snape finds hermione broken fanfiction

One possible reason could be the stress from her studies. Hermione is always under a great deal of pressure to excel academically. Maybe she reached a breaking point due to the overwhelming workload. Another reason might be some kind of conflict with her friends. For example, if she had a big fight with Harry or Ron over something serious, it could leave her feeling broken.

Snape might be suspicious at first. He might think it's some sort of trick or part of a bigger plot. However, as he observes Hermione more closely and realizes the genuineness of her situation, his attitude could gradually change to one of reluctant assistance. He might even offer some words of wisdom, albeit in his typical sarcastic way, to help Hermione regain her strength.

He may show a rare moment of kindness. Given his own past traumas and experiences, he might empathize with Hermione on some level. He could offer her some words of wisdom or even some form of magical assistance to help her get better.

One possible reason could be that she was attacked by some dark creatures while on a solo adventure in the Forbidden Forest. The forest is full of dangers, and Hermione, being brave and curious, might have ventured too deep and got injured by a creature like a werewolf or a giant spider.

Snape could offer Hermione a book to distract her. Knowing her love for knowledge, a rare and ancient book about magic could draw her attention away from whatever is breaking her. It would be his way of saying that there are other things to focus on and that she can find solace in learning.

A common theme could be redemption. Snape, who has a complex and often - dark past, might find in Hermione a chance to redeem himself in some way. Maybe he saves her from a danger in the dungeon, which starts his journey towards a more positive path. Another theme is the exploration of hidden knowledge. The dungeon is full of secrets, and both Snape and Hermione are curious minds. They could uncover something that changes their understanding of Hogwarts or the wizarding world.

He might initially show annoyance. After all, Hermione is often seen as a know - it - all in his eyes. But his sense of justice and his underlying good nature (despite his cold exterior) would kick in. He'd untie her in a rather brusque manner, but then start to question her about how she got into this mess. Depending on her answer, he might offer some cryptic advice on how to avoid similar situations in the future.

Snape could also share some of his own experiences of being an outcast and misunderstood. He might tell Hermione that he too has faced hardships and that it is possible to rise above them. For example, 'I have been judged wrongly all my life, Miss Granger. Yet here I am, still standing. You are far stronger than you think.' This would give Hermione a new perspective and comfort her.

Well, it might result in a confrontation. Snape has his own secrets and motives, and Hermione is not one to back down easily. If she's in the dungeon without permission, Snape could be quite harsh with her. However, some fanfictions take this in a different direction. Maybe Hermione discovers something about Snape's past while in the dungeon, and this knowledge makes Snape more vulnerable in front of her. It could be a turning point where their relationship goes from antagonistic to something more complex and nuanced.

Well, perhaps Hermione starts debating with Snape about magical theories during class. She might bring up new research or different interpretations that go against what Snape has been teaching for years. Like, when Snape is talking about the properties of a certain magical plant, Hermione could say 'But Professor, I've read in an old wizarding journal that the plant has additional properties that we're not considering.' This would surely annoy Snape as he's not used to being challenged in such a way.