Zhang Xiaofan still loved Biyao in the end. Even though he was with Lu Xueqi, his longing for Bi Yao lasted for a full ten years. After Biyao died, Zhang Xiaofan burst into tears. In the original novel, Zhang Xiaofan's feelings for Biyao were real. His heart would beat and his face would blush at any time because of Biyao. He was willing to fall into the devil path for Bi Yao. For ten years, he was only trying to find hope to save her from the sea of suffering. Therefore, it could be said that Zhang Xiaofan still loved Biyao in the end.

The ending of Celestial Bane was open-ended, and it didn't explicitly state whether Zhang Xiaofan was with Biyao or Lu Xueqi. In the novel, Zhang Xiaofan and Biyao had a deep relationship, but they were not together. Lu Xueqi, on the other hand, had special feelings for Zhang Xiaofan, but they weren't together. At the end of the novel, Zhang Xiaofan and Lu Xueqi both experienced many setbacks, but they still insisted on their beliefs and finally got a happy ending.
In the novel, Jade Dynasty, Biyao did not revive in the end. At the end of the novel, Biyao died because of Zhang Xiaofan's betrayal, and Zhang Xiaofan blamed himself for his mistake and finally chose to leave this world. As for who Zhang Xiaofan ended up with, it wasn't clearly stated in the novel. Even though Zhang Xiaofan had some emotional entanglements with Lin Jingyu, Lu Xueqi, and the others, his final choice was to leave Lin Jingyu, Lu Xueqi, and Bai Jingjing. Bai Jingjing was also an important character in the novel. She had a deep relationship with Zhang Xiaofan, but Zhang Xiaofan did not end up with her and left this world.
Biyao was a fictional character created by Xiao Ding in the Celestial Bane novel. She was one of the main female leads in Celestial Bane. She was born in the Xiao Sect and was a smart and quick-witted woman. She had a complicated emotional entanglement with Zhang Xiaofan. Zhang Xiaofan was one of the main male leads in Celestial Bane and a fictional character created by Xiao Ding. He came from Xiao Gate and was a tenacious, open-minded and cheerful man. He had a mutual attraction with Bi Yao. The emotional entanglement between Biyao and Zhang Xiaofan was one of the core stories of Celestial Bane and one of the most controversial and touching parts of the novel. The relationship between Biyao and Zhang Xiaofan was complicated. They had experienced many hardships and trials, but in the end, they supported each other and relied on each other to overcome all kinds of difficulties and come together. In the novel, Biyao and Zhang Xiaofan were known as the " immortal partners " of the Xiao Sect, and their relationship was seen as the spiritual bond of the Xiao Sect.
The content of the novel was summarized as follows: " Celestial Bane " was a fantasy martial arts novel written by Xiao Ding. It described the grudges between Zhang Xiaofan, a monk from Tianyin Temple, Bi Yao, a disciple of Ghost King Sect, and Gui Li, a demonic sect, at the end of the Southern Song Dynasty. The story began with Zhang Xiaofan entering Tianyin Temple, and then the emotional entanglement between him and Biyao led to a series of conspiracies and sinister. In the story, Zhang Xiaofan went through hardships and finally joined hands with Biyao to fight against the demonic sect and save the world. The whole story was full of ups and downs and characters. It was a classic in ancient Chinese novels. Biyao was one of the female protagonists in the novel. She was born in the Ghost King Sect and had a gentle and kind personality, but she also had feelings that were difficult to let go of. In the story, the emotional entanglement between Biyao and Zhang Xiaofan was the most touching. They supported each other to face the invasion and crisis of the demonic sect. In the end, Biyao still died due to accidental injury, leaving Zhang Xiaofan grief-stricken. Through Biyao's death, the novel expressed the complexity of human nature and the selflessness and preciousness of love, which deeply touched people. In the end, Zhang Xiaofan overcame many difficulties and successfully saved the world and returned to his hometown with Biyao. After experiencing the trials of life and death, he became stronger and more decisive, and at the same time, he cherished life and love more. The whole novel was based on the relationship between Zhang Xiaofan and Biyao. It was interwoven with various plots and sinister plots to show an era full of war and hatred, but it also conveyed the beauty and preciousness of human nature.
The ending of the Celestial Slaying Cyan Cloud Chronicles was a sad story. At the end of the novel, Zhang Xiaofan and Biyao didn't end up together because they both realized that their relationship had gone beyond the scope of friendship. In the last chapter, Zhang Xiaofan and Lu Xueqi became friends and faced the invasion of the Demon Cult together. Biyao's sacrifice in the battle became a scar in Zhang Xiaofan's heart. The whole story was full of drama and touching emotions, showing the friendship, love and battle between Zhang Xiaofan and Lu Xueqi. Although they did not end up together, their feelings and experiences became an unforgettable part of the readers 'hearts throughout the novel.
The ending of the Celestial Slaying Cyan Cloud Legend was that Zhang Xiaofan and Biyao finally met after experiencing many hardships and faced the invasion of the demonic sect together. They fought hand in hand and finally defeated the demonic sect's forces. In this process, they also experienced many emotional entanglements and tests, but in the end, they loved each other and helped each other through the difficulties. At the end of the novel, they stood on a pile of ruins. Zhang Xiaofan confessed to Biyao that he had decided to protect her forever.
The ending of the Celestial Slaying Qingyun Annals was that Zhang Xiaofan and Biyao met on Zhongnan Mountain and entered the Qingyun Sect to cultivate together. After experiencing many cultivation and battles, the two gradually understood and trusted each other, and spent many wonderful times together. In the end, Zhang Xiaofan became the strongest existence among the new generation of Qingyun Sect disciples, while Biyao improved greatly in her cultivation and became a true immortal. The two of them fought against the Demonic Sect and other evil forces together to maintain the peace and tranquility of the entire world. At the end of the story, Zhang Xiaofan and Biyao faced the fate of the world together, showing their deep feelings and firm beliefs.
Zhang Xiaofan loved Lu Xueqi more. In the novel Celestial Bane, Zhang Xiaofan had a good impression of Biyao, but more of it was admiration and guilt because Biyao had once blocked a fatal sword for him. As for Lu Xueqi, Zhang Xiaofan truly loved her. In the end, they got together and had children to accompany them. Therefore, it could be said that Zhang Xiaofan loved Lu Xueqi more.
Zhang Xiaofan loved Lu Xueqi more. In the novel Celestial Bane, Zhang Xiaofan had a good impression of Biyao, but more of it was admiration and guilt because Biyao had once blocked a fatal sword for him. As for Lu Xueqi, Zhang Xiaofan truly loved her. In the end, they got together and had children to accompany them. Therefore, it could be said that Zhang Xiaofan loved Lu Xueqi more.
Zhang Xiaofan loved Lu Xueqi more. Although he also had a good impression of Bi Yao, his feelings for Lu Xueqi were deeper. In the novel Celestial Bane, Zhang Xiaofan and Lu Xueqi finally got together and had a son. After experiencing a series of ups and downs, they developed a deep relationship with each other. Therefore, it could be said that Zhang Xiaofan loved Lu Xueqi more.