Why did 'Dream of the Red Chamber' have a tragic ending? Why couldn't it have a happy ending?

2024-09-19 12:49

1 answer

2024-09-19 17:11

The reason why 'Dream of the Red Chamber' had a tragic ending was because it was a novel and a historical novel at the same time. The plot of the novel described the microcosm of the feudal society of the Qing Dynasty, while historical novels paid more attention to the political, economic, cultural and other historical phenomena of the real society. In Dream of the Red Chamber, the author Cao Xueqin reflected the various ills of the feudal society of the Qing Dynasty through the death and separation of the main characters such as Jia Baoyu, Lin Daiyu, Xue Baochai, etc., such as official corruption, family disputes, social darkness, etc. At the same time, it also reveals the complexity and unpredictability of human nature, which makes the ending of the novel full of sadness and tragedy. The happy ending could not perfectly express the theme and plot of Dream of the Red Chamber because it could not reflect the historical and social reality depicted in the novel. As a result, the ending of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' was destined to be a tragedy.

Why did Dream of the Red Chamber have such a tragic ending?

1 answer

2024-09-10 20:01

Dream of the Red Chamber was a classic work in Chinese classical literature. The reason why its ending was so miserable was that the author Cao Xueqin had experienced many twists and turns and pain in the process of writing, as well as the influence of the era and social background. When Cao Xueqin wrote 'Dream of the Red Chamber', it was during the decline of the feudal society of the Qing Dynasty. In this context, social unrest, political corruption, people's living standards decline, traditional culture gradually lost its vitality. Cao Xueqin had experienced a lot of hardships and pain when he was writing 'Dream of the Red Chamber'. He had to sell his property and furniture because of poverty, and finally exhausted all his savings. Therefore,'Dream of the Red Chamber' depicted a poor, depressed, and competitive feudal society, which was one of the reasons for its miserable ending. The ending of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' was also influenced by the era and social background. In the feudal society of the late Qing Dynasty, due to political corruption, social unrest, economic decline and other reasons, the value of people's lives gradually decreased. Family, love, friendship and other interpersonal relationships also became indifferent and hypocritical. In 'Dream of the Red Chamber', many characters experienced pain and suffering, but they all chose to leave this world in the end, which also reflected the mental state of the society at that time. To sum up, the reason why the ending of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' was so miserable was because the author, Cao Xueqin, had experienced a lot of hardships and pain in the process of writing, as well as the influence of the era and social background. Although the ending was heartbreaking, it was also a classic in the history of Chinese literature, which had a profound impact on later literature and art.

Why is the ending of Dream of the Red Chamber so tragic?

1 answer

2024-09-16 09:30

'Dream of the Red Chamber' was a classical Chinese novel that told the story of Jia Baoyu, Lin Daiyu, and the others. Although it was an excellent literary work, its ending was not perfect and was called "tragic". The reason why 'Dream of the Red Chamber' had such a tragic ending was mainly because it depicted a complicated social reality, and the author Cao Xueqin could not find a perfect solution in it. In addition, there were many problems in the novel itself, such as insufficient character creation and complicated plots. In the novel, the love line between Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu was finally torn apart and Jia Baoyu's health was always poor. In addition, there were many characters in the novel who did not have satisfactory endings, such as Xue Baochai, Wang Xifeng, and others. In summary, the reason why the ending of Dream of the Red Chamber was so tragic was mainly because it depicted a complex social reality, and the author Cao Xueqin could not find a perfect solution in it. In addition, there are many problems in the novel itself. These factors eventually lead to the ending of the novel.

Why was the ending of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' so tragic?

1 answer

2024-09-16 09:25

The reason why the ending of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' was so sad was due to the complexity of the story's background and plot, as well as the various difficulties and setbacks that Cao Xueqin had experienced in the process of writing. The story of Dream of the Red Chamber took place in the Qing Dynasty and told the love story of Jia Baoyu, Lin Daiyu and others. In the story, the relationship between Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu was very deep, but in the end, due to various factors, they died separately. This ending was very sad, especially for those who had a deep understanding of relationships. The ending of Dream of the Red Chamber also involved the fate of many people, including Jia Baoyu's family, Xue Baochai and others. Due to the author Cao Xueqin's experience and identity, he could not completely control the plot and development of the entire story, which led to the twists and turns of the fate of many characters, making the whole story even more tragic. The story of Dream of the Red Chamber also involved the creative process of the author, Cao Xueqin. He had experienced many difficulties and setbacks in the creative process, including economic and political pressures, as well as physical and mental health problems. These factors caused him to be unable to complete his work and the final outcome was regrettable. In summary, the reason why the ending of Dream of the Red Chamber was so tragic was due to the complexity of the story background and plot, as well as the difficulties and setbacks experienced by the author Cao Xueqin in the process of writing.

Why did most of the people in 'Dream of the Red Chamber', not have a good ending?

