harry potter james potter bashing fanfiction

Some people write 'Harry Potter James Bashing' fanfictions because they feel that James was not as perfect as he was made out to be in the original series. His bullying of Snape, for example, is a big factor. They want to explore a different side of the story where his actions have consequences.

There's 'James Potter: The Dark Side'. It delves into the idea that James Potter wasn't as pure - hearted as he seemed. Fanfiction writers in this genre might take small hints from the original 'Harry Potter' series, like his bullying of Snape, and expand on it to create a more unlikable version of him. They may show how his actions affected others in more long - term and severe ways than the original story hinted at.

Some write it because they feel that James Potter's actions as a bully towards Snape in the original books were not fully addressed. They want to explore the consequences of his actions more deeply.

One popular 'Harry Potter James Bashing' fanfiction is 'The Boy Who Lived in Darkness'. It portrays James in a negative light by highlighting his supposed arrogance and bullying tendencies during his school days. Another one could be 'A Different Perspective on Potter', which reimagines the story with a more critical view of James' actions and how they might have affected others.

Not really. The vast majority of Harry Potter fans love the original series and its characters. So, fanfiction that bashes the main elements of the story is not as popular as positive or alternative - but - still - respectful fanfiction. However, there are some niche groups who might be interested in it, usually those who have very strong opinions about what they perceive as flaws in the original work.

Well, often in such fanfiction, a theme is the distortion of the 'saint - like' image of James and Lily. Some might focus on James' past bullying and exaggerate it to make him seem completely unworthy. And for Lily, they could create scenarios where her relationship with James was more about self - interest rather than love. Also, there could be a theme of revenge, where characters who had issues with James and Lily in the original story get their 'comeuppance' in these new, bashed versions of the characters.

Often, these fanfictions might have a theme of exploring the power dynamics at play. Since Lily was a Muggle - born witch and James was from a pure - blood family, some fanfictions could play on the idea that their relationship was more about power and status rather than love. They might also explore how their actions affected the wizarding world in a more negative light, like their decision to join the Order of the Phoenix might be painted as a self - serving move rather than a heroic one.

Harry would often be a main character in these fanfictions. Since it's about bashing his parents, his reaction and how he copes with the new view of them is a big part of the story. Another could be Sirius Black. He was very close to James, so fanfictions might explore his feelings towards the bashing of his best friend.

Probably not as popular as the regular positive or canon - compliant Harry Potter fanfiction. Most fans love the characters and the world, so bashing everyone might not appeal to the general fanbase.

There could be several reasons. One is simply to add drama. A lot of fanfiction writers thrive on creating conflict, and what better way to do that than by taking on one of the most beloved houses in the 'Harry Potter' series? Another reason might be personal bias. Perhaps the writer had a negative experience with someone who identified strongly with Gryffindor, or they just don't like the traits that are typically associated with Gryffindor, like impulsiveness, and they use fanfiction as a way to express their views.