The sense of isolation is a really scary element. When the characters are alone, like the hiker in the forest or the girl in the apartment, they have no one to turn to. It makes the fear more intense.
One 'Shit Your Pants Scary Story' could be about a haunted house. A family moves into an old, dilapidated mansion. At night, they start hearing strange scratching noises on the walls. Then, they see shadowy figures moving in the hallways. The children's toys start moving on their own, and the family feels a cold presence everywhere. They try to leave, but the doors seem to be locked from the inside, trapping them with the unknown terrors.
The story of the haunted lighthouse has an unexpected twist. It was said that a lighthouse keeper disappeared mysteriously one night. People thought it was a ghostly apparition that got him. But as it turns out, he had faked his own disappearance to start a new life because he was in debt. However, years later, his guilt made him come back to the lighthouse. And that's when the real hauntings started. His own ghost now haunts the place because of his remorse.
One such story could be about a girl who was home alone at night. She heard strange scratching noises coming from the attic. As she slowly made her way up the stairs, the scratching got louder. When she finally opened the attic door, she saw a pair of glowing eyes in the darkness. She was so terrified that she thought she might pee her pants. But then it turned out to be just a stray cat that had found its way in.
One shit scary story could be about a haunted house. People say there are strange noises at night, like the sound of chains dragging. Shadows move on their own, and cold spots are felt throughout the house. It gives a feeling of being watched all the time.
One such story is about an old, abandoned asylum. Legend has it that at midnight, the ghost of a former patient roams the halls. A group of teenagers once dared to enter. As they walked through the dark corridors, they heard strange moaning sounds. Then, a cold wind blew past them, and they saw a shadowy figure with long, stringy hair. It was so terrifying that they nearly peed their pants and ran out as fast as they could.
The story of the haunted doll is also well - known. There's this doll that seems to move on its own and has an evil look in its eyes. In one instance, a collector who bought the doll started having nightmares of a little girl's ghost. The doll would be in different positions every morning. One night, the collector woke up to find the doll right next to his face, and he was so scared that he almost wet himself. The doll's presence just radiates pure horror.
The fear of losing control, like peeing your pants, adds a sense of real vulnerability to the story. It makes the reader or listener feel more connected to the character's fear.
I heard about a girl who was on a really intense roller coaster. She was so nervous before getting on and during the ride, the sudden drops and twists made her lose control. It was an accident, of course. Her friends were a bit shocked at first but then they all had a good laugh about it later when she was okay.
There's the story of the haunted mansion on the hill. A family moved in once, and every night they heard strange noises coming from the attic. One night, the little girl saw a pale face looking at her from the window. She screamed, but when her parents came, there was nothing there. As the days passed, they found old diaries in the house that told of a tragic death that happened there many years ago. Ever since then, people claim to see the ghost of the victim wandering around the house, especially on moonless nights.