The plot should be engaging. It could involve exploring new aspects of the alchemist world that we haven't seen much in the original series. Maybe a story where Edward and other male alchemists are trying to reform the alchemist community from within. Also, good character development for the other male alchemists involved is important. They should not just be there as sidekicks but have their own stories and motives.
A good fanfiction in this category often has a deep understanding of Edward Elric's character. It should stay true to his personality traits like his determination and his complex relationship with alchemy. For example, a story where he teams up with other male alchemists to solve a mystery related to alchemy would be great.
The writing style also matters. It should be descriptive enough to bring the world of alchemy to life. A well - written fanfiction might describe the alchemical processes in detail, making the reader feel like they are part of the story. And of course, it should have a good flow. No sudden jumps in the plot or inconsistent character behavior. For instance, if Edward is portrayed as being overly emotional in a way that doesn't fit his character, it would detract from the overall quality of the fanfiction.
You can try searching on fanfiction platforms like Archive of Our Own (AO3). They have a large collection of fanfics, and you can use the search filters to specifically look for fanfiction related to Edward Elric and male alchemists. Just type in relevant keywords in the search bar.
In fanfiction, Edward as a sniper often has a strong sense of purpose. His experiences with alchemy and his quest for the Philosopher's Stone might translate into his sniper role. He might be using his sniper skills to protect something or someone important. Also, his determination would be a big part of his character as a sniper. He'd be willing to wait for the perfect shot, no matter how long it takes. And his intelligence would play a role in strategizing his shots and anticipating his targets' movements.
A good 'female Edward Elric fanfic' should first have a believable portrayal of the character. Since Edward is being re - imagined as female, her personality traits should still be somewhat recognizable from the original. For example, her determination and intelligence should remain intact. Also, it should have an engaging plot. Maybe it could explore how her gender changes her relationships, like with Roy Mustang or Winry Rockbell.
Yes, there are some out there. You can start by looking on popular fanfiction websites like Archive of Our Own. Just search for 'Edward Elric is a sniper' and you'll likely find a variety of stories with different takes on this concept.
One great Edward Elric in DC fanfiction is 'The Alchemist in Gotham'. In this story, Edward's alchemical skills bring a unique dynamic to the DC universe. His no - nonsense attitude and determination to do what's right fit well with the morally complex world of DC.
One common theme is adventure. Since the Fullmetal Alchemist world is full of danger and exploration, the fics often involve the reader and Edward going on adventures together, facing alchemical beasts and solving mysteries.
Yes, there are likely fanfictions out there with such a concept. The worlds of Naruto and Fullmetal Alchemist, where Edward Elric comes from, are quite different, but that's what makes the idea of a crossover in fanfiction so interesting. Writers might explore how Naruto's ninja world and its unique powers could interact with Edward's alchemical abilities and the complex world of Amestris.
Alphonse Elric is often present. He might play a role in helping Edward understand and use his new gamer - like abilities in relation to alchemy. For example, he could be the one who discovers a new aspect of Edward's powers.
There might be a fanfic where Edward is faced with a powerful and malevolent alchemical creature that he has no prior knowledge of. The creature's very presence makes Edward scared as it seems to defy all the rules of alchemy he knows. His fear is palpable as he tries to figure out a way to defend himself and escape this terrifying encounter.
One interesting 'dark edward elric fanfiction' could be where Edward is trapped in a nightmarish alternate dimension. In this story, his alchemical powers are distorted, and he has to fight not only strange, dark creatures but also his own inner demons. Another could be a story where he's forced to make morally dark choices to save his brother Alphonse, like dealing with a malevolent alchemist who offers a solution at a great cost.