It could be because some fanfiction writers want to take a different approach and create a new storyline where Harry's role or perception is challenged.
One reason might be to offer a fresh perspective on the Harry Potter universe. It could also be to examine the impact of certain events differently or to show how circumstances could have led to a different interpretation of Harry's role. Sometimes, it's just for the sake of creativity and breaking away from the traditional narrative.
It's criticized because it often changes the core essence of Harry's character and the original story's themes.
It is complete. The story wraps up all the major plot points and gives a satisfying conclusion to the alternate take on the Harry Potter universe.
The 'Wrong Boy Who Lived' idea gives room for creativity. It allows for different character developments and plotlines that deviate from the original canon, making for fresh and exciting reads.
Well, if Neville was the 'Wrong Boy Who Lived', the entire magical world's perception of heroes and chosen ones would shift. It would also change how his character develops and how he interacts with others.
Well, the 'Wrong Boy Who Lived - Charlus Potter' concept often involves reimagining the prophecy and the roles of the characters. Maybe there are hidden secrets or different circumstances that make Charlus the supposed 'chosen one' instead of Harry. It adds a new layer of intrigue to the Potterverse.
Sometimes, in fanfiction, authors like to challenge the established norms to create unique and unexpected plots. Maybe they thought it would add more depth or drama to have Harry Potter not be the boy who lived in their particular story.
Perhaps it's to showcase Neville's growth and strength that was often overlooked in the original story. This fanfiction idea might aim to highlight that anyone can rise to the occasion and be a hero, not just the obvious choice like Harry.
Perhaps it's to challenge the traditional narrative and offer a fresh perspective. Maybe it's to show how Ron could have handled the challenges if he were in Harry's shoes.
It could be because the author wanted to create a unique twist or challenge the traditional storyline. Maybe they thought it would add more drama and intrigue.
The fanfiction might explore an alternate storyline where Alexander Potter takes the place of Harry Potter as the central character and faces different challenges and adventures in the magical world.