It could be a story where Lucy discovers an old family recipe book. She decides to recreate the recipes in it for her Fairy Tail friends. As she cooks each dish, she uncovers memories and stories from her family's past. This cooking journey also helps her to grow closer to the guild members as they share in her family's culinary heritage.
Maybe she enters a cooking competition in the magical world. Lucy has to use her magic in creative ways to cook unique dishes. Along the way, she meets other interesting characters from different guilds who also participate in the competition. In the end, she not only improves her cooking skills but also makes new friends and strengthens the reputation of Fairy Tail.
One idea could be that Jackal, after some soul - searching, decides to turn over a new leaf and teams up with Lucy. They could go on a mission to retrieve a powerful magical artifact that was once used by an ancient dark wizard. Along the way, Jackal's knowledge of the dark arts helps them navigate through various traps, while Lucy's celestial magic provides the offensive and defensive power they need.
One possible plot could be that Lucy and Juvia leave Fairy Tail to go on a self - discovery journey. They might want to explore their individual magic powers more deeply without the constraints of the guild. Maybe they travel to different magical realms, meet new characters, and learn unique magic techniques that they can bring back to Fairy Tail later.
One possible plot could be that Midnight uses his magic to trap Lucy in a dream - like world. In this world, he challenges her to various magical tasks. As they interact more, Lucy starts to understand Midnight's past and the reasons behind his actions. Eventually, she manages to break free from the dream world using her Celestial Spirit magic and in the process, Midnight has a change of heart and decides to turn away from his evil ways.
In this fanfiction, perhaps Lucy joins Fairy Tail right after she discovers her magic abilities. This would change a lot of the initial interactions. She could be more naive and inexperienced when joining, which would lead to different dynamics within the guild. Like, she might be more reliant on the others for guidance in using her magic, rather than having some basic skills already when she actually joins in the original story.
One possibility could be that they discover they're having a baby unexpectedly. Natsu might be initially confused but then super excited. Lucy would probably be a bit more practical, thinking about how to raise the baby in the Fairy Tail guild environment. The guild members would be overjoyed and offer all kinds of help, like Happy bringing little gifts for the baby to be.
Well, one possibility could be that it's a really innocent situation. Maybe they got into some kind of magical mishap that made them dirty and the only available place to clean up was a shared shower area. But they're both really embarrassed and trying to be respectful of each other's space while also dealing with the comical aspect of the situation.
One possible plot twist could be that Lucy initially refuses Natsu's proposal because she fears it will change their dynamic in the guild. She might think that getting married will make them less focused on their adventures and more on domestic life.
One possible reason could be a misunderstanding. Maybe someone framed Lucy for something she didn't do, like stealing a powerful magic item from the guild. Another reason might be that she accidentally broke a very important and unbreakable guild rule without realizing it. For example, if there was a rule about not using a certain type of dark magic, and she unknowingly used it to save a friend.
A possible plot could involve a dark magic that starts affecting Fiore. Lucy discovers some ancient texts about it, and she realizes she needs the help of Sting and Rogue. They go on a journey to find the source of this dark magic. Along the way, they encounter many enemies. Sting and Rogue use their Dragon Slayer magic to fight, while Lucy summons her Celestial Spirits. As they get closer to the source, they find out that one of their old enemies has returned and is using this dark magic to seek revenge. Together, they combine their powers to defeat the enemy and save Fiore.
It could be that there are some internal issues within Fairy Tail that make her leave while being pregnant. For example, there might be a prophecy or a curse that she believes could harm her baby if she stays. So, in order to break free from that potential threat, she decides to leave. Also, she may be facing some personal conflicts with other members of Fairy Tail regarding her pregnancy, like some not being supportive or having different views on how she should handle it, which ultimately drives her to leave.