Chapter 29: Coulson’s Dilemma
Agent Phil Coulson walked down the corridors of the S.H.I.E.L.D. office with his usual measured stride, clipboard in hand. His face remained calm, collected, as it always was in front of other agents. The discussions he'd had with Fury earlier about Alex Winters lingered in his mind. He didn't show it, but there was a growing unease bubbling under the surface.
Alex wasn't supposed to be a problem. He was just a guy—another face in the crowd trying to survive in the chaos that New York City had become ever since the world realized superheroes weren't just comic book fantasies. But as Fury had pointed out, there were things about Alex that didn't add up.
Coulson's mind wandered back to the Hydra case. Alex had come onto his radar purely by accident during one of S.H.I.E.L.D.'s clean-up operations. Hydra had been all but decimated, but there were still remnants hiding in the cracks, and it was during an investigation into one such pocket of agents that Alex had first crossed paths with Coulson. Nothing particularly notable had stood out about the kid at the time—he was quiet, a bit out of place in the midst of chaos, but who wasn't?
It had been small moments, though—tiny things. Alex had this odd way of knowing just where not to be during a skirmish, as if he had a sixth sense for trouble. He'd always kept his head down, but something about the way he moved, the way he observed, felt deliberate. Calculated. Coulson noticed things like that, and despite his easygoing manner, he never forgot.
In those moments, Coulson had chalked it up to gut instinct—a skill a lot of civilians developed just by living in New York. But now that Fury was looking into him more closely, Coulson couldn't help but revisit those past interactions. He'd met Alex a few times since then, mostly in passing, during other investigations. Alex was always polite, a bit awkward but genuine. They'd shared a few casual conversations, nothing deep, but it had been enough for Coulson to develop a mild acquaintance with the guy.
And now? Now he was supposed to view him as a potential threat.
The thought bothered Coulson more than he'd expected.
As he entered one of the quieter sections of the helicarrier, he took a moment to pause near the observation deck, staring out at the vast ocean below. The setting sun painted the sky in hues of orange and pink, and for a brief moment, the world seemed peaceful. Deceptively peaceful.
Coulson sighed, running a hand over the back of his neck. The truth was, Fury was rarely wrong. If the Director had a hunch about someone, it usually meant there was something there. Coulson respected Fury's instincts more than anyone. But this situation with Alex felt...off. Alex didn't strike him as a villain, or even someone capable of causing serious harm. Sure, there were gaps in his background, but New York was full of people trying to hide from their pasts. Not every secret had to mean something sinister.
But then again, this wasn't just any world—they weren't just any agency. In a world where gods descended from the skies and men turned into monsters, no one was ever truly ordinary.
The soft hum of approaching footsteps caught his attention. One of the junior agents, barely out of training, stood a few paces away, uncertain whether to disturb him.
"Agent Coulson, sir?" she asked hesitantly.
Coulson turned to her with his usual affable smile. "What can I do for you?"
"There's been a report. Nothing urgent, just wanted to keep you updated on the ongoing Hydra surveillance," she said, handing him a small tablet. "Also, Director Fury wanted me to remind you about the surveillance arrangements on Mr. Winters."
"Thanks," Coulson said, taking the tablet from her. "I'll look into it."
As she left, Coulson's eyes fell back to the tablet, displaying the surveillance schedule for Alex. He flipped through the logs, noting the increased attention on Alex's movements—where he went, what he did, who he interacted with. The reports were thorough but impersonal, the way S.H.I.E.L.D. operated when they had their sights on someone.
He hated this part of the job. Keeping tabs on people who might not deserve it. But that was the thing about S.H.I.E.L.D.—they didn't operate on maybes or feelings. They acted on potential threats, and potential was a dangerous word in their line of work.
Still, a part of Coulson resisted. He liked Alex. He didn't want to believe the guy could be wrapped up in something dangerous. But he'd seen too much to ignore the possibility. After all, Ward had been a good guy, too. Or at least, that's what everyone had thought. But Ward had turned out to be Hydra—deeply, irreversibly Hydra—and Coulson had been blindsided by that betrayal. The memory still left a bitter taste in his mouth.
Was Alex hiding something as dangerous? Could he turn out to be a wolf in sheep's clothing, just like Ward had been?
Coulson tapped the screen of the tablet, flipping through more reports. Alex had been delivering pizzas lately, of all things. Just a regular guy working a low-key job, probably trying to stay under the radar. But something about that bothered Coulson too. For a guy who was being so carefully watched, Alex hadn't put up any resistance, no signs of awareness that he was under surveillance.
Either Alex was the best actor Coulson had ever seen, or there was more to him than they realized.
His thoughts were interrupted by the beeping of an incoming message. It was from Fury.
Keep an eye on him. Don't let your guard down.
Coulson frowned. It was rare for Fury to micromanage a case, especially one this small. That only added to the weight on his shoulders. Fury trusted him to handle the situation, but the underlying message was clear: Don't let this one slip through the cracks.
The thought nagged at him. What if Alex really was dangerous? What if he turned out to be more like Ward than Coulson wanted to believe? The idea made him sick, but he couldn't afford to let his personal feelings cloud his judgment. Not again.
He closed the tablet and turned back toward his office, his pace a little quicker now. The surveillance team would be watching Alex closely, but Coulson knew he needed to stay involved, keep his own eyes on the situation. He wouldn't make the same mistake twice.
Still, as he made his way down the familiar hallways of the helicarrier, he couldn't shake the lingering sense of conflict. Alex Winters wasn't just another case. There was something different about this one, something that didn't sit right with him. Coulson had always prided himself on being a good judge of character, but this time, he wasn't sure what to think.
As he stepped into his office and closed the door behind him, Coulson sat down at his desk, pulling up the latest files on Alex. He spent a moment staring at the man's picture—an ordinary guy, a pizza delivery kid, with nothing particularly remarkable about him.
Yet here he was, under S.H.I.E.L.D.'s watchful eye, with the possibility of being much more than what he seemed.
Coulson leaned back in his chair, his mind still working through the puzzle that was Alex Winters. He wasn't sure what the next few weeks would reveal, but one thing was certain: he'd be watching closely.
And if Alex turned out to be a threat? Well, Coulson would do what he always did.
He'd make sure the world stayed safe. No matter the cost.
---
As the night settled over the helicarrier, the glow of computer screens illuminated Coulson's office. He remained at his desk, deep in thought, his mind running through every possibility, every potential twist in the story of Alex.