Sometimes, in fanfiction, authors like to challenge the established norms to create unique and unexpected plots. Maybe they thought it would add more depth or drama to have Harry Potter not be the boy who lived in their particular story.
Maybe it's a twist to explore Neville's potential and show a different outcome. It could be that the author wanted to give him a chance to shine and be the hero instead of Harry.
Perhaps it's to showcase Neville's growth and strength that was often overlooked in the original story. This fanfiction idea might aim to highlight that anyone can rise to the occasion and be a hero, not just the obvious choice like Harry.
Perhaps it's to challenge the traditional narrative and offer a fresh perspective. Maybe it's to show how Ron could have handled the challenges if he were in Harry's shoes.
It's rare. Usually, the 'boy who lived' is Harry Potter himself in the original story and most fanfictions adhere to this. However, there could be unique takes where his brother takes on that role, but it's not the norm.
Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone: The Boy Who Lived
He looked at the Headmaster of Hogwarts with fear and unease. 'I,' said the headmaster,'but you don't belong here. You're a free man. You should go somewhere else. '
He knew, he thought, that he didn't belong at Hogwarts. He had to go somewhere else. He began to pack his things and prepare to leave home. 'I don't know where to go,' he said,'but I know I can't stay here. '
Harry looked at the Headmaster of Hogwarts with fear and unease. 'I,' said the headmaster,'but you don't belong here. You're a free man. You should go somewhere else. '
He knew, he thought, that he didn't belong at Hogwarts. He had to go somewhere else. He began to pack his things and prepare to leave home. 'I don't know where to go,' he said,'but I know I can't stay here. '
It could be because some fanfiction writers want to take a different approach and create a new storyline where Harry's role or perception is challenged.
It could be that the character's development doesn't match the original or expected traits. Maybe they act out of character or the story takes an unexpected turn with this aspect.