Was it reasonable for Jin Yong and Gu Long to plagiarize Yoshikawa's novels?

2024-09-24 10:35

It was said that in Jin Yong's novel, the long-winded speech of Guo Jing's loyalty and bravery was plagiarized from the understanding of Bushido in Miyamoto Musashi. In several works of Gu Long, he talked about how a sword could only be considered a sword art if it was in one's hand and heart, and directly quoted passages from Yoshikawa's novel without any modification. Moreover, Gu Long's novel, The Record of Washing Swords in Huanhua, almost borrowed the plot and passages of the Peony Messenger... I want to know if there is really a basis for saying that. My friend ridiculed modern Chinese popular literature, especially martial arts novels, as alternative translation works. I am very depressed. I hope someone can teach me, thank you!

1 answer

2024-09-24 12:40

This statement was not accurate. Jin Yong and Gu Long were both famous martial arts novels in China. Their inspiration came from different cultural traditions and social environments, and they had different writing styles and storylines. Although their works were influenced by other literary works, their creations were not plagiarized but borrowed and absorbed. Yoshikawa's light novels were a form of Japanese light novels known for their humor, relaxed, and romantic style. Yoshikawa's light novels were inspired by traditional Japanese literature and folklore, as well as life experiences in modern society. Although Jin Yong and Gu Long's novels were also influenced by Japanese light novels, their writing methods and story plots were very different, so it could not be said that Jin Yong and Gu Long copied Yoshikawa's light novels. Therefore, this statement is not accurate and cannot be used to evaluate the creation of Jin Yong and Gu Long.

Jin Yong and Gu Long's novels

1 answer

2024-09-18 19:22

Jin Yong and Gu Long are famous martial arts novels in China, and their works are deeply loved by readers. Here are two: Jin Yong (formerly known as Zha Liangyong)'s works: Eight Heavenly Dragons, Legend of the Condor Heroes, The Return of the Condor Heroes, Smiling Proud in Jianghu, The Sword of the Blue Blood, The Story of Heaven Sword and Dragon Sabre, etc. Jin Yong's works described the grudges of Jianghu, chivalrous feelings, and heroism as the theme. The plot was ups and downs, and the characters were full. The language was concise and bright, which was deeply loved by the readers. Gu Long's works: "The Peerless Twin Prides,""The Legend of Lu Xiaofeng,""The Legend of Chu Liuxiang,""Meteor·Butterfly·Sword," etc. Gu Long's works described Jianghu characters, thieves, detectives, martial arts secrets, etc. The plot was twisted and bizarre, and the characters had distinct personalities. The language was gorgeous and poetic, which was deeply loved by the readers. The two Jin Yong's works were based on history and focused on the creation of characters and the arrangement of the plot. The language was concise and clear, while Gu Long's works focused on describing the psychology and feelings of the Jianghu characters. The language was gorgeous, poetic, and the plot was twisted and bizarre.

Gu Long and Jin Yong

1 answer

2024-09-15 23:29

Gu Long and Jin Yong were both famous wuxia novels in China, and their works were very popular among readers. Gu Long's novel used Wuxia as the theme to describe the legendary stories of various characters in Jianghu. The plot was complicated and the characters were vivid. His representative works included The Peerless Twin Prides, The Legend of Lu Xiaofeng, and so on. Jin Yong's novels, on the other hand, used chivalry as the theme to describe the stories of various characters walking in the martial world with their moral character and indomitable fighting spirit. His representative works included The Legend of the Condor Heroes, The Return of the Condor Heroes, and The Eight Dragons. The works of Gu Long and Jin Yong were deeply loved by readers and were regarded as the classics of Chinese martial arts novels.

Please recommend Jin Yong and Gu Long's novels.

1 answer

2024-09-21 19:28

Jin Yong and Gu Long are both representatives of Chinese martial arts novels. Their works have profound cultural background and unique artistic style. Here are two for your reference: Jin Yong's works included The Legend of the Condor Heroes, The Return of the Condor Heroes, Eight Dragons, The Smiling Proud Jianghu, The Deer and the Cauldron, etc. These works had complicated plots, vivid characters, and beautiful language. They were widely praised and influenced several generations of Chinese people. Gu Long's works included The Legend of Lu Xiaofeng, The Legend of Chu Liuxiang, The Legendary Twin Prides, Meteor·Butterfly·Sword, etc. These works were known as the pinnacle of Chinese martial arts novels with their unique style, vivid characters, and ingenious plot design. Both Jin Yong's and Gu Longqi's works contain profound life philosophy and values that help readers think deeply about Chinese culture and life problems.

