The plot could involve Mike and Bella living in a small town. When they become pregnant, it causes a stir in the community. Some people might be judgmental while others are supportive. They could have a series of adventures during the pregnancy, like going on a road trip to visit a special doctor or trying out different natural birthing methods. The fanfiction could also explore how their relationship changes with the added responsibility of a baby on the way.
One possible plot twist could be that they initially think they're having one baby but find out it's twins. This would add a whole new layer of excitement and challenges for them. Another could be that there are some complications during the pregnancy that make them reevaluate their relationship and future plans.
One possible plot twist could be that Paige discovers she's pregnant at a very inconvenient time, like right before a big career opportunity. Maybe she has to decide between her career dreams and starting a family. Another twist could be that Mike has some long - lost family secret that comes to light when they find out about the pregnancy and it threatens to disrupt their relationship. And yet another could be that Paige and Mike find out they're having twins when they were only expecting one baby, which throws all their plans into chaos.
One possible plot twist could be that the pregnancy is not natural. Maybe it was the result of some magical or supernatural interference. For example, a powerful witch cast a spell on them for some unknown reason.
One possible plot could be that Mike makes an inappropriate comment about Bella's relationship with someone else, and in a fit of anger, she punches him. Then the story could follow the consequences of that action, like how their friends react or if there are any apologies later.
A great plot twist could be that the pregnancy is not as straightforward as it seems. There could be some sort of magic or curse involved that changes the nature of the baby as it develops. For example, the baby could start to show signs of being a different species than expected. Also, what if there are other characters who want to claim the baby as their own for power or some other ulterior motive? This could lead to a lot of conflict and drama in the fanfiction.
Another plot twist could be that the father of the baby is not who they initially thought. This would create a huge amount of drama and relationship turmoil. It could also lead to a search for the real father and a battle against whoever was trying to deceive them about the pregnancy.
One possible fanfiction could be where Mike and Rachel's pregnancy is a surprise to them. They might initially be scared but then slowly embrace the idea. They could start planning for the baby's future, with Mike being worried about his past affecting their child but Rachel reassuring him.
The plot might involve a twist where Rachel discovers she's pregnant, but she's not sure if Mike is the father. This creates a lot of internal conflict for her. She doesn't want to tell Mike right away until she's certain. Meanwhile, Mike starts noticing that Rachel is acting strange and becomes worried. As the story unfolds, they have to face the truth together and decide what to do about the pregnancy, whether they stay together or not depending on the paternity results.
Perhaps in the fanfiction, Mike and Tina's relationship is put to the test. The stress of the pregnancy makes them argue a lot. They start to question if they are really ready for this. However, as time passes and they start to feel the baby move, they realize that they are in this together and their love for each other and the unborn child becomes stronger. They then start to plan for a future that includes their baby and their dreams within the Glee club.
Maybe the pregnancy is actually a part of a bigger plan by an enemy of the mob boss. They use Edward and Bella's situation to get to the mob boss, for example, by trying to kidnap Bella when she's most vulnerable. The mob boss then has to decide how much he's willing to risk to protect them.