There are also cases where Shouto could be in shock. The suddenness of the kidnapping could leave him stunned for a while. During this time, Dabi could have the upper hand. But as Shouto recovers, his natural instincts as a hero trainee kick in, and he starts to think of ways to get free and stop Dabi's plan, whatever it may be.
The Flash might initially be in denial. He's used to Batman always having a plan and his death would be a huge shock. He would then turn his speed into a tool for investigation, trying to find out exactly what happened. Green Lantern could feel a sense of loss but also be spurred into action, using his ring to try and prevent future tragedies like Batman's death. He might create constructs in Batman's memory to inspire the team.
Well, one possibility is that Bakugou is initially frustrated with the hero society in the fanfic. Maybe he feels overlooked or misunderstood. The League of Villains could approach him, promising a place where he can use his power more freely without the restrictions of the hero rules. And he might be tempted by their offer, leading to his joining.
He'd probably be confused at first. Naruto is used to being among friends and comrades. But then, his determination would kick in. He'd likely try to talk to them, to understand why they think he's a threat.
Some might be shocked. For instance, Batman is often portrayed in very different ways in fanfiction compared to his 'canon' self. Superman might raise an eyebrow at a fanfic where Batman is overly emotional. Others like the Flash might be really into it, finding the different takes on Batman's character and his adventures exciting.
Well, unfortunately, Dabi did meet his end in the manga. It was a heart-wrenching moment for fans. The events leading up to his death were filled with tension and drama.