A famous killer in Jin Yong or Gu Long's novels

1 answer

2024-09-21 07:04

The famous killers in Jin Yong's or Gu Long's novels included: 1 Duan Yu: Duan Yu is one of the top killers in Jin Yong's novels. He is skilled in martial arts, proficient in poisons, and good at using various weapons. He is a warrior of Dali Kingdom. Xuzhu: Xuzhu is a protagonist in Gu Long's novel. His identity is a monk, but he is also an excellent killer. He uses his wisdom and wit to survive in the Jianghu. 3 Azhu: Azhu is one of the female protagonists in Jin Yong's novels. She is a smart and witty assassin who is good at using various weapons and techniques. Her assassination methods are often unexpected. 4. Mei Niansheng: Mei Niansheng was a famous killer in Gu Long's novel. She was good at using poison and had successfully assassinated many martial arts masters at that time. She was known as the "Poisonous Mei Niansheng". Ye Kai: Ye Kai is one of the main characters in Jin Yong's novels. He is a young assassin who is good at using various weapons and techniques. His appearance changed the fate of the entire Jianghu. Ximen Chuixue: Ximen Chuixue was a famous assassin in Gu Long's novel. He was known as the "Sword God" and was good at using all kinds of swords. His assassination methods were extremely cruel and terrifying. These are some famous killers in Jin Yong's or Gu Long's novels. They are agile and intelligent, and use their skills to survive and take revenge in the Jianghu.

Gu Long, what are the jokes in Jin Yong's novels?

1 answer

2024-09-10 09:19

Gu Long and Jin Yong were famous martial arts novels in China. Their works were rich in content and contained many jokes. The following are some of Gu Long's novels: 1. Little Li Flying Dagger: The Little Li Flying Dagger is a magical weapon that allows the user to use light-body-like speed to dazzle the enemy and win. Ximen Chuixue is a mysterious person. He's good at swordsmanship and is known as the Sword God. He had never killed anyone, but he was able to defeat his enemies with fewer people and make them tremble in fear. 3 Ye Kai: Ye Kai is an open-minded and cheerful character. He has unique skills but never shows off. He only focuses on his own cultivation. His story was full of philosophy and made people think deeply. 4. White Jade Tiger: The White Jade Tiger is a mysterious book that is said to contain the weaknesses of all martial arts masters. Only a true martial arts master could obtain this book and use the secrets within to achieve victory. Unrequited Love Valley: Unrequited Love Valley is a mysterious place where a ruthless martial arts master lives. His name is Ruthless. He never cared about the past nor did he worry about the future. He only focused on his own cultivation. These were some of the jokes in Gu Long's novels that made people laugh.

Seeking the Doujinshi of Gu Long and Jin Yong's novels

1 answer

2024-09-08 06:55

Gu Long and Jin Yong are the two most famous martial arts novels in China. Their novels are deeply loved by the readers. If you want to find doujinshi related to Gulong Jin Yong's novels, you can search for related keywords on the search engine such as " Gulong Jin Yong's novel doujinshi "," Gulong Jin Yong's novel adaptation ", etc. This way, you can find a lot of doujinshi related to Gulong Jin Yong's novels. Doujinshi referred to derivative works based on the original novel characters. In Doujin novels, one could see various derivative images of the original novel characters, such as adapted storylines, new character settings, and so on. Doujinshi novels had a wide audience in China. Many readers liked to find the shadow of the original novel in the novel.

The differences in the adaptation of Gu Long and Jin Yong's novels

1 answer

2024-09-07 19:40

Gu Long and Jin Yong are famous martial arts novels in China. Their novels have been widely adapted into movies, TV series, animation and other forms of works. The following are some of the adaptation differences between them: 1. Plot: The plot of Gu Long's novels is usually more unique and imaginative, while Jin Yong's novels pay more attention to the compact and logical plot. In the process of adaptation, Gu Long's novel may be more free to play, while Jin Yong's novel may make some adjustments and cuts to the story to meet the requirements of television or movies. 2. Character setting: The characters in Gu Long's novels usually have distinct personalities and unique images, while the characters in Jin Yong's novels pay more attention to their personality characteristics and background stories. In the adaptation process, Gu Long's novel might be more free to play, while Jin Yong's novel might make some adjustments to the character settings according to the requirements of the TV or movie. 3. Literature style: The literary styles of Gu Long and Jin Yong are different. Gu Long's novels pay more attention to describing the grudges of Jianghu, emotional entanglements and the contradictions and conflicts of the characters 'hearts. Jin Yong's novels pay more attention to describing the historical background, political struggles and the shaping of the characters. In the process of adaptation, in order to meet the requirements of television or movies, Gu Long's novels may pay more attention to the compact and logical plot, while Jin Yong's novels may pay more attention to the image and personality of the characters. 4. Adapted versions: Gu Long and Jin Yong's novels have been adapted into various versions, including movies, TV series, anime, games, etc. In the process of adaptation, different versions may have different adaptation methods and styles, but their core content is the same. Gu Long and Jin Yong's novels are both classic works of Chinese martial arts novels. They have some differences in story plot, character setting, literary style and adapted versions.

