Another interesting plot could be that a mysterious artifact appears in the school. Vali and his harem must figure out what it is and how to keep it safe from those who would use it for evil. Along the way, secrets about the harem members' pasts could be revealed, adding more depth to their characters.
Perhaps a plot where the members of Vali's harem start developing new and unique powers. They then have to train together to control these powers while also facing threats from other factions in the Highschool DxD universe. This would involve a lot of character development and relationship building within the harem.
A plot idea could be Vali being sent on a secret mission by the Devils. He has to infiltrate an enemy stronghold that is rumored to be developing a weapon that could destroy the balance between the three factions. Along the way, he teams up with some unexpected allies, including some from the Angel faction who also don't want the balance to be disrupted.
Maybe the story could revolve around the main character accidentally hypnotizing the wrong person in the harem, which leads to a series of comical and challenging situations. He has to then find a way to reverse the effects without causing too much chaos among the group.
Well, a plot could revolve around the main character getting sent on a special mission by the school's authorities. Along the way, he meets new female characters who end up joining his harem. Also, there could be a plot where the harem members start developing their own unique powers and they have to train together with the main character. This could strengthen their bonds not only as a harem but also as a team. And then, there could be a mystery element where someone is secretly trying to break up the harem, and the main character has to find out who it is.
One idea could be Gasper using his unique powers to protect his harem members from a new threat in the high school. Maybe a group of rogue devils tries to target the girls he cares about.
The OC could be a new transfer student with a mysterious past. As the story progresses, it's revealed that they are on a quest to find a powerful artifact that is somehow connected to the characters in the harem. This could lead to adventures together, and the building of deeper relationships within the harem.
One idea could be an OC who is a transfer student with a unique power. The harem could form as different characters in the Highschool DxD world are intrigued by this power and gradually fall for the OC. For example, the OC might have the ability to heal wounds instantly, which is very useful in the battles that often occur in the DxD world.
One idea could be the main character, as the harem queen, having to deal with rivalries among the members of the harem. Maybe there's a new girl who challenges her position and she has to prove herself through various magical trials.
One idea could be an OC who is a transfer student with a unique power, like the ability to manipulate time slightly. This catches the attention of the main characters in the Highschool DxD world. The harem could start to form as different characters are intrigued by the OC's power and mysterious background.
A good concept for 'highschool dxd harem fanfiction' could be a time - travel story. The harem and Issei could be sent back in time and have to navigate the past while also dealing with their feelings for each other. They might meet younger versions of themselves or their predecessors. Another idea is to have a mystery element, where something strange is happening in the school and the harem has to solve it together. This could bring out different sides of each character and also develop their relationships further.
One idea could be the OC having a unique power that attracts the various characters in the harem. For example, if the OC can manipulate time in a certain way, it could lead to some really interesting situations. Maybe they use this power to save a member of the harem from a dangerous situation, which then makes that character develop strong feelings for the OC. Another plot idea is the OC being from a different dimension and having to adapt to the Highschool DxD world while building relationships with the harem members.