There were different explanations and speculations about whether Yan Bingyun had killed Fan Xian in Joy of Life. There was a view that Yan Bingyun had assassinated Fan Xian for the safety of the Qing Kingdom because Fan Xian had discovered the truth of the Second Prince and Eldest Princess colluding. He had also made a deal with the Northern Qi empress dowager. This was not good for the Qing Kingdom. However, there were also some search results that hinted that Fan Xian might not have really died. There was some controversy. Thus, there was no clear answer as to whether Fan Xian had really been killed.

There were different explanations and speculations about whether Yan Bingyun had killed Fan Xian in Joy of Life. There was a view that Yan Bingyun had assassinated Fan Xian for the safety of the Qing Kingdom because Fan Xian had discovered the truth of the Second Prince and Eldest Princess colluding. He had also made a deal with the Northern Qi empress dowager. This was not good for the Qing Kingdom. However, there were also some search results that hinted that Fan Xian might not have really died. There was some controversy. Thus, there was no clear answer as to whether Fan Xian had really been killed.
Fan Xian was not killed by Yan Bingyun in " Celebrating Years." Although the plot of Yan Bingyun assassinating Fan Xian appeared in the TV series, this was added to the suspense in the process of adapting the plot. The purpose was to make the audience look forward to the next season. According to the original novel and analysis, Fan Xian had only been stabbed once, but there were no obvious signs that he was dead. Fan Xian and Yan Bingyun were friends who admired and trusted each other. They had common goals and interests. Thus, it could be inferred that Fan Xian had not been killed by Yan Bingyun.
There was currently no clear answer to the question of whether Yan Bingyun had killed Fan Xian in Joy of Life. Some people believed that Yan Bingyun and Fan Xian had discussed a plan beforehand. Fan Xian faked his death to protect the safety of others. Others believed that Yan Bingyun had killed Fan Xian for the stability of the Qing Kingdom. However, none of these claims provided conclusive evidence to support one of them. Therefore, we cannot be sure if Yan Bingyun killed Fan Xian.
Fan Xian was assassinated by Yan Bingyun in the ending of Joy of Life. Although the specific reason why Yan Bingyun wanted to kill Fan Xian was not clearly stated in the search results, some people believed that Yan Bingyun might have chosen to stab Fan Xian in order to protect the stability of the Qing Kingdom. This was because Fan Xian had discovered the collusion between the Second Prince and Eldest Princess in Northern Qi and their illegal actions. However, these opinions were only guesses. There was no conclusive evidence to prove the exact reason Yan Bingyun killed Fan Xian. Therefore, there was no clear answer as to why Fan Xian had been killed.
Fan Xian was not killed by Yan Bingyun in Joy of Life. Although the plot of Yan Bingyun assassinating Fan Xian appeared in the TV series, this was added to the suspense in the process of adapting the plot. The purpose was to make the audience look forward to the next season. According to the original novel and analysis, Fan Xian had only been stabbed once, but there were no obvious signs that he was dead. Fan Xian and Yan Bingyun were friends who admired and trusted each other. They had common goals and interests. Thus, it could be inferred that Fan Xian had not been killed by Yan Bingyun.
At present, there was no definite answer to whether Yan Bingyun had killed Fan Xian during the celebration. There were different explanations and speculations. Some people believed that Fan Xian and Yan Bingyun had discussed this plan in advance. In order to ensure the stability of the Qing Kingdom, Fan Xian pretended to be assassinated by Yan Bingyun so that Yan Bingyun could become Fan Xian's spy. However, there was no conclusive evidence to prove whether these explanations and speculations were true. Therefore, based on the information provided, I cannot be sure whether Yan Bingyun killed Fan Xian.
Fan Xian was not killed by Yan Bingyun in Joy of Life. Although the plot of Yan Bingyun assassinating Fan Xian appeared in the TV series, this was added to the suspense in the process of adapting the plot. The purpose was to make the audience look forward to the next season. According to the original novel and analysis, Fan Xian had only been stabbed once, but there were no obvious signs that he was dead. Fan Xian and Yan Bingyun were friends who admired and trusted each other. They had common goals and interests. Thus, it could be inferred that Fan Xian had not been killed by Yan Bingyun.
Fan Xian was stabbed to death by Yan Bingyun in the ending of Joy of Life. However, there were also some search results that hinted that Fan Xian might not have really died. There was some controversy. Thus, there was no clear answer as to whether Fan Xian had really been killed.
Yan Bingyun did not kill Fan Xian. In the original work of " Celebrating Years," Yan Bingyun's final sword pierced Fan Xian's abdomen, but Fan Xian did not die. In the TV series, the plot of Yan Bingyun assassinating Fan Xian was different from the original. After Fan Xian fell to the ground and spat out blood, Yan Bingyun told Fan Xian that all of this was for the Qing Kingdom. Only then did Fan Xian understand that this was a play between the two.
Yan Bingyun had not truly killed Fan Xian. In the plot, Yan Bingyun stabbed Fan Xian, but Fan Xian did not die. Instead, he was saved. Yan Bingyun's goal in stabbing Fan Xian was to gain the Second Prince's trust and protect Fan Xian's life. Fan Xian later decided to return to Jingdou to investigate the Second Prince and Eldest Princess 'behind-the-scenes instigation. Therefore, based on the information provided, it could be concluded that Yan Bingyun did not kill Fan Xian.