webnovel
Spelloyal
SpelloyalLv124yr
2020-11-28 15:15

It's a good fanfic, but it has a very annoying flaw that prevents me from giving it 5 stars. From time to time it seems that the author is too lazy to write or something and just edits the original material. Nie Li has been having so much presence that he is becoming the MC of the fanfic. Scenes like the alchemist exam by Nie Li that should be summarized or skipped are being copied and pasted in full in this fic and this kind of creates redundant chapters for those who read the original material. This fic seems to be more about the changes that the presence of Tatsuya and Miyuki cause Nie Li rather than about them in TDG (Sorry for any erros, i used google translator)

Liked by 34 people

LIKE
Replies5
jeanpierregerardo
jeanpierregerardoLv5

Thanks to your review, I save myself from reading something repetitive, I thought it would be something different, but if I only send them to be assistants of "nieli" it is not my thing, I thought it would be focused on miyuki and tatsuya while they get stronger, but If it's like you say, then it's a big "No."

Spelloyal
SpelloyalLv12

I would say that there is still hope for this novel, the chapters before Nie Li were very good and the author apparently does not intend to continue like this. Giving the benefit of the doubt I recommend to wait a few more chapters to see if it improves before completely abandoning the idea of reading this fanfic.

jeanpierregerardo:Thanks to your review, I save myself from reading something repetitive, I thought it would be something different, but if I only send them to be assistants of "nieli" it is not my thing, I thought it would be focused on miyuki and tatsuya while they get stronger, but If it's like you say, then it's a big "No."
LostThe50_50
LostThe50_50Lv6

so....did it improve?

Spelloyal:I would say that there is still hope for this novel, the chapters before Nie Li were very good and the author apparently does not intend to continue like this. Giving the benefit of the doubt I recommend to wait a few more chapters to see if it improves before completely abandoning the idea of reading this fanfic.
EternalAnxiety
EternalAnxietyLv13

So did it?

Spelloyal:I would say that there is still hope for this novel, the chapters before Nie Li were very good and the author apparently does not intend to continue like this. Giving the benefit of the doubt I recommend to wait a few more chapters to see if it improves before completely abandoning the idea of reading this fanfic.
Izayori_Em
Izayori_EmLv14

I'm around the 60s and while they don't play the supporting role anymore it seems to still be following the same settings as the original with some extra added

LostThe50_50:so....did it improve?
Other Reviews
Related Stories