The respective styles of Gu Long and Jin Yong's novels

1 answer

2024-09-07 09:49

Gu Long and Jin Yong are both famous martial arts novels in China. Their works have a distinct personal style and unique narrative style, and are widely regarded as the masters of Chinese martial arts novels. Gu Long's novel style was natural and unrestrained, bold and unconstrained, and romantic. The characters in his works often had a very high personality and charm, and the plot was full of twists and turns, full of drama and thrills. Moreover, the descriptions in his works were often presented in the form of poetry. Gu Long's novel language was smooth, bright and full of music. His representative work, The Legend of Lu Xiaofeng, was regarded as a masterpiece in the history of Chinese martial arts novels. Jin Yong's novel style was exquisite, deep and rigorous. The characters in his works often had profound meanings and complex psychological structures. The plots were compact and exciting. The descriptions in his works were very real and delicate, giving people a deep feeling and thinking. Jin Yong's novel language was concise, simple but philosophical. His representative work, The Deer and the Cauldron, was regarded as a classic in the history of Chinese martial arts novels. Gu Long and Jin Yong's novels had their own unique styles, both of which had high literary value and influence. They were the outstanding representatives in the history of Chinese martial arts novels.

It was a description of a fight in Jin Yong and Gu Long's novels!

1 answer

2024-09-06 21:37

Jin Yong and Gu Long were both representatives of Wuxia novels. Their novels often described wonderful fighting scenes. Here are two: 1. Description of Fighting in Jin Yong's Fictions The descriptions of fighting in Jin Yong's novels were often full of thrills and gorgeous visual effects. For example, in " The Return of the Condor Heroes ", Xiao Longnu and Yang Guo dueled in the Unrequited Love Valley. The two of them displayed all kinds of martial arts stunts. Their figures were sometimes as fast as lightning, sometimes as fast as wind and thunder. The scene of sparks flying everywhere was very spectacular. 2. Description of fighting in Gu Long's novels Gulong's fighting descriptions were more concise and direct, often with astonishing speed and skill to make the readers feel as if they were there. For example, in the Legend of Lu Xiaofeng, Lu Xiaofeng and his friends had a fierce fight in the night market. Lu Xiaofeng displayed all kinds of exquisite skills and means to catch his opponents off guard. The scene was very lively. The fighting scenes in Jin Yong and Gu Long's novels were so wonderful that not only did they let the readers feel the charm of martial arts, but they also let the readers feel the emotions and philosophy of life contained in the novels.

All the poisons in Jin Yong or Gu Long's novels

1 answer

2024-08-23 05:48

The poisons in Jin Yong's or Gu Long's novels were as follows: Poisonous spiders: Poisonous spiders are poisonous insects in Jin Yong's novels. Their venom can kill and reproduce very quickly. The Poisonous Spider was once used to make poison in the Underworld, and it was a major evil force in the Underworld. 2. Scorpion: Scorpions were also one of the common poisons in Jin Yong's novels. Their venom could kill and was highly toxic. Scorpions were often used to make poison and were a major evil force in the martial world. 3. Viper: Viper was also a dangerous poison in Jin Yong's novels. Its venom could kill and was highly toxic. Venomous snakes were often used to make poison, and they were also a major evil force in the martial world. Poison: Poison is a special item in Jin Yong's novels that can be used to kill or make other items. There were many types of poisons, such as gunpowder, poison soup, poison arrows, and so on. Poison also played an important role in Jianghu. Silver Needle: Silver needle is a weapon in Gu Long's novel. It can shoot poison needles to attack enemies. The venom of the silver needle could also be used to make other weapons or items. 6. Poisonous Mushroom: Poisonous Mushroom is a plant in Gulong's novel. It can release venom that is poisonous to both humans and animals. Poisonous mushrooms were often used as poisons and were also a major evil force in Jianghu.