A good one typically has well-crafted characters that we care about, an exciting adventure that feels fresh within the Harry Potter world, and maybe some hidden secrets or mysteries to solve along the way.
It often has unique plot twists and character developments that expand on the Potterverse. The magical elements are vividly described and the story keeps you hooked.
A captivating magical awakening Harry Potter self-insert fanfic typically has well-written interactions with the original characters. The way the self-insert blends into the existing story and influences it in a fresh way is key. Plus, a touch of mystery or adventure always keeps readers hooked.
Well, there are several things that can make a Harry Potter diary fanfic engaging. First, the connection to the existing story. It should feel like it fits into the Harry Potter world seamlessly. If it references events, characters, and locations from the books in a natural way, it draws the reader in. Second, the emotional depth. A diary can be a great way to explore the emotions of the characters on a deeper level. For example, if it shows how Ginny felt when she was possessed by Tom Riddle through her diary entries, it can be very engaging. Third, the exploration of new themes. Maybe the diary is a tool to explore themes like time - travel or alternate realities within the Harry Potter universe. And finally, the use of the diary format itself. The idea of reading someone's private thoughts in the form of a diary can be very alluring and make the fanfic engaging.
It could be about a new student at Hogwarts who discovers a hidden magical ability and embarks on a journey to uncover its origin. This journey might lead them to encounter forgotten spells, mysterious creatures, and make new friends along the way.
An engaging long journey home fanfic typically has a strong story structure. It could have unexpected twists, beautiful descriptions of the journey, and characters you really care about. Also, a bit of humor or romance can add to the charm.
It could be a young witch or wizard who is a transfer student to Hogwarts. They would be the main character as they try to adapt to the new environment and in the process, discover a magical mystery that sets them on a journey.
Unsettling plot twists can contribute to a fanfic being a 'nightmare' type. For example, if it turns out that Dumbledore was actually an evil mastermind all along and has been manipulating Harry for his own dark purposes. Or if the prophecy was a lie and Harry's whole life has been a cruel joke. These kinds of revelations that shatter our perception of the original story can make a fanfic feel like a nightmare.
Hippogriffs could be involved. They are majestic and powerful creatures. Harry might incorporate the loyalty and strength of a Hippogriff into his noble phantasm. It could have the ability to fly at great speeds and attack enemies with its sharp beak and talons.
The drama and conflicts that come with starting a new life together after past experiences. The growth and change of the characters are what draw readers in.
The worst Harry Potter fanfic might be the one that tries too hard to be edgy or different. It could introduce inappropriate or offensive elements that don't fit with the family - friendly nature of the Harry Potter series. Also, if it fails to capture the magic and wonder of the wizarding world, like having a dull and uninteresting description of Hogwarts or the magical creatures. If the author clearly doesn't understand the essence of the series and just uses the names to attract readers, it would be a candidate for the worst fanfic.
A clever Harry Potter fanfic often has unique plot twists. For example, it might change the way a well - known spell works or introduce a new magical creature in a way that makes sense within the existing wizarding world. This shows creativity and a deep understanding of the source material.