1 answer

2024-09-13 05:03

'Dream of the Red Chamber' was a novel that described the feudal society of the Qing Dynasty. Many of the characters involved had different endings. Some people's endings were good, such as Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu, who finally came together and established a beautiful relationship, while some people's endings were not good, such as Xue Baochai, Wang Xifeng, and others, who finally met with an unfortunate ending. The reason why these characters ended badly could be found in the plot of the novel. First of all, the characters involved in 'Dream of the Red Chamber' had complicated interpersonal relationships. These people intertwined with each other and restricted each other, resulting in unsatisfactory endings. Secondly, there were some flaws in the plot setting of the novel, such as the struggle of interests between families, the cheating behavior of the characters, etc., which would affect the ending of the characters. In addition, the background of the novel was also an important factor that affected the ending of the characters. The atmosphere and environment of the feudal society in the Qing Dynasty had a profound impact on the characters and plots in the novel. For example, the corruption of society, the darkness of politics, the distortion of human nature, etc. all led to the bad ending of the characters. Based on the above reasons, we can conclude that most of the characters in 'Dream of the Red Chamber' do not have a good ending. But we also have to realize that this is just a fictional way of fiction, and not all characters will have a tragic ending.

Why was the ending of Dream of the Red Chamber lost?

1 answer

2024-09-16 09:32

The main reason why the ending of Dream of the Red Chamber was lost was that it was a novel and had gone through many twists and turns in the process of creation, including many changes and cuts. Therefore, the final ending was not the original intention of creation. In addition, the ending of Dream of the Red Chamber also faced many disputes and doubts, including speculations about the fate of the characters and the continuation of the story. These needed further research to obtain a definite answer. Therefore, the ending of Dream of the Red Chamber was gradually forgotten and lost in the process of inheritance, becoming a regret.

Why was the ending of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' a tragedy and not a comedy?

1 answer

2024-09-16 09:52

The reason why the ending of Dream of the Red Chamber was a tragedy was because it depicted a complicated relationship between the characters and the social reality, but in the end, it did not achieve the perfect harmony shown in the comedy ending. The tragedy of a novel usually means that the protagonist has experienced various setbacks and hardships but ultimately failed to achieve his or her desired goal. As the main character in the novel, Jia Baoyu experienced the decline of his family, the setback of love, the loss of friendship and other unfortunate events. Finally, he died in the deserted garden. Such an ending showed the impermanence and unpredictability of life, which made people feel deeply regretful and sad. The tragedies in novels usually contained deep human thoughts and moral implications. Through the tragic love story between Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu, Dream of the Red Chamber expressed the author's deep reflection on the complexity of human nature and social reality. For example, through the relationship between Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu, the novel explored the relationship between love and friendship, as well as the good and evil, vanity, greed and other aspects of human nature. This kind of ending not only made people feel emotional pain, but also made people think deeply about the nature of human nature and society. To sum up, the reason why the ending of Dream of the Red Chamber was a tragedy was that it depicted a complicated relationship between the characters and social reality, but in the end, it did not achieve the perfect harmony shown in the comedy ending. At the same time, the tragedy of the novel also contains profound human thinking and moral meaning, which makes people feel emotional pain and make people think deeply about the nature of human nature and society.

The ending of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' was too sad. Why didn't the author set a perfect ending?

1 answer

2024-09-10 20:00

The reason why the ending of Dream of the Red Chamber was so sad was because it was a literary work created by the author Cao Xueqin. He had already experienced many difficulties and pains when he completed this novel. Dream of the Red Chamber depicted the rise and fall of a family and the fate of many people. There were many sad and unfortunate plots. Cao Xueqin was already very old when he wrote Dream of the Red Chamber. He had experienced a lot of pain and difficulties. These experiences might have affected his creation. In addition, there were many characters in Dream of the Red Chamber whose fates were not determined by themselves but were influenced by external factors such as politics and social environment. In the end, Cao Xueqin had passed away when he was writing the Dream of the Red Chamber. His works had not been fully passed down and developed, so it was difficult to come up with a satisfactory ending. To sum up, the reason why the ending of Dream of the Red Chamber was so sad was because it was a literary work created by the author Cao Xueqin. He had already experienced many difficulties and pains when he completed this novel. In addition, there were many sad and unfortunate plots in 'Dream of the Red Chamber', and the fate of the characters was not decided by themselves. These factors would affect the ending of the work.

Why couldn't the old version of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' surpass it?

1 answer

2024-09-05 08:32

Dream of the Red Chamber was a classic novel with profound historical and cultural value. Since its publication, it had received widespread attention and love. Although the old version of Dream of the Red Chamber was shot in the 1980s, due to technical limitations and creative concepts at that time, it had some artistic and aesthetic limitations that were difficult to surpass. The director and screenwriter of the old version of Dream of the Red Chamber were deeply influenced by traditional culture in the creative process, so they paid more attention to the description of the characters 'personalities and the expression of emotions in shaping the characters and plots. This kind of writing method limited the depth and breadth of the novel to a certain extent, making the story relatively simple and lacking