Martial Saint is Guan Yu, then what is Zhang Fei?
Zhang Fei was known as the "Enemy of Ten Thousand Men". He was famous for his bravery. In the official history, he showed a careful and certain military strategic vision. For example, when Liu Bei entered Xichuan, Zhang Fei skillfully used goading and ambush tactics when fighting Yan Yan in Bajun. He also defeated Zhang He, one of the five generals of Cao Wei, and defended the gate of Yizhou in the battle of Hanzhong. His comprehensive strength could not be underestimated. "Warrior Sage!" The novel is equally exciting. Everyone is welcome to click and read it!
Is the Martial Saint Yue Fei or Guan Yu?
In China culture, Guan Yu was known as the Martial Saint. Yue Fei was also a famous general, but he wasn't a Martial Saint. Guan Yu became one of the representatives of the Chinese traditional virtues because of his loyalty, courage, martial arts, bravery, loyalty, and loyalty. He was honored as the Martial Saint and Emperor Guan. "Warrior Sage!" The novel is equally exciting. Everyone is welcome to click and read it!
Is the Martial Saint Yue Fei or Guan Yu?
Guan Yu was now officially recognized as a Martial Saint. The first time Guan Yu entered the Martial Temple was during the reign of Emperor Dezong of the Tang Dynasty. During the Song Dynasty, his position in the Martial Temple had changed many times. During the Wanli years of the Ming Dynasty, Guan Yu was conferred the title of "The Three Realms Demon Subduing Emperor God Weiyuan Town Tianzun Emperor Guan Sheng Emperor" and became the chief priest of the Martial Temple. From then on, he was regarded as a Martial Saint. In 1730, Emperor Yongzheng of the Qing Dynasty officially conferred Guan Yu the title of Martial Saint, further confirming his status as a Martial Saint. Yue Fei was once regarded as a Martial Saint. He was a famous general who fought against the Jin Dynasty during the Southern Song Dynasty. He was outstanding in military skills and loyal. However, due to ethnic integration and other reasons, Yue Fei was later removed from the Martial Temple, and Guan Yu became a widely recognized Martial Saint. "Warrior Sage!" The novel is equally exciting. Everyone is welcome to click and read it!
Who is the Martial Saint, Yue Fei or Guan Yu?
Guan Yu was officially recognized as the Martial Saint. During the Yongzheng period, the officials elected Guan Yu as the Martial Saint and built the Guandi Temple, which was on par with Confucius 'Confucian Temple, known as the Wenwu Temple. However, there were also people who believed that Yue Fei was the real Martial Saint. Yue Fei's military attainments and strategies were stronger, and he had made great contributions to the Chinese nation. In different periods of history, Martial Saints were recognized differently. Jiang Ziya was recognized as a Martial Saint before the Tang Dynasty, and Yue Fei was also recognized as a Martial Saint after the Song Dynasty. However, due to ethnic integration and other factors, Guan Yu eventually became the official Martial Saint. "Warrior Sage!" The novel is equally exciting. Everyone is welcome to click and read it!
Is the Ming Dynasty Martial Saint Guan Yu or Yue Fei?
In the Ming Dynasty, the Martial Saint was Yue Fei. After Zhu Yuanzhang established the Ming Dynasty, he invited Jiang Taigong from the Martial Saint Temple. Yue Fei became the Martial Saint at that time because he resisted the Jin Dynasty and saved the country. Guan Yu had been known as the " Emperor Guan Sheng " since the Ming Dynasty. He had become the officially recognized " Martial Sage " since the Qing Dynasty, which had continued the tradition of the Ming Dynasty. "Warrior Sage!" The novel is equally exciting. Everyone is welcome to click and read it!
Why did Martial Saint Yue Fei change to Guan Yu?
One view was that Yue Fei was a general who resisted the Jin Dynasty. In the process of China's multi-ethnic integration, it might seem that the ethnic groups were not united because the ethnic groups involved in the Jin Dynasty had become part of the Chinese nation. During the Qing Dynasty, the government believed that Yue Fei's resistance against the Jin Dynasty did not meet the needs of his rule, so he respected Guan Yu as a Martial Saint. In addition, Guan Yu's folk worship also played a certain role. Guan Yu's image among the people was relatively good. He was righteous and loyal. Although his historical image, literary image, and folk image were not exactly the same, they all had a certain influence. For example, the image in the literary work Romance of the Three Kingdoms was widely praised. These factors combined made Guan Yu become a Martial Saint and replace Yue Fei. "Warrior Sage!" The novel is equally exciting. Everyone is welcome to click and read it!
