Perhaps the writing style is poor. If the author fails to convey Naruto's emotions, motives, and the overall atmosphere of being a Hokage effectively. Bad grammar, inconsistent pacing, and lack of engaging dialogue can all contribute to the perception that it's a terrible fanfic. For example, if the dialogue between Naruto and his advisors as Hokage is stilted and unconvincing, it can ruin the whole fanfic experience.
Improving the plot would also help. Instead of having random and unconnected events, a well - thought - out plot that challenges Naruto as Hokage in a way that is consistent with the Naruto universe would make it better. For example, a plot where Naruto has to deal with a new threat to the village in a creative and engaging way.
Shikamaru is another possibility. He is known for his strategic mind. As Hokage, he could use his intelligence to make wise decisions for the village. He may not have the brute strength of Naruto or Sasuke, but his ability to plan and analyze situations would be invaluable in leading Konoha.
Perhaps a perk is the ability to shape the future of the ninja world. As Hokage, one can inspire the younger generation of ninjas. They can create new ninja academies or training programs. They also have the power to pardon or punish ninjas according to their deeds, which helps in maintaining law and order in the village.
Sasuke could also be a possibility for the 6th Hokage in the fanfic. He has grown stronger over the years and his unique perspective on the ninja world could bring new ideas to the leadership of the Hidden Leaf. He might start off as a controversial choice but prove himself through his actions in protecting the village and making tough decisions.
I really like 'Naruto: Hokage's Ascent'. It delves deep into the political aspects of being Hokage, which is not often explored in great detail in regular Naruto stories. It shows Naruto having to make tough decisions for the village, and the relationships between the different ninja clans are also well - portrayed.
One possible fanfic could be about the 5th Hokage, Tsunade, facing a new and powerful enemy that the village has never seen before. This enemy could be a rogue ninja from a far - off land who has a special jutsu that can disrupt the chakra flow in the village. Tsunade would have to use her medical ninjutsu and combat skills to counter this threat and protect the village.
Yes, there are likely many fanfics with that theme. The Naruto fandom is huge and creative, so it's common to find fan - made stories exploring different 'what - if' scenarios, like Naruto becoming the fifth Hokage. You can look for them on popular fanfic websites.
A really interesting plot could be Naruto traveling back in time to the era before he was born. He could meet his parents and other important figures in the village's history. This would give him a chance to understand the roots of the village better and also learn some new jutsu or strategies that he could bring back to his own time to make the Hidden Leaf even stronger as a Hokage.
Sasuke could also be a candidate in some fanfics. He has his own set of powerful abilities and a complex personality. A story could be written where he decides to take on the role of Hokage at a young age to bring about change in the village in his own way, perhaps using his Sharingan and new techniques he develops.