The 'female Harry Potter Dumbledore bashing fanfiction' may exist because some fans want to explore the darker sides of Dumbledore. When the main character is female, she might be written to have a more emotional and empathetic approach to the situations around her. This could lead to a more critical view of Dumbledore. For example, if Dumbledore knew about Harry's (or in this case, a female Harry's) difficult home life and still left him there, the female character could be more vocal about her dissatisfaction with Dumbledore's lack of intervention. It's a way for fans to rewrite the story according to their own interpretations.
Well, obviously Harry Potter. He's the main protagonist in the original series and in the bashing fanfictions, he might be the one to finally see through Dumbledore's facade. Ron Weasley could also be popular. He's Harry's best friend, and in these stories, he might support Harry in his doubts about Dumbledore. And then there's Voldemort. Some fanfictions might use Voldemort as a tool to show how Dumbledore's actions or inactions affected the battle against him. For example, if Dumbledore was so secretive, it could have made it easier for Voldemort to gain power.
Another theme could be the exploration of female agency. With a female Harry Potter, the fanfiction might focus on how she challenges Dumbledore's authority. Since Dumbledore is often seen as the all - powerful figure in the original series, a female lead might be written to break free from his control and make her own decisions, which would lead to bashing Dumbledore as he tries to keep her in line according to his plans.
Well, a common theme is the idea that Dumbledore was a bad mentor. In the fanfiction, he might be shown as not really caring about Harry's well - being as much as he seemed in the original story. For instance, he sent Harry back to the Dursleys every year, and in these fanfictions, it could be portrayed as a more callous act rather than for protection. Another theme is his secrecy. People write about how his secrecy led to a lot of chaos and danger for the characters. And his past mistakes, especially regarding Grindelwald, are often a central point where he's bashed in these fanfictions.
Well, in some fanfictions, Dumbledore is bashed because writers want to explore alternative storylines. They might believe that Dumbledore was too controlling. He made a lot of decisions for Harry without really consulting him. So by bashing him, they can create scenarios where other characters step up or Harry has a different kind of growth without Dumbledore's influence.
One common theme is betrayal. Writers often depict Dumbledore as having betrayed Harry's trust in some way. Another theme is manipulation. They show Dumbledore as a master manipulator who used Harry for his own ends. Also, the theme of hidden motives is prevalent, where Dumbledore's actions are re - examined and shown to have ulterior motives.
Some fanfictions focus on Dumbledore's mistakes in raising Harry. They might show that his distance and secrecy were not just for protection but rather a sign of his lack of true care. For example, in a particular fanfic, Dumbledore is blamed for not being more forthcoming with information about Harry's parents and the prophecy, which leads to Harry making many mistakes and facing more danger than necessary.
One common theme is his so - called 'manipulation' of Harry. Some fanfics focus on how Dumbledore used Harry for the greater good without really considering Harry's personal feelings. Another theme is his secrecy. Writers in these fanfictions often explore how his secrets had negative consequences for the characters around him.
One reason could be that some fans feel Dumbledore made mistakes in the original story. For example, he didn't always fully protect Harry. He also had a rather secretive nature which might have frustrated some readers. So in fanfiction, they explore the idea of criticizing him more deeply.
One common theme could be a sense of betrayal. For example, in some fanfics, Dumbledore might be portrayed as having ulterior motives that betray Harry's trust, which is different from his more benevolent portrayal in the books. Another theme could be jealousy towards the Weasleys. Maybe the author of the fanfic feels that the Weasleys got too much attention or special treatment in the series. However, these are often extreme interpretations that deviate from the original source material.