Guan Yu vs Zhang Fei
The analysis of Guan Yu and Zhang Fei from many aspects was as follows: ** 1. Situation in Official History ** Chen Shou had clearly stated in the Records of the Three Kingdoms that Zhang Fei was inferior to Guan Yu. Although Cao Cao's advisor Cheng Yu and the others had evaluated Guan Yu and Zhang Fei as "ten thousand enemies", Chen Shou had concluded that Zhang Fei was not as powerful as Guan Yu. ** 2. The situation in the novel Romance of the Three Kingdoms ** 1. ** One-on-one battle record comparison ** - Guan Yu had killed Hua Xiong in a warm wine at Lishui Pass, fought against Lu Bu at Hulao Pass (Lu Bu also had Guan Yu helping Zhang Fei in the Battle of the Three Heroes), killed Yan Liang at White Horse Slope, and killed Wen Chou at Yanjin Crossing. - Zhang Fei had fought Lu Bu one-on-one for 100 rounds without being defeated. He had also fought Lu Bu one-on-one twice (once for 50 rounds, once for 100 rounds) and killed Ji Ling in less than 10 rounds. However, in the Jiajing edition, when Zhang Fei and Lu Bu fought, there was a situation where the marksmanship was scattered. If it was not for Guan Yu's rescue, it might have failed. Moreover, when Zhang Fei fought and killed Ji Ling, Yuan Shu's army was in the twilight, and Ji Ling was not in full condition to fight. Overall, Guan Yu's solo battle record was quite valuable. For example, before Guan Yu killed Yan Liang, none of Cao Cao's subordinates dared to fight Yan Liang. Cheng Yu believed that only Guan Yu could kill Yan Liang, and Cao Cao also agreed with this. 2. ** From Liu Bei's arrangement ** - When Liu Bei had just started his career, he had asked Guan Yu to follow him and Zhang Fei to stay behind. From the perspective of Liu Bei's choice of guards, it could be seen that he felt that Guan Yu's martial arts were higher than Zhang Fei's. - Later, when the group became stronger and divided its forces, Guan Yu was used to command the army, and Liu Bei's guard became Zhao Yun. To a certain extent, this showed that Liu Bei thought that Zhao Yun's martial arts were better than Zhang Fei's. Zhang Fei might be the weaker one among the three (Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, and Zhao Yun). 3. ** From Zhuge Liang's attitude ** - In the Battle of Jiameng Pass, Ma Chao attacked. Zhuge Liang used Guan Yu to provoke Zhang Fei, saying that only Guan Yu could defeat Ma Chao. This implied that Guan Yu's martial arts were higher than Zhang Fei's. - After Ma Chao surrendered, Guan Yu wanted to enter Sichuan to compete with him. Zhuge Liang replied to Guan Yu that Ma Chao was at most on the same level as Zhang Fei, but not as strong as Guan Yu. Although he wanted to appease Guan Yu, it could be seen that in Zhuge Liang's eyes, Guan Yu was stronger than Zhang Fei. ** 3. The situation in the game (Tribute to the Three Kingdoms)** In the annals of the Three Kingdoms, Zhang Fei's strength was set to 98 while Guan Yu's was 97. However, this was only the game setting and could not completely represent the actual strength of the two. Based on the historical records, the various performances in the novel, and the hints of some related settings, Guan Yu might be more powerful than Zhang Fei. Click on the link below to read "The Strongest in History" comic
Guan Yu was honored as the Martial Saint
There were many reasons why Guan Yu was addressed as a Martial Saint. He was famous for his loyalty and loyalty to Liu Bei. He had experienced many battles while following Liu Bei. For example, when he was guarding the Jing State, he went to a meeting with Lu Su alone and displayed extraordinary courage. In the twenty-fourth year of Jian 'an, he led his troops to besiege Cao Ren, defeated Yu Jin, and flooded seven armies. His outstanding military ability made Cao Cao plan to move the capital. Although he was eventually killed by Sun Quan and Cao Cao after rejecting the marriage alliance, his heroic deeds were respected by the government and the people. Since the Northern Song Dynasty, Guan Yu had been conferred titles by successive dynasties. In Confucianism, he was known as Emperor Wen Heng and Martial Saint, the same name as Confucius. In Taoism, he was regarded as Emperor Guan Sheng and Emperor Demon Subduing. In the folk, he was regarded as the God of Wealth and the God of Rain. Later generations respected him as Guan Gong and later rulers worshipped him as Martial Saint. In the novel Romance of the Three Kingdoms, he was ranked first among the Five Tiger Generals and used the Green Dragon Crescent Blade. These factors together contributed to Guan Yu being honored as the Martial Saint. "Warrior Sage!" The novel is equally exciting. Everyone is welcome to click and read it!
Why is the Martial Saint Guan Yu?
Based on context alone There were several reasons why Guan Yu was honored as a Martial Saint. Firstly, Guan Yu's loyalty. He was loyal to Liu Bei. Even though Cao Cao gave him generous treatment, he still cared about Liu Bei. He would return to Liu Bei's side even if he had to go through five passes and kill six generals. This kind of loyalty was deeply respected by the rulers and the people and became a moral model. Secondly, Guan Yu's martial arts skills were very strong. In many stories and legends of the Three Kingdoms, Guan Yu's military achievements were remarkable. For example, he showed his bravery and fearlessness by killing Hua Xiong while drinking warm wine. He also showed his martial arts skills by killing Yan Liang and Wen Chou. His heroic performance on the battlefield was admirable. Thirdly, the cultural transmission of Guan Yu's image. With the development of history, literary works and operas based on the stories of the Three Kingdoms continued to emerge. Guan Yu's image was widely spread and his popularity among the people was extremely high. His story was passed down by word of mouth among the people, further consolidating his lofty status in people's hearts. Fourth, the worship of religion. In Taoism, Guan Yu was revered as Emperor Guan Sheng, and in Buddhism, he was revered as Bodhisattva Qielan. The worship of religion also caused Guan Yu's status to rise continuously, gradually becoming a Martial Saint. "Warrior Sage!" The novel is equally exciting. Everyone is welcome to click and read it!
