How many versions of the novel 'Dream of the Red Chamber' were there? Can someone give me an authoritative reference? thank everybody
There were many versions of the Dream of the Red Chamber, among which the more famous ones were Zhiyanzhai's re-evaluation of the Story of the Stone, Cheng Weiyuan's Cheng Jia version, Cheng Yi version, Geng Chen version, etc. These versions were all different, and there were even differences in annotations and collations. Information: - The Collated Notes of Dream of the Red Chamber - A Collection of Research Theses on the Dream of the Red Chamber
How many versions were there in Dream of the Red Chamber?
There were many versions of 'Dream of the Red Chamber', and the most famous one was the current version. The current version was edited by Cheng Weiyuan, Gao E, and others. It was a classic in the history of Chinese classical novels. In addition, there were many other versions of the Dream of the Red Chamber, including manuscripts, adapted versions, collated versions, and so on. These versions were different in content, collations, and writing styles, but they all had a profound impact on the study and appreciation of the Dream of the Red Chamber.
How many versions of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' were there?
As far as I know, there are many versions of 'Dream of the Red Chamber'. 1. Cheng Weiyuan and Gao E's 'Dream of the Red Chamber': This is currently the most popular version and is also recognized as one of the best. This version of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' had a total of 20 chapters. Each chapter had a clear title and a paragraph. The writing style was beautiful and the description of the Dream of the Red Chamber was very detailed. 2 Cao Xueqin's 'Dream of the Red Chamber': This version of' Dream of the Red Chamber 'was personally written by Cao Xueqin and was also one of the most original versions. This version of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' retained the original meaning of Cao Xueqin's poem, which was exquisitely described and concise. It was hailed as the pinnacle of Chinese classical novels. 3. The Commercial Press's 'Dream of the Red Chamber': This version of' Dream of the Red Chamber 'was compiled by the Commercial Press according to the version compiled by Cheng Weiyuan and Gao E, and was divided into 20 chapters. This version of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' was slightly different from the previous two versions, but overall, it still had a high literary value. In addition, there were many other versions, each with its own unique characteristics and style.
How many versions of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' were there?
As far as I know, there are two main versions of 'Dream of the Red Chamber', which are the Qing Dynasty's' Dream of the Red Chamber', and the modern 'Dream of the Red Chamber'. These two versions were different in literary style, plot, and character creation, but they were both representative versions of the classic literary work, Dream of the Red Chamber.
How many versions of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' were there? Was there a big difference?
As far as I know, there are currently a total of 12 versions of 'Dream of the Red Chamber', including the current version, Gao E's continuation, Gengchen version, Fairy Jinghuan's Biography, Cheng Jia version, Cheng Yi version, Cheng Weiyuan's preface version, New Evidence of Dream of the Red Chamber, the Collection of Dream of the Red Chamber, Gao E's Dream of the Red Chamber, and other versions of the Dream of the Red Chamber. The differences between these versions are usually very small, but there may be subtle differences in some aspects such as text, chapter structure, proofreading, etc. However, because there were many versions of 'Dream of the Red Chamber', the differences between some versions might not be particularly obvious, so readers could choose different versions to read according to their preferences and needs.
Many people liked to read 'Dream of the Red Chamber'. Why were there so many versions of' Dream of the Red Chamber'?
Dream of the Red Chamber was a classic in Chinese classical literature and one of the most important works in the history of world literature. Due to its complicated plot, numerous characters, and the author Cao Xueqin's life experience, creative mood, and other factors, there were many versions of 'Dream of the Red Chamber', and each version had its own unique characteristics and style. The following are some of the reasons why there are so many versions of 'Dream of the Red Chamber': 1. Different historical backgrounds: The social, cultural, and political environments of the Qing Dynasty when Dream of the Red Chamber was created were different. Therefore, different versions may differ in these aspects. 2. Different storylines: The story of Dream of the Red Chamber is very complicated. Different versions may have differences in the development of the story and the changes in the relationship between the characters. 3. Different literary styles: "Dream of the Red Chamber" is an idyllic poem of great reunion. Different versions may have different literary styles such as language, rhythm, artistic conception, etc. 4. The influence of the publishing company: "Dream of the Red Chamber" has multiple publishing companies. Different publishing companies may edit and proofread their versions differently, resulting in differences between different versions. Therefore, the many versions of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' were the result of many factors working together. Different versions had their own characteristics and reflected different understandings and appreciations of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' from different historical periods and cultural backgrounds.
How many versions of the Twelve Golden Beauties in Dream of the Red Chamber were there?
Dream of the Red Chamber was a very famous Chinese novel, and the twelve golden hairpins were also one of the important characters. However, there were still a few versions of the Twelve Golden Beauties in Dream of the Red Chamber that did not have a definite answer. Some people believed that only ten of the twelve golden hairpins in the Dream of the Red Chamber were Lin Daiyu, Xue Baochai, Jia Yuanchun, Jia Tanchun, Shi Xiangyun, Miaoyu, Jia Yingchun, Jia Xichun, Wang Xifeng, and Jia Qiaojie. Some people believed that there were actually fifteen of the twelve golden hairpins in the Dream of the Red Chamber, including Jia Yingchun's mother, Jia Jia, Jia Tanchun's mother, Li Wan, Wang Xifeng's father, Wang Ren, and Jia Qiaojie's mother, Sun Shaozu. No matter which version it was, the 12 golden hairpins were all very important characters. Their fates and encounters were also an indispensable part of the novel.
