webnovel
Precheur
PrecheurLv53yr
2021-01-31 21:15

Bro this character design... MC is acting like a 14yo with his brother, i hate it, act like a fucking ***** moron. Your brother is a little prick ? Then you teach him, you help him, that's what a brother do, that's what an ***** do, you help him get better. Robert may be a little shit, but MC is no better, letting things go wrong with his brother without doing anything just laughting at him. I can already tell where it's going and i hate it. OF COURSE you have to make robert a bad guy in every point, otherwise how could you take the power from him. OF COURSE, because the MC is in the good people side right, he is a good person, so he can't betray someone good to get to power right, it would make him nuanced and that's not what we want. Let's stay with the manichean view of the world, good side, bad side that's it.

Liked by 16 people

LIKE
Replies4
GNaNA
GNaNAAuthor

If you would read the entrance of chapter 31 you would understand. I also wanted to tell you that I treat Edward with his mental age in Game of Thrones, not with both lives. All he got from his previous life was the knowledge and his goal to be the king. So he would live by the world's rules. He is now a teenager so he would be confused with a lot of twisting ideas. I respect your opinion, bro. I am no saint and mistakes happen. If you don't like it, don't make it worsen your day and enjoy.

Precheur
PrecheurLv5

It's far too confusing him having knowledge, isn't knowing your name knowledge ? Knowing the history of got knowledge ? Then what's not knowledge ? How could he only have lost his personnal knowledge ? This is far too confusing. Also him having knowledge should make him more mature, that's what make us sage. You know from experience that this is good or this is bad, that this is the way you should act or not, knowledge is maturity.

GNaNA:If you would read the entrance of chapter 31 you would understand. I also wanted to tell you that I treat Edward with his mental age in Game of Thrones, not with both lives. All he got from his previous life was the knowledge and his goal to be the king. So he would live by the world's rules. He is now a teenager so he would be confused with a lot of twisting ideas. I respect your opinion, bro. I am no saint and mistakes happen. If you don't like it, don't make it worsen your day and enjoy.
image
GNaNA
GNaNAAuthor

I said in the first chapter that he only remembered the knowledge in his previous life. He did not remember any events nor his name. He forgot everything. As for knowing the knowledge would help you mature, that is absolutely wrong. I had seen many smart children that could learn to high school knowledge while they still behave as ten-year children. It is about the social IQ, not the knowledge.

Precheur:It's far too confusing him having knowledge, isn't knowing your name knowledge ? Knowing the history of got knowledge ? Then what's not knowledge ? How could he only have lost his personnal knowledge ? This is far too confusing. Also him having knowledge should make him more mature, that's what make us sage. You know from experience that this is good or this is bad, that this is the way you should act or not, knowledge is maturity.
Long_Live_The_King
Long_Live_The_KingLv3

100% True

GNaNA:I said in the first chapter that he only remembered the knowledge in his previous life. He did not remember any events nor his name. He forgot everything. As for knowing the knowledge would help you mature, that is absolutely wrong. I had seen many smart children that could learn to high school knowledge while they still behave as ten-year children. It is about the social IQ, not the knowledge.
Other Reviews
OukisLips
OukisLipsLv15

Writing Quality: 2 stars ---Decent grammar and spelling (relative to this site, not even close to professional grade though). However, the author uses many terms that simply aren't used in Game of Thrones, such as "hey." Stability of Updates: 5 stars ---The stability of updates is rather good. There's a bit of a lull during the holidays but otherwise it's very consistent at the time of this review. Story Development: 3 stars ---Nothing much to say here. The story is only 9 chapters in, and the story development is pretty standard for a Game of Thrones fanfiction Character Design: 1 star ---The main character is ok. However, every other character is essentially just an NPC, with no other reason for being other than granting the MC's ridiculous requests. --- 5 year old MC: "Father, give me a 1,000 soldiers and trainees to use as I wish with no oversight!" --- MC's father: "Sure son, no problem. Anything else I can do for you today?" --- MC: "Yeah, give me some children to brainwash to be loyal to me, despite me not being the heir." ----MC's father: "Sure son, no problem. Anything else I can do for you today?" ---I'm not even exaggerating this. This is essentially how the conversation was written in the story. World Background: 1 star ---Like I mentioned before, some of the words used in dialogue is incongruous with the Game of Thrones setting. Then there's things like the MC dual wielding two great-swords despite not having any enhanced strength. A lot of the small details in this story are incredibly ridiculous and simply don't fit with the setting. And the large details were created by GRRM, so I don't really consider them while rating this story. Thus, one star for world background

TrueImmortal
TrueImmortalLv6

This review is gonna be very harsh. This story is so ridiculously stupid that i actually laugh out loud sometimes at its stupidity. Everything and i mean EVERYTHING goes the Mc way for no reason at all, literally nothing happens that doesn't benefit him immensely. Also the Mc is for some reason this ultimate badass so much so that Tywin freaking Lannister is afraid of him for no damn reason. There are a lot of stuff that i could complain about like him becoming the lord of Stormlands which would NEVER happen since he is not the oldest, westeros rules are very strict in that regard, or him somehow (by somehow i mean in a way that would never work) making the Stormlands extremely rich, the richest actually, in a laughably short amout of time (he is making MILLIONS of gold in pure profit every month) but let's focus on the recent ones. During the rebellion he negotiates a deal so ridiculous that even if i try to read this ff with my brain shut off the sheer amount of stupidity shocks it back on. He tells Jon Arryn that he will only join the rebellion if after it's success they will recognize Stormlands as an independent kingdom lol. But as ridiculous as that is it doesn't end there, he also demands a HUGE portion of Targaryen gold like half or something hahaha. If you thought he was done you are wrong, he also demands that all the lands he takes over will belong to his new kingdom. Do i have to even explain why everything he demands is literally Impossible? But of course just like everything else all goes his way. You know what, i will give a few reasons why it would not work just in case some idiot thinks this will work For example: when Aegon Conquered westeros he appointed great houses as Lord Paramounts and gave them the authority to reign within their region as they see fit, as long as they pay taxes and follow the Kings Laws of course. Now why did he do it? Becouse he wasn't stupid enough to think that noble houses that followed and served the great houses for THOUSANDS OF YEARS would simply abandon them and be loyal to his house from that point on. So if Edward (the Mc) takes over some of the Reaches lands, one third in fact lol, the noble houses in that region would never be loyal to him. Their loyalty will remain with their Liege lords and/or the House that they're sworn to. The House Tyrell struggled and still Struggles to gain their loyalty for now 300 years. And the only reason why they had some success is because they would marry in to those houses like Olenna frome the Redwynes or Mace wife from House Hightower. Also why the Tyrells were so obsessed with having marriage ties wit royal family to strengthen their hold on the Reach. Also a perfect example would be some Houses in crownlands don't pay taxes and when tax collectors are send to them, they either don't return or only a small number makes it back with only a portion of the taxes.

Sculp
SculpLv12
Drakknml
DrakknmlLv3
Related Stories