Why did the Martial Saint change from Yue Fei to Guan Yu?
The Martial Saint was initially Jiang Ziya, and later on, Yue Fei was also regarded as a Martial Saint. However, in the end, Guan Yu became a Martial Saint mainly for the following reasons. In the course of history, Yue Fei had made a great contribution to the Chinese nation. He was strong in martial arts and humble. However, with the development of ethnic integration, Yue Fei was gradually removed from the ranks of the Martial Saint in order to reflect national unity. Guan Yu had contributed to the establishment of Liu Bei's regime during the Three Kingdoms period. He had always been loyal to Liu Bei and was regarded as a representative of loyalty. During the Southern Song Dynasty, the situation of the Southern Song Dynasty was similar to that of the Shu Han Dynasty. The Southern Song Dynasty took the Shu Han Dynasty as the orthodox. Among Liu Bei, Zhuge Liang, Zhang Fei, Ma Chao, Zhao Yun and other people, Guan Yu had a strong symbolic characteristic, so he was respected. Emperor Gaozong of the Song Dynasty granted Guan Yu the title of King Wu 'an, and at the end of the Southern Song Dynasty, he was granted the title of King Wu' an Yinglie. In the Qing Dynasty, Emperor Yongzheng officially conferred Guan Yu the title of Martial Saint in 1730. From then on, Guan Yu became officially recognized as a Martial Saint. "Warrior Sage!" The novel is equally exciting. Everyone is welcome to click and read it!
Martial Saint Guan Yu, Second Master Guan
Guan Yu, also known as Yunchang, was born in Changping, Xie County, Hedong Prefecture during the Eastern Han Dynasty (now Changping Village, Xie Zhou Town, Yuncheng City, Shanxi Province). He was a famous general at the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty and the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion. In his early years, he committed a crime and fled to Zhuo County. Later, he joined Liu Bei and participated in the suppression of the Yellow Turban uprising. Liu Bei was promoted to Pingyuan Prime Minister because of his achievements, and later granted Guan Yu the title of Sima of another department. After Liu Bei took Xuzhou, he was ambushed by Lu Bu. Guan Yu followed Liu Bei and joined Cao Cao to defeat Lu Bu. After that, Liu Bei arranged for him to guard Xiapi City. When Cao Cao marched eastward, Liu Bei was defeated. Cao Cao treated Guan Yu well and appointed him as a partial general. Guan Yu was granted the title of Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion by Cao Cao because he killed Yuan Shao's general Yan Liang. Soon after, he left a letter to bid farewell to Cao Cao and followed Liu Bei again. After Liu Bei took over Jingzhou, Guan Yu guarded Jingzhou. During this period, he and Lu Su went to meet each other alone. In the twenty-fourth year of Jian 'an (219 AD), Guan Yu led his troops to besiege Cao Ren, the general who conquered the south of the Wei Dynasty. He defeated Yu Jin, the general of the left of the Wei Dynasty, and flooded the seven armies. At one point, Cao Cao had the intention to move the capital. However, he was later defeated by Sun Quan and Cao Cao because he rejected Sun Quan's marriage alliance. He and his eldest son, Guan Ping, were killed by Sun Quan's generals in Linju at the age of 59. After Liu Chan ascended the throne, in the autumn of the third year of Jingyao of Shu Han Dynasty (AD 260), Guan Yu was posthumously named Marquis Zhuang Miao, and his second son Guan Xing inherited his title. Guan Yu's loyalty was highly respected by the government and the people. After the Northern Song Dynasty, he was granted titles by successive dynasties. He was regarded as the Guardian God of Qielan by Buddhism, the Emperor of Guan Sheng and the Emperor of Demon Subduing by Taoism, and the God of Martial Fortune and the God of Rain by the common people. Later generations respected him as Guan Gong, and later rulers worshipped him as the Warrior Sage. In the novel Romance of the Three Kingdoms, he was ranked first among the Five Tiger Generals. He used the Green Dragon Crescent Blade, and Mao Zonggang called him the "Yijue" in the "Three Wonders" of Romance. However, Guan Yu was also evaluated by the historian of the Western Jin Dynasty, Chen Shou, as a self-willed and arrogant person, although he had the demeanor of a national scholar. In the end, he was defeated and died because of his own shortcomings. In addition, after Liu Bei went to Yizhou and before Guan Yu carelessly lost Jingzhou, he had lost at least three battles that were not recorded in his biography. His opponents were all Cao Wei's side, and the leading generals were Yue Jin and Wen Pin. The Legend of Lin Yi is equally exciting, and everyone is welcome to read it!