What versions of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' were there?
There were many versions of 'Dream of the Red Chamber'. 1. The current version of 'Dream of the Red Chamber', also known as' Zhiyanzhai's Reevaluation of the Story of the Stone 'was the first version created by Cao Xueqin and also one of the most widely circulated versions. 2 "Dream of the Red Chamber" Cheng Weiyuan's original edition: Cheng Weiyuan was one of the people who adapted the popular version of "Dream of the Red Chamber". He revised some words and deleted some chapters to make "Dream of the Red Chamber" more fluent. 3 "Dream of the Red Chamber" Liu Xinwu's book: Liu Xinwu has conducted an in-depth study of "Dream of the Red Chamber". He has carried out a unique interpretation of the text according to his own understanding. Gao E was one of the authors who adapted 'Dream of the Red Chamber'. He adapted Cao Xueqin's original poem and added, deleted, and tampered with the text. These versions all had their own characteristics, advantages, and disadvantages. The readers could choose to read them according to their own preferences and needs.
What versions of the "Dream of the Red Chamber" were there?
The Zhiyanzhai version of Dream of the Red Chamber referred to the Zhiyanzhai version of Cao Xueqin's novel Dream of the Red Chamber. As Zhiyanzhai was a very important character in the novel, his comments were also preserved in every edition of 'Dream of the Red Chamber', hence the name' Zhipi Edition'. The following are some versions of the edited version of 'Dream of the Red Chamber': 1 Gengchen edition: It is currently one of the most famous fat batches and the most circulated version on the market. It was collected by Cao Xueqin's grandson, Cao Xueqin's family. After many generations, it was finally compiled and published by Cheng Weiyuan and others. 2. Jiaxu edition: It is also one of the Zhipi edition. Like the Gengchen edition, it was compiled from the collection of Cao Xueqin's family. 3. Jimao edition: It was also one of the versions approved by Zhi. It was passed down through many generations by Cao Xueqin's great-grandfather, Cao Yin, and was finally compiled and published by Cao Xueqin's good friend, Gao E. 4. Jing Zang Ben: It is also one of the fat batches. It was collected by Cao Xueqin's uncle, Cao Dingchen. It is now stored in the National Library of China. In addition, there were some other versions such as Guiyou version, Zhuangzhou Lixiang Yuan version, Dream of the Red Chamber Xinzheng version, etc. However, the quantity and quality of their versions were not as good as the above versions.
How many versions are there in the novel version of Dream of the Red Chamber? Which version is better?
There were many versions of the novel version of Dream of the Red Chamber. The more well-known versions included: The audio novel version of " Dream of the Red Chamber " was performed by Beijing Chinese Theater. This version was based on the Beijing dialect and sang the tone and emotions of many characters in the novel that were closer to the original. 2. The novel version of Dream of the Red Chamber was dubbed by a Taiwan voice actor. This version used modern dubbing technology to create the plot and characters in the novel in great detail. 3. The video tutorial version of "Dream of the Red Chamber" was dubbed by a professional voice actor. This version used a video tutorial to explain the plot and characters in the novel and provided some audio files for reference. As for which version was the best, it varied from person to person. For the average reader, the dubbing of the novel version and the video tutorial version of "Dream of the Red Chamber" were clear enough and close to the original work. For professional voice actors and hobbyists, they might prefer the sound quality, tone, or the way the voice actors performed in a certain version. Therefore, he could choose the version he was interested in to enjoy.
So far, what were the authoritative books on 'Dream of the Red Chamber'?
There were many authoritative books on 'Dream of the Red Chamber'. The following were some of the more well-known ones: 1 << Dream of the Red Chamber >>: The << Dream of the Red Chamber >> academic journal sponsored by the << Dream of the Red Chamber >> Society of China > is one of the important institutions for the study of the Dream of the Red Chamber in China. 2.<< The Study of the Dream of the Red Chamber >>: This is also a journal sponsored by the China Dream of the Red Chamber Society. It mainly published the latest research results and papers on the study of the Dream of the Red Chamber. 3 " Study of the Dream of the Red Chamber ": The Dream of the Red Chamber Research Institute, hosted by the Peking University's Dream of the Red Chamber Research Team, mainly introduced the history, characters, plots, and art of the Dream of the Red Chamber. 4. A brief history of Chinese novels: A brief history of Chinese novels in the Qing Dynasty listed "Dream of the Red Chamber" as one of the important works in the history of Chinese novels. " Exploration of the Dream of the Red Chamber ": The Qing Dynasty's Exploration of the Dream of the Red Chamber was another important book on the study of the Dream of the Red Chamber. It provided an in-depth analysis of the plot, character, and psychological state of the Dream of the Red Chamber. [Appreciation of the Dream of the Red Chamber]: This book was written by the Hong Kong Society of the Dream of the Red Chamber. It was a book that introduced the appreciation articles and works of the Dream of the Red Chamber. The above are some authoritative books on 'Dream of the Red Chamber'. In addition, there are many other books and papers. Every scholar has their own unique research results and perspectives.