He could be secretly touched. Deep down, Snape has a complex personality. Even though he doesn't show it easily, the fact that Hermione, a bright and determined student, gives him a gift might reach his softer side and make him feel a bit of warmth.
It could be a rare potion ingredient. Hermione is known for her academic prowess and might find a special ingredient that Snape has been seeking for his potions research.
Hermione could be defiant. She's not one to be easily intimidated. She might stand her ground and demand to know what he wants, all while using her quick wits to figure out his motives. She could also try to use the situation to her advantage, like gathering information from him about the Death Eaters' plans.
Most fans would likely condemn it. The fandom has a wide range of ages and backgrounds, and this type of content goes against the family - friendly and positive nature of the Potterverse. It would be considered a violation of the characters' integrity and the values that the series promotes, like respect and friendship.
Snape might initially be taken aback. He's not used to students standing up to him so forcefully. He could glare at Hermione with his cold, dark eyes, trying to intimidate her into silence.
Dumbledore might come to Snape's aid. Dumbledore always had a somewhat complex relationship with Snape, and he would likely step in to prevent things from getting too out of hand. He could use his powerful magic to stop Hermione and then try to sort out the situation calmly.
Yes, in the vast world of fanfiction, there are various stories that explore different relationships and interactions. However, not all of them are in line with the original tone of the 'Harry Potter' series. Some fanfictions might create unique scenarios where Snape and Hermione interact in unexpected ways, but it's important to note that these are creative interpretations by fans.
One challenge could be his own reputation. Snape has a rather dark and brooding image at Hogwarts. So, other students or even some teachers might be suspicious of his motives for being Hermione's guardian. Also, Hermione is very independent - minded, which might clash with Snape's over - protective tendencies at times.
He might be initially shocked. Snape is used to students being intimidated by him, so Hermione's outburst could catch him off - guard. He may glare at her silently for a moment, trying to regain his composure.
It's hard to say who would be the clear winner. Hermione is intelligent and quick - witted, but Snape has years of experience and a great deal of magical knowledge. If it's a battle of words, Hermione might hold her own for a while, but Snape could use his authority to shut her down.
She might be required to research in the restricted section of the library. Given her penchant for knowledge and Snape's often - dark and esoteric interests, the restricted section could hold the key to whatever he needs help with.