webnovel
Wallabalooza
WallabaloozaLv34yr
2020-03-12 18:07

There are quite a few issues with this story. First and foremost is how absolutely slowly it moves. By chapter 20, the story has barely even begun, and it took about 11 chapters to reach what should have essentially been the first. This feels like a result of you going into extreme detail about backstory and world building before even giving the reader a chance to care about your characters. These are things that should have been introduced gradually, and less forcefully, as the story progressed, not all at once at the beginning. You also have a tendency to over explain things a lot. This not only takes up 200+% more words than you need to, it gets very tiring to read. The grammar is okay, but not great. You use "!!!!" and "???" and chatroom-like syntax, and it makes your story come off as if written by an overly excited teenage girl (which may be the case, I don't know). Your dialogue tends to be heavy eye-roll material as you often use it for exposition, making your characters come off as robotic and unrealistic. Backstory should not be forced into dialogue. It kills a story. And you've done that /a lot/ in yours, and right from the start as well. You've got a few interesting ideas and some potential, but the way you write seriously needs an overhaul. Spend a little time reading better written works, see how they do things and try to reach where you are at Ch20 in 2-4 chapters instead. Good luck.

Liked by 52 people

LIKE
Replies11
Ronaldo_Caouna
Ronaldo_CaounaLv2

"...how absolutely slowly it moves" .. there are way more stories out there that crawl even slower. "...detail about backstory and world building...not all at once at the beginning" .... its good and appropriately done. Maybe you r the type that don't care about background and just like info dumps once in a while every 100 chapters or so. ".. tendency to over explain things ..:" ...there are way many more authors out there who do even more bs explaining then done here. "..grammar is okay, but not great.." ...did you perhaps secure the highest marks in your class in english? "...written by an overly excited teenage girl " ..well ok grandpa you can move on to the next life. "....reach where you are at Ch20 in 2-4 chapters " ..what hilariousness? this is a web novel not a Jane Austin classic. What you are suggesting is for the author to go full time into writing and book publishing.

Felix_Neros
Felix_NerosLv13

“Murderers are bad.” “But pedos are worse, your argument is thus null and void.” 👌👏👏👏👏

Ronaldo_Caouna:"...how absolutely slowly it moves" .. there are way more stories out there that crawl even slower. "...detail about backstory and world building...not all at once at the beginning" .... its good and appropriately done. Maybe you r the type that don't care about background and just like info dumps once in a while every 100 chapters or so. ".. tendency to over explain things ..:" ...there are way many more authors out there who do even more bs explaining then done here. "..grammar is okay, but not great.." ...did you perhaps secure the highest marks in your class in english? "...written by an overly excited teenage girl " ..well ok grandpa you can move on to the next life. "....reach where you are at Ch20 in 2-4 chapters " ..what hilariousness? this is a web novel not a Jane Austin classic. What you are suggesting is for the author to go full time into writing and book publishing.
CamilleDirithyl
CamilleDirithylLv10

Why are you attacking the commentvof Wallabolazo? It is justified in addition to being usefully constructed. As a reader you may not know it, but for an author the lack of negative reviews is a terrible thing, as these are chances to see what we as an author have not seen. The positive reviews are encouraging, but in truth they are only cancers for the improvement of a story. And I agree with what he says. These things make reading unpleasant, and it's not that hard to fix them once you know it. Good luck author

Nurofae
NurofaeLv10

Very well writen review👌

galalijan
galalijanLv13

Thanks for this review. I always look for a positive and negative review with substance before reading a novel, and this is one of the most constructive I’ve seen. keep it up sir!

Primordial_Phoenix
Primordial_PhoenixLv10

Here's a question dear reviewer will I need to read rise of a demon god to understand this story or can I just read this and then read rise of the demon god if I like this one

Demonic_angel
Demonic_angelAuthor

You can start with this one without reading that,

Primordial_Phoenix:Here's a question dear reviewer will I need to read rise of a demon god to understand this story or can I just read this and then read rise of the demon god if I like this one
Demonic_angel
Demonic_angelAuthor

In 20 chaps, I've written the backstory, his death, his rebirth, his meeting his new family, his getting adopted, his learning skills, his going in a coma, his walking up, his powers awakening. I personally believe that some things need time, you can say that it's slow, but if I did it all in 2-4 chapters, there will be someone saying that it was too rushed.

Primordial_Phoenix:Here's a question dear reviewer will I need to read rise of a demon god to understand this story or can I just read this and then read rise of the demon god if I like this one
Venom_God
Venom_GodLv12

Worst argument ever🤣

Ronaldo_Caouna:"...how absolutely slowly it moves" .. there are way more stories out there that crawl even slower. "...detail about backstory and world building...not all at once at the beginning" .... its good and appropriately done. Maybe you r the type that don't care about background and just like info dumps once in a while every 100 chapters or so. ".. tendency to over explain things ..:" ...there are way many more authors out there who do even more bs explaining then done here. "..grammar is okay, but not great.." ...did you perhaps secure the highest marks in your class in english? "...written by an overly excited teenage girl " ..well ok grandpa you can move on to the next life. "....reach where you are at Ch20 in 2-4 chapters " ..what hilariousness? this is a web novel not a Jane Austin classic. What you are suggesting is for the author to go full time into writing and book publishing.
kloudybae
kloudybaeLv3

you just dismissed constructive criticism with "OtHeRs Do ThAt ToO"... idiot.

