The use of Christmas traditions against the characters can be quite frightening. For instance, when the Christmas lights that are supposed to symbolize hope and celebration start to be used as a means of luring victims in the dark. Or when the Christmas cookies that are usually a sign of kindness and sharing are poisoned or have some sort of dark magic associated with them.
Isolation is also a very scary aspect. In a Jezebel Christmas horror story, a family might be snowed in during Christmas, and that's when the horror starts to unfold. They are cut off from the outside world, and there's no escape from the terrifying events happening in their home, like a malevolent presence that preys on their fear and the fact that they can't get help.
The sense of being trapped is also a big factor. In the cursed forest story, the hiker feels like he can't escape the clutches of the forest. This feeling of being powerless against the situation is terrifying. It's like you're at the mercy of something far more powerful than you.
The scariest element could be the use of psychological horror. For example, a character slowly losing their sanity. They start seeing things that aren't there, but they can't tell what's real and what's not. It messes with the reader's mind too, as we question the character's perception of reality.
One possible Jezebel Christmas horror story could be about a haunted Christmas ornament. A family inherits an old ornament that, once hung on the tree, starts to cause strange things to happen. Lights flicker, there are cold spots in the room, and at night, people hear eerie whispers coming from the direction of the tree. It seems the ornament has a dark past and is bringing some sort of malevolent spirit into the home during the Christmas season.
There may be a story about a witch's curse. A family had unknowingly built their house on an ancient burial ground. Soon, they started experiencing strange events. Their pets died mysteriously, and the family members began to have health problems. They found out later about the curse and had to find a way to break it, which was a very scary and difficult journey for them.
The distortion of Christmas symbols is often a really scary element. For example, a possessed Santa Claus or an evil Christmas elf. It takes the things that are usually associated with joy and turns them into sources of fear.
Another scary part is the use of familiar Christmas items in a menacing way. Such as a gingerbread man coming to life and not in a friendly way like in the normal stories, but rather as a vengeful little creature that causes chaos in the house. The juxtaposition of the sweet and innocent image of Christmas with horror is really frightening.
The unknown presence is a really scary element. For example, in stories where there are strange noises or movements around the tree but no visible cause. It's the not - knowing what could be there that sends shivers down your spine.
The scariest element might be the sense of isolation. In many horror stories, the characters are alone and can't get help, like being trapped in an old, abandoned building.
Another type could be related to travel disasters. A family is traveling to their Thanksgiving destination, but they encounter multiple flight delays, lost luggage, and then when they finally arrive, they find out the host has fallen ill and the whole event is in disarray. It's a series of unfortunate events that make their Thanksgiving a horror story.
One time my jezebel roommate took my clothes without asking. She just rummaged through my closet and wore my favorite dress to a party. When I confronted her, she said it looked better on her. It was so infuriating.