Well, one reason could be for the sake of exploring an 'alternate universe' scenario. Writers often like to play with the existing characters and settings in different ways. In this case, having Harry submit to Uncle Vernon can lead to a whole new set of interactions and storylines. It can also be a way to study power dynamics in a more extreme way. Since Uncle Vernon is usually the one in a position of power in the Dursley household, this fanfiction can take that power imbalance to an even greater extreme and see how the characters react. Also, it might be a way to add some unexpected twists to the well - known Harry Potter story.
Some writers might create this type of fanfiction to explore a different side of Harry's character. By making him submit, they can show his vulnerability in a new way. It could also be to create a more complex relationship between Harry and his Muggle relatives, adding a new layer of drama.
In this kind of fanfiction, perhaps Harry, out of fear or some form of coercion, starts to obey Uncle Vernon's every order. Maybe Vernon uses threats about expelling Harry from the house or withholding food to make him submit. This could lead to a very different dynamic in the Dursley household, with Harry being more submissive and not showing his usual defiance.
In some fanfiction, Uncle Vernon develops by becoming more accepting. For instance, he may start to see Harry not just as a freak but as a person with unique abilities that can be useful. He might begin to tolerate the wizarding world a bit more, especially if he realizes that Harry can use his magic to protect the family from certain threats.
One possibility could be that Harry, out of a sense of duty or some form of magical coercion, decides to follow his uncle's every order in order to protect his aunt and Dudley from a new magical threat. He might suppress his own desires and instincts to keep them safe.
Some fanfictions might explore a backstory for Uncle Vernon. Perhaps he had an encounter with a wizard when he was younger that made him so bitter towards magic. In these stories, Harry could discover this secret and it could change their relationship. Also, there could be a plot where Uncle Vernon is magically turned into a wizard for a short time. This would be a comical yet thought - provoking plotline as he would have to navigate a world he once despised.
On the other hand, it could be positive in a way. Maybe through submitting, Harry learns more about his uncle's insecurities and past, which could lead to a new understanding and a form of reconciliation between them.
In most of the official 'Harry Potter' canon, Vernon Dursley didn't murder anyone. However, in fanfic, the story can take many wild turns. It depends on the specific fanfic in question. Some fanfics might create extreme scenarios where Vernon could be involved in a murder, perhaps out of his extreme dislike for magic or a character related to magic. But without reading the particular 'Harry Potter Vernon murdered' fanfic, it's hard to say for sure.
Yes, it could potentially be a popular genre within the fanfiction community. Fanfiction allows for a great deal of creative license, and fans often like to explore different aspects of character relationships. The concept of Harry Potter submitting to Sirius Black might attract those who are intrigued by the mentor - mentee relationship between them taken to an extreme level. It could also be popular among fans who enjoy stories with elements of loyalty, trust, and power play. However, it's also likely to be controversial as it can be seen as changing the fundamental nature of the characters too much for some readers.
Good Vernon Harry Potter fanfiction usually has a fresh perspective. It might explore Vernon's past to explain his present behavior. For instance, perhaps he had a bad experience with a wizard when he was younger that made him so anti - magic. It should also have engaging plotlines. Instead of just repeating the same old interactions between Vernon and Harry, it could introduce new conflicts and resolutions. And the writing style matters. If the author can write in a way that makes Vernon seem real and his story interesting, then it's a good fanfiction.
The 'harry potter gagged by vernon fanfiction' could be about a particular situation where Vernon restricts Harry Potter's ability to speak. This might be part of a larger plot in the fanfiction. For example, it could be set in a scenario where Vernon has discovered some of Harry's wizarding secrets and in an attempt to keep them from getting out, he gags Harry. Or perhaps it's a more psychological exploration where Vernon's abuse of Harry takes on a new form of silencing him, and the story could then delve into how Harry overcomes this obstacle, or how it affects his relationships with other characters like Hermione and Ron.
If Vernon kills Harry Potter in fanfiction, it implies a breakdown of the safety net that was supposed to protect Harry. It also shows how a non - magical person can have a catastrophic impact on the magical world. This could lead to a re - evaluation of the relationship between Muggles and wizards in the fanfiction. It might also inspire other characters to take up the fight against Voldemort in a more vengeful way, as they would be avenging Harry's death.