why does snape and lily have the same patronus

One possible theme is unrequited love. Snape loved Lily deeply, and their Patronuses, both being doves perhaps in some fanfictions, could symbolize that love. His Patronus could be a constant reminder of his love for her, even though she was with someone else.

In a fanfiction, Snape's Patronus could be the key to saving Lily from a dark magic curse in an alternate universe. Since the Patronus represents love and protection, Snape's doe Patronus might be able to break the curse that has trapped Lily's soul. As he sends his Patronus towards her, it glows with a powerful light that gradually dispels the dark magic surrounding her.

Well, it really depends on the fanfiction author's creativity. Some might give her a Patronus that reflects her own unique personality traits. For example, if she's portrayed as very brave and fierce in a particular fanfic, her Patronus could be a lioness, representing her courage and leadership. Another possibility is that it could be a bird, perhaps a phoenix, which would tie in with the magical and powerful nature often associated with the Potter family.

One interesting Snape patronus fanfiction is 'The Silver Doe's Secret'. It delves into the significance of Snape's doe patronus and its connection to his unrequited love for Lily. Another is 'Snape's Patronus Revelation' which explores how his patronus might have changed over time due to different events in his life.

In the original setting of Harry Potter, Lily married James Potter, but not Snape. However, if Snape were to marry Lily, the whole story would change dramatically. For one thing, Snape's personality might have become much milder. His love for Lily was deep and persistent. If Lily became his wife, the loneliness and indifference in his heart might be resolved by love. When Voldemort first rose and threatened Lily's life, Snape might not need to protect her as a spy, because he could directly protect Lily under his wings. For Harry Potter, his upbringing would be very different. He would probably have grown up in a family full of Potionology knowledge, because Snape was an expert. Moreover, Harry might receive a more direct magical education from Snape, and his magical abilities might develop further in different directions. Things would change at Hogwarts. Snape might not become Harry's "troublemaker" at school, and the relationship between Slytherin and Gryffindor within the school might be eased by Snape and Lily's union. Questions such as the Wizarding world's attitude towards the offspring of Muggle-born wizards (Lily was Muggle-born) and half-bloods (Snape was half-blood) would also become new story elements. However, this was only an imagination based on a hypothesis, which was very different from the original story. Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire was not enough. Everyone, please click to read the novel!

If Snape married Lily, it would be a completely different story. Judging from their personalities and values, Lily was kind, brave, righteous, and anti-bullying. She was against black magic. Snape, on the other hand, had gone to the Dark Arts due to his own experiences as a student. Although he loved Lily deeply, this internal difference in values was a potential contradiction. If they were to marry, Snape might need to make a huge change and abandon the ideas and behaviors related to Dark Magic before he could live in harmony with Lily. In terms of social relations, Snape had a bad relationship with James and others during his student days. James was the representative of Gryffindor, and he had a deep friendship with Lily and eventually won her heart. If Snape married Lily, his relationship with James would become extremely complicated, and it might lead to greater conflict between Gryffindor and Slytherin or require more reconciliation. In the background of Voldemort's rise, James and Lily stood against Voldemort's camp, and Snape mistakenly entered the Death Eater camp and became a double agent. If Snape married Lily, he might be more directly on the side of fighting against Voldemort because of Lily's influence, which might change the direction of the war against Voldemort. For example, the Death Eaters camp might expose some plans earlier or lose some sources of information, and the Order of the Phoenix might have more knowledge about Dark Magic to fight against the Death Eaters because of Snape's existence. At the same time, Harry's growing environment would also change dramatically. He might grow up in an environment with a more complex family background and magical knowledge. And because of Snape and Lily's union, he might not become the " chosen one " in the prophecy. Neville might take on a different role. Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire was not enough. Everyone, please click to read the novel!

It was not explicitly stated in the original book whether Lily had completely forgiven Snape. From their experience, Snape and Lily had fallen out over Snape's practice of the Dark Arts and his unintentional insults. Although Snape had done many things to protect Lily and her family, there was no evidence that Lily had explicitly expressed her forgiveness for Snape before she was killed by Voldemort. However, Snape's love for Lily and the sacrifices he made to protect her were very deep, and it became a complex and touching emotional vein in the Harry Potter series. Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets is not enough. Everyone is welcome to click to read the novel!

When Snape saw Lily dead, his heart was filled with great grief and regret. Lily's death had a profound effect on Snape: - He had always loved Lily emotionally, and her death had broken his heart. Snape had felt pain and regret for Lily's death all his life, and this emotion had accompanied him until his death. He had protected Harry for another seventeen years because he had Lily's eyes. - In terms of behavior, Lily's death became an important factor in Snape's path to redemption. Despite his initial bad attitude towards Harry Potter, he knew that Harry was the child of Lily and James. Out of love for Lily, he swore to protect Harry Potter at all costs and did his duty to protect Harry's safety. Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets is not enough. Everyone is welcome to click to read the novel!

Snape had never confessed to Lily directly. His love for Lily was restrained. Although the words " Always " were a very touching and affectionate expression, Lily would never be able to hear it. Even if Lily hadn't been killed by Voldemort, Snape probably wouldn't have spoken of his love. Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets is not enough. Everyone is welcome to click to read the novel!

Snape's patronus being a doe in fanfictions often because it was his love for Lily that was a central part of his character. In the original story, his doe patronus was a symbol of his love for her. Fanfiction writers like to explore this aspect further, so they keep using it as it is such a powerful and poignant symbol of his unrequited love.