The plot could involve Percy and his friends sitting around in Camp Half - Blood. They start playing 'Never Have I Ever' as a way to bond and share secrets. Maybe Percy has to admit things like 'Never have I ever made a sea monster do my bidding for fun' which would lead to some shocked reactions from his friends like Annabeth.
Percy himself would be really interesting. He has so many adventures and experiences that his answers would be full of surprises. For example, he might say 'Never have I ever been to the bottom of the ocean without being scared at least a little'. Given his connection to the sea, it would be fascinating to see how his friends react to such a statement.
I really like 'Percy's Never Have I Ever Nightmare'. In this fanfic, Percy has a strange dream where he's forced to play 'Never Have I Ever' with some of the most dangerous monsters from Greek mythology. It's full of action and suspense as he tries to find a way out of the dream while not giving away too much about his friends and their plans.
Well, maybe Percy uses his demigod speed and reflexes on the soccer field. He could be the star player, zipping past opponents with ease. His friends from Camp Half - Blood might come to watch him play, and he could use some of his water - related powers in a really creative way, like making a small water - based distraction for the opposing team's goalie.
Archive of Our Own (AO3) is another great place. There are some really well - written and unique 'Percy Jackson Never Have I Ever' fanfictions there. The tagging system on AO3 makes it easy to filter and find exactly what you're looking for. You might have to dig a little deeper compared to fanfiction.net, but it's worth it for the quality of the stories.
Maybe Percy is on a quest and stumbles upon a group of magical creatures playing poker. They invite him to join. Percy, being Percy, is a bit clumsy at first but then realizes that the game has a deeper meaning related to the prophecy he is part of. He starts using his battle - trained mind to analyze the opponents' moves and the patterns of the cards, all while trying not to reveal his true identity as a demigod.
Perhaps there could be a team of demigods from another camp. They see Percy as a threat on the soccer field and want to prove that their camp is better. They might use their own unique powers during the game in an attempt to outplay Percy. For example, a demigod from a fire - based camp could heat up the soccer ball to make it difficult for Percy to handle.
Another aspect could be that his friends from Camp Half - Blood come to support him at the games. Annabeth could be giving him strategic advice from the sidelines, and Grover could be cheering him on. And perhaps there are some mythical elements involved in the football games, like the ball suddenly having some sort of magical power during a crucial play.
It could explore his emotions. For example, playing the piano might be a way for Percy to express his inner turmoil or joy that he can't put into words. Since he has been through so much in his adventures, the piano could be a form of catharsis.
A plot where one of the characters time - travels back to their parents' high school days. Let's say Paxton somehow gets sent back in time. He could see how his parents were in high school, what they were like as teenagers. This could give him a new perspective on his family and his own identity. He might also accidentally change something in the past that has a ripple effect on the present when he returns, creating an interesting and complex storyline.
In Avengers fanfiction, a 'Never Have I Ever' scenario could be really interesting. For example, the characters might reveal secrets about their past battles or hidden feelings for each other. Maybe Iron Man could say 'Never have I ever been more scared than when I went into space in that first battle.' It would be a fun way to explore their personalities deeper within the fanfiction world.