It's not ethical. Harry Potter is a beloved character, and writing about him being brutally beaten goes against the spirit of the original story. It can be disturbing for many fans who love the positive and magical elements of the series.
Well, it could cause quite a stir in the fandom. For those who are attached to the positive and inspiring image of Harry Potter, this type of fanfiction would be very off - putting. It might lead to arguments about the boundaries of fan creativity. Some fans might feel that it violates the essence of what the 'Harry Potter' series represents, which is mainly about hope and heroism. And it could potentially drive away some fans who don't want to be associated with such a dark take on the story.
Well, perhaps Vernon might beat Harry out of his extreme dislike for magic. He could be enraged by some accidental magic Harry does at home and lose his temper completely.
It might be a fan who was really intrigued by the relationship between Harry and Vernon and decided to take it to an extreme in their writing. There are so many fanfiction writers out there, some write for fun, some to explore different character dynamics. So, it could be anyone really.
There could be some extremely dark and non - canon fanfiction out there with such a plot, but it's not something that is typically promoted or widely known within the mainstream Harry Potter fan community. Most fanfiction focuses on more positive aspects like adventure, friendship, and magic, rather than such violent and disturbing themes.
One possible fanfiction could be set during a fight with some dark wizards in a back alley. Harry is outnumbered and gets beaten up badly. In the chaos, his glasses are knocked off and broken. He has to rely on his other senses and magic to fend off the attackers until help arrives.
It could be a form of expressing a very different view of the Harry Potter universe. Some writers might feel constrained by the relatively positive and heroic nature of the original story and want to break free by creating something extremely contrasting. But this kind of fanfiction is likely to be frowned upon by many in the fandom. The original series has themes of love, friendship, and heroism, and this type of 'beaten to death' concept is a complete deviation from that. It might also be a result of the writer having some personal issues or a very different understanding of the characters and the world, but it's not a typical or welcome addition to the fanfiction landscape.
Harry might initially be in shock. He could feel a mix of anger and helplessness. Maybe he'd try to hold back his magic out of fear of getting into more trouble with Vernon.
Well, it might be a really strange or unique concept. 'Naruto brutally kills fanfiction' could be a statement from a very dark or alternate universe fan - story where Naruto has some sort of power or reason to go after and violently end fan - made stories. It could also be a metaphorical statement about how some people feel Naruto's character could be misused in fanfiction and this is a very extreme reaction to that in a fictional sense.
It's not a common type. In the vast world of Harry Potter fanfiction, you'll find a lot more stories about Hogwarts during different eras, the relationships between the main trio, or the exploration of the wizarding world's politics. 'Breeder fanfiction' is more of a specialized sub - genre that only a small subset of fans might be interested in, as it delves into family - building and genetic - like concepts which are not as central to the general appeal of the Harry Potter series.