chapter) will be chosen. With that information you can see that people who uses coins are certainly retarded, not all of them, but a vast majority.
Vinayak_
Vinayak_Lv12Vinayak_

Was about to try it, but ince you said that its worse than Forging the Path to Godliness, immediately stopped myself. And I cannot agree more, that novel was just so plain and boring and shallow, that I too thought that it’d be tough for said novel to be beaten in above three fields. Even the thought of another novel being as bad or worse than that makes me wanna never read it. Thank you for your noble sacrifice.

LordInsanity
LordInsanityLv5LordInsanity

plot twist, editor is actually the ceo of webnovel

Oto
OtoLv14Oto

If you actually believe this you are an idiot. Why don’t they show the coins spent? Becuase there is something to hide. You’re trying to tell me that the 3.3 rated novels get picked over the 4.8 ones? As if people spend more coins on the former. Get your shill ass out of here. You are fooling no one.

Usagi_mofu:So uhh...... Reader opinion and review indeed doesn't matter BECAUSE the one novel with the MOST coins spent on per reader (So, how many people at least spent coins on one chapter) will be chosen. With that information you can see that people who uses coins are certainly retarded, not all of them, but a vast majority.
Tyrannical_Book
Tyrannical_BookLv3Tyrannical_Book

I always check and read on royalroad there's great novels like Mother of learning, Beware of chicken, there's no loot only pun, vainqueur the dragon, the iron teeth tale of a goblin many others

Tyrannical_Book
Tyrannical_BookLv3Tyrannical_Book

saying like all Royalroad novels are clichĂŠ and predictable insults to those great novels

Cat_King
Cat_KingLv5Cat_King

Not all royalroad stories are bad. There’s absolutely great stories there. Forge of Destiny is a good cultivation novel and there’s other great ones if you just pause to read them.

HolyDragon17
HolyDragon17Lv4HolyDragon17

I read raws for "I Just Won't Play By The Book"/"My Debauched Devotion" and trust me they suck (no proper outline) but sigh I guess that's how most CNs are I guess

nyc_broy
nyc_broyLv11nyc_broy

While was it last week? Or 2 weeks ago, a 3.7 rated novel got picked but don't focus on that. See the fan section, see how the max for the contributed is 240. What if I told you that's how many [img=coins] it takes to unlock all the paid chapters? Now you can do the math yourself, believe me, or be ignorant. FYI, $4.99 = 250 [img=coins], so to frame it another way, the novel that makes the most money gets selected.

Oto:If you actually believe this you are an idiot. Why don’t they show the coins spent? Becuase there is something to hide. You’re trying to tell me that the 3.3 rated novels get picked over the 4.8 ones? As if people spend more coins on the former. Get your shill ass out of here. You are fooling no one.
Darcksage
DarcksageLv11Darcksage

doesn't exist

DaarkSun:search for magic smithing on royal road
Mrmonste_Thul
Mrmonste_ThulLv12Mrmonste_Thul

If your looking for a decent blacksmithing novel I would recomend Spirit Blacksmith(?) Its definetly not your average blacksmith novel. After about 60 chaps or so he leaves his home world which was kinda a let down so im hoping he goes back some time.