It can lead to a lot of debate. Fans who are against this type of fanfiction may argue that it's disrespectful to the original creators and the intended image of Edward Elric. On the other hand, those who support freedom of expression in fanfiction may defend its existence, but it still creates a contentious environment within the community.
It can cause a split. Some fans might be really put off by it and feel that it's not in the spirit of the original story. Others might be more open - minded but still find it a bit jarring.
Overall, it can make the fan community less cohesive. Since the original work of Edward Elric has a certain tone and set of values, the presence of such 'abused fanfiction' can make some fans feel alienated. It may also overshadow the more positive and in - spirit fan creations, as the controversy around the abused fanfiction draws more attention, which is not ideal for a healthy fan community that should be focused on celebrating the original work in a positive way.
It can make the fan community more aware of serious issues like abuse. Some fans might be inspired to create more content that deals with difficult topics in a sensitive way.
Well, Edward's alchemy in DC fanfiction is sometimes a source of mystery to the DC characters. Since they are used to powers like super - speed or telepathy, Edward's ability to transmute objects and substances through complex alchemical arrays is something new. It can also be a tool for him to bridge the gap between the two very different worlds he finds himself in - his own FMA world and the DC world. He might use alchemy to communicate with characters who have different forms of power or to solve problems that the DC heroes can't solve with their usual methods.
It can divide the fan community. Some fans might be outraged by this kind of uncharacteristic portrayal and distance themselves from those who support or create such fanfiction.
It can divide the fan community. Some fans might be disgusted by such content and distance themselves from those who create or support it.
The 'Naruto is abused' fanfic genre can have a polarizing impact. Some fans love it as it offers a different perspective on Naruto's character. It shows his strength in surviving and rising above the abuse. However, others might dislike it because it goes against the more positive and heroic image of Naruto in the original series. It can also spark a lot of discussions within the fan community about the nature of abuse and how it could have changed Naruto's story.
One concern is that it can distort the original character of Edward Elric. Fanfiction should respect the essence of the source material, and abuse-themed stories may go against the positive traits and development of the character in the original work.
In the original story, Edward's relationships are based on his male identity. In the fanfiction where he's a girl, her relationships with male characters might take on a romantic or different platonic angle. For example, her relationship with Roy Mustang could be less of a mentor - mentee and more of a complex romantic or competitive relationship. This would significantly change her character development path.
On the positive side, for some fans, it can be a way to explore different aspects of the characters in a more adult - oriented way. However, it can also make the community less inclusive. New fans, especially those who are not interested in sexualized content, may feel alienated, and it may limit the growth and diversity of the fan community.
The fanfiction challenges the original by highlighting the darker side of a relationship that was previously seen as idyllic. It forces the audience to think about the signs of abuse that might have been overlooked in the original narrative. For example, Edward's over - protectiveness in Twilight could be seen as a form of controlling behavior when looked at through the lens of this fanfiction.
At first, Edward might be a bit resistant to Roy's attempts at adoption. But as time goes on, Roy shows his care and concern for Edward. He helps Edward with his problems, like dealing with the homunculi or his own self - doubt. Edward then starts to rely on Roy more, and their relationship deepens into a strong bond of family - like love.