There could be an OC that is a fairy with a dark past. This fairy teams up with Peter Pan to fight against a new evil force in Neverland that is even more menacing than Captain Hook. The OC's dark past could add an interesting layer to the story, like they have some knowledge of the new evil's weaknesses from their own experiences, but they also have to overcome their own inner demons while helping Peter Pan and his friends.
Some fanfictions might have an OC who is from our modern world but gets transported to Neverland. This OC could introduce modern technology concepts to the lost boys, like using a flashlight to scare off the pirates instead of torches. Or an OC who is a magical healer and helps the injured characters in Neverland, which changes the power dynamics as characters who might have died in the original can now be saved.
One unique storyline could be an OC (Original Character) who has the power to manipulate time in the Neverland setting. This OC could accidentally change some of the classic Peter Pan events, like making Captain Hook a more sympathetic character at some point. Another could be an OC who is a mermaid with a special connection to Peter Pan and they go on adventures together that no one else in Neverland has experienced.
One plot idea could be that the OC is a lost girl from another dimension. Peter Pan discovers her and brings her to Neverland. She has unique powers that both fascinate and worry the Lost Boys. Another idea is that the OC is a mermaid who can transform into a human on land. She meets Peter Pan on the shore of Neverland and they embark on adventures together, with her mermaid knowledge helping them in various situations. And a third idea could be that the OC is a fairy who has been banished from her own kind. Peter Pan takes her in and she uses her fairy magic to help him against Captain Hook.
One plot idea could be a modern - day Peter Pan who discovers the real world has changed a great deal. He has to adapt to technology and new social norms while still maintaining his Neverland spirit. Another could be a story where Peter Pan meets a character from another fairy - tale realm and they go on an adventure together in Neverland. Maybe a girl from a strict, old - fashioned society stows away on his ship and he has to teach her how to have fun and be free.
One common theme is adventure. Since Peter Pan is all about adventures in Neverland, the fanfictions often include the reader joining Peter on his wild escapades, like fighting pirates or exploring hidden parts of the island. Another theme is the concept of eternal youth. The reader might experience the allure and consequences of never growing old in the story. Also, themes of friendship and first love are quite prevalent as the relationship between the reader and Peter Pan develops in these fictional tales.
A character like a talking tree. This tree could be the guardian of an ancient part of Neverland that has been long forgotten. It could give wisdom and tasks to those who seek its help. Another unique character could be a shadow - weaver. This being can manipulate shadows to create illusions or even trap people within their own shadows. It could add a new level of mystery and danger to the story. Also, a music - making sprite. This sprite can use its music to heal or to cause chaos, depending on the notes it plays.
A memorable OC in Peter Pan Once Upon a Time fanfiction can be created by making them have a special item or power. For instance, an OC with a magical amulet that can control the weather in Neverland. This not only gives them a unique role in the story but also affects the environment and other characters. Their values also matter. If the OC values fairness above all else and constantly challenges Peter Pan's sometimes - selfish decisions, it makes for an engaging character dynamic.
One idea could be to have Peter Pan meet characters from other parts of the Once Upon a Time realm in a friendly competition. For instance, a race through the magical forests of Neverland against characters like Alice from Wonderland. This would be a fun and exciting story without any inappropriate content.
I really like 'The New Arrival in Neverland'. In this fanfiction, a new character enters Neverland and changes the dynamics between Peter Pan and the other residents. It has some great descriptions of Neverland that make you feel like you're really there. And then there's 'Peter Pan's Hidden Heart'. This one delves into the emotions that Peter Pan tries to hide, which is really interesting as in the show he often comes across as carefree.
Here's an interesting plot. In a modern - day setting, Wendy discovers that Peter Pan is real through some ancient family heirloom that has a connection to Neverland. She then finds a way to get to Neverland herself, but it has changed a lot since she was last there. Peter is also different, a bit more jaded. They have to work together to bring back the old magic of Neverland and along the way, they deal with feelings they had buried deep down for each other all those years ago.
In Peter Pan romance fanfiction, the theme of sacrifice often comes up. Maybe Peter has to sacrifice some of his freedom or his connection to Neverland for love. Or the other character might sacrifice their normal life to be with Peter. Another popular theme is the struggle between the rules of the real world and the lawless nature of Neverland in the context of a relationship.
A great plot could be a time - travel twist. Peter Pan accidentally travels to the future and discovers that Neverland is in ruins. He then has to work with a group of his future fans who have studied all about him and Neverland to go back in time and fix what went wrong. They find out that Captain Hook made a deal with an evil wizard from another dimension and that's what caused the destruction. Or perhaps there could be a plot where a new character arrives in Neverland who claims to be Peter Pan's long - lost sister. She has different powers than Peter and challenges his leadership, causing a rift among the lost boys.