Ronaldo_Caouna:"...how absolutely slowly it moves" .. there are way more stories out there that crawl even slower. "...detail about backstory and world building...not all at once at the beginning" .... its good and appropriately done. Maybe you r the type that don't care about background and just like info dumps once in a while every 100 chapters or so. ".. tendency to over explain things ..:" ...there are way many more authors out there who do even more bs explaining then done here. "..grammar is okay, but not great.." ...did you perhaps secure the highest marks in your class in english? "...written by an overly excited teenage girl " ..well ok grandpa you can move on to the next life. "....reach where you are at Ch20 in 2-4 chapters " ..what hilariousness? this is a web novel not a Jane Austin classic. What you are suggesting is for the author to go full time into writing and book publishing.
User177785
User177785Lv12

Your argument is comparing him to other authors. That doesn't make sense as just because other authors do it, it doesn't make it right nor does it give the reader enjoyment.

Ronaldo_Caouna:"...how absolutely slowly it moves" .. there are way more stories out there that crawl even slower. "...detail about backstory and world building...not all at once at the beginning" .... its good and appropriately done. Maybe you r the type that don't care about background and just like info dumps once in a while every 100 chapters or so. ".. tendency to over explain things ..:" ...there are way many more authors out there who do even more bs explaining then done here. "..grammar is okay, but not great.." ...did you perhaps secure the highest marks in your class in english? "...written by an overly excited teenage girl " ..well ok grandpa you can move on to the next life. "....reach where you are at Ch20 in 2-4 chapters " ..what hilariousness? this is a web novel not a Jane Austin classic. What you are suggesting is for the author to go full time into writing and book publishing.
Other Reviews
AsunaKaoru
AsunaKaoruLv13
Demonic_angel
Demonic_angelAuthor
Jhone_K
Jhone_KLv10
Related Stories

Steadily becoming a saint, the immortal officials hired me to tend the horses

The latest novel by the author of 'I Became An Immortal On Mortal Realm', Let me laugh, the author you will never be disappointed with, enjoy to your heart's content!!! ------------- Author's message to webnovel readers: It has come as an unexpected delight that Xianxia novels, a genre unique to China, have been warmly received by an international audience. I sincerely thank everyone for their support. I am committed to considering all the valuable suggestions put forth by readers, and to maintaining the style you have all come to love, all the while striving to continue delivering my best work. The book "Steadily Becoming a Saint, The Immortal Officials Hired Me to Tend the Horses" retains the familiar style of my previous works but ventures into entirely new territory with its plot and world-building. This story will reflect mortal aspirations for eternal life and ascension to immortality, as well as portray the epic tale of celestial beings witnessing the evolution of the universe through the ages. I hope you will all enjoy it. Best regards. by Let me laugh ------------- As a house servant, Gu An accidentally shattered a jar of Spirit Flowers in his youth, and in his panic, he discovered that he had seized twelve years of life span! A path to immortality thus unfolded before Gu An's eyes! In order to cultivate in peace, Gu An chose to become a Servant Disciple of the Supreme Sect, planting medicinal herbs daily to cultivate by seizing the life span of these herbs. Through the evolution of life span, his Basic Skill constantly evolved, deducing from Basic Sorcery to reach Divine Skills that connected to heaven! Eras changed, constellations shifted, and the Mortal World transformed vastly. Gradually, legends of immortals emerged in the Mortal World. The immortal known as Gu An expended half of his life span, helping his Cultivation Level break through the limits of the Immortal Path and achieving the realm of a Saint, soaring above the heavenly laws. However, one day, a white-robed old man with a saintly presence came to visit Gu An. "I am Xuan Qing from the Heavenly Stars above, appointed by the Heavenly Emperor Tai Hao. Hearing of Daoist Friend's numerous benevolent deeds in the Mortal World and your countless rescues of the living beings here, the merits are immeasurable. Thus, I have been dispatched from the Lower Realm to invite Daoist Friend to join the ranks of the immortals, to take up an immortal office, the Divine Steed Celestial Official." "May I ask what the duties of the Divine Steed Celestial Official are?" "In the Heavenly Court, there are divine steeds that can traverse earth and heaven and penetrate Yin Yang. The Divine Steed Celestial Official is responsible for looking after and feeding these divine steeds." Huh? Taking care of horses? Groom?!

Let me laugh · Eastern
4.6
280 Chs