How about a story where the girl loses her toe due to a supernatural encounter and has to face the consequences of that encounter in terrifying ways. It could involve otherworldly creatures or evil spirits.
Once upon a time, there was a girl named Lily. She went for a walk in the old, spooky forest near her town. As she was walking, she heard strange noises. Suddenly, a hidden trap snapped shut on her foot, cutting off her toe. She screamed in pain, but then she saw a shadowy figure approaching. It was an old witch who lived in the forest. The witch cackled and said she would use Lily's toe for a dark spell. Lily was terrified and tried to run, but she could barely move with her injured foot. That night, she thought she would never escape the forest alive.
Well, it could be a cruel prank gone wrong. Maybe some mean kids set up a dangerous trap and the girl accidentally walked into it. Another reason could be that she was in a haunted place and some evil spirit caused her to lose her toe as part of a curse.
Maybe it was some kind of creepy monster or a ghost. They often do such things in scary stories.
One scary missing toe story could be about a hiker who got lost in the woods. While trying to escape from some unseen creature, his toe got caught in a trap. He managed to free himself but had to leave his toe behind. Later, at night, he heard strange noises outside his makeshift shelter and swore he could hear something dragging his lost toe around.
One scary story could be that a girl woke up in the middle of the night and saw a long, shadowy figure lurking at the end of her bed. As her eyes adjusted, she realized it was a bony hand reaching out from under the bed, slowly inching towards her big toe. She was too frozen in fear to move, and just as the hand was about to touch her toe, she screamed and the figure disappeared.
Hard to say. It could be someone who overheard a rumor or had a wild imagination and came up with the story. But there's no definite person who 'has' it.
The main character is, of course, the lost girl herself. She is at the center of all the spooky happenings.
I'm not really sure specifically which 'the toe scary stories' you mean. There could be various stories involving toes in the realm of scary tales. Maybe it's about a haunted toe or something really gross like a toe that has some kind of evil power.
It's a tale of a little girl's adventure to find her lost name. It might involve meeting various characters and facing challenges along the way.
In another ending, a brave person decides to help the corpse. They search everywhere and manage to find a toe that looks like hers. When they give it to her, she is so grateful that she uses her last bit of power to protect the person from all the other evils in the haunted place, and then she peacefully ascends to the afterlife.