Reviews of The Surgeon's Studio
The Surgeon's Studio
Black Ursa Prime
- Overall Rate
- Translation Quality
- Updating Stability
- Story Development
- Character Design
- world background
I'm waiting for you on the app's discussion channel!
Download the app to discuss your favorite works, TV shows, and even the weather with me!
I really can't understand how this one got picked when plague doctor is on the list of trial read. Probably because this one are early released than plague doctor. Well, it's not the worse option on the list, but it really is not for me. That confuse hospital (that apparently don't have security), the forced development just to create a lot of face-slaps like some cultive novels and the Mc that I really can't sympathize with, when all this point are placed together on one novel, I really can't continue reading it. The good medical terminology and the fact that it's a medical novel with a system are not sufficient for hook me on this.
Premise is nice. Quite similar to Great Doctor Ling Ran but the MC has been a doctor for 10 years, iirc, at this point. The fact that he has been a doctor for so long has basically no effect on the whole story, other than times where he quotes his "immense medical experience" when he needs to think of an excuse when using the system. Speaking of the system, it basically fades out into the background and becomes a glorified scanner and surgery streaming machine later into story. Even the streaming plot point is mostly to show the readers that the MC is, indeed, a master surgeon by making the stream viewers stare and awe at the MC's supreme godly skill. Plot progression is basically non-existent. 500 chapters in and only now is the MC starting to move up into a bigger stage. There is too much filler chapters that has mostly no impact on the overall story. The translation quality takes a dive around 300 chapters in. It starts to feel like its MTL as the pretty boy side character starts being referred to as a "she" and mob characters' titles start changing around all the time, becoming Director, CEO, President, Doctor, Teacher and such. At around page 500 it becomes basically unreadable.
Great medical novel. Although I am not in the medical field, the author made everything very easy to understand even while using all the medical jargon. This also provide a small window into the lives of doctors. With Covid-19 devastating the world and overwhelming our hospital, we can't help but have a lot more appreciation for all our hero in the medical field. This novel illustrates how our doctors, nurses, and hospital administration face battle on a daily. I know it's not exaggerated because even before Corona virus our hospitals were crowded. This novel tells you why it happens. It's a good read.
Surprisingly this book has a lot of potential, from the get go our mc already have a genuine skill only need some improvement. The story development also have a good flow..it’s true that in real life a political issue happened in the hospital..a higher position doctor always take credit or put blame onto the lower position doctor..kind of sad for me..
This one is definitely awesome. i've read it till chapter 60 and I just want moarrr!! The Story is not so boring as other medical type novel. And the focus of the story is as the title say its surgeon. The first chapter is kinda absurb cuz he gain 30minute peak level skill to save npc but afterward get blamed by the main surgeon cuz they fail the surgery and need to 'scapegoat' and blame the MC The System is kinda confusing as the skills point is changing several times. i dont know if this is miss-translation or error from the book. Lastly The MC is kinda slow-witted with low EQ when conversation with woman is brought and max level face blindness. Anyway this one is good, and different from the rest medical type novel out there. no showoff, no face slap, no cr*p xianxia with MC lv 100 fighting skills most importantly the main topic of this novel is SURGERY Thank you!
If you want the character to develop than this is not for you. If you like a monotone MC that this is for you. The story was good when I started reading. At first I thought that the MC will improve himself and he did but it's like he is a dead man with no emotions. All he cares about is surgery. He did not think that if he goes to a higher end hospital he would gain more experience and knowledge. The fact that he thinks that only he is a proper doctor is mind blowing. He forgets names and never tries to correct it. Has zero communication skills despite being a doctor but says that he comforted someone who had cancer, plot hole or what? he has also been threatened a few times but never took self defense. Food, friendship, hobbies, nothing. I really wanted a good medical novel with slice of life but this is all about surgery. the MC doesn't even lives at his home. He stays in the hospital all the time. in 100 chapters he went out less than 10 times. All in all I'm disappointed because i really liked the beginning when the MC had some emotions.
How can i describe it?! Annoying!! This has similarities with Dr Ling Ran. If not from the same author then this is inspired by it. Both have MCs with super low EQs. What makes this worse is the actual MC itself. Given that he is plain looking, he is basically a wallpaper. Either people ignores him or they disrespects him. And again what is worse is he has no backbone to stand for himself. This started to get glaringly obvious when the infuriating Dr Su Yun(Dr Ling Ran who knows how to use his appearance to get what he wants) gets to join his team. The author keeps on going about on every scenario how this guys looks good and ladies keeps chasing after him while the same people look daggers or ignore the pitiful MC. And this same guys cant speak to the MC w/o insulting him. MC of course, is defenseless. Enough of my rant. I am not sure if the character development of the MC is a long term plan by the author. But like I said, it got worse when Dr Su gets into the picture. I will try a few more chapters and if there's no improvement, i will drop it.
This is a good book, written if I am not mistaken by a doctor. However the translation has been going downhill making it difficult to read. is this MTL? How can Su Yun who obviously a guy became a She, instead of trying to add too many books, finish the ones you had properly. If you are just a fan translating people will understand if you are losing interest but you are taking people’s money, You have the responsibility to actually do it properly. I want to continue reading it but I won’t because its becoming ineligible.
