who took my toe

Could be a deranged serial killer who has a strange obsession with toes. Or maybe it was a supernatural force that randomly chose your toe as its trophy.

Maybe it was some kind of creepy monster or a ghost. They often do such things in scary stories.

Maybe it was a prank gone wrong by someone you know, or perhaps it was part of a dark and unknown conspiracy. The possibilities are endless, and it's quite a baffling mystery!

I have no idea who could have taken your big toe. It's a really creepy and mysterious situation!

Hard to say. It could be someone who overheard a rumor or had a wild imagination and came up with the story. But there's no definite person who 'has' it.

Well, that's a mystery. It could be hidden in a dark corner of your imagination or perhaps in a creepy old house you dreamed of.

I have no idea. It's a rather mysterious and maybe hard-to-track-down story origin.

Well, it could be that you accidentally stored it in a place you don't usually look. Or perhaps someone moved it without you knowing.

Since there's no more context about this 'cut off big toe with axe story', it's impossible to say who did such a thing. It could be anyone in the story's context, but without further details, we can't determine it.

I don't know who created the 'big toe soup story'. It could be an anonymous person who just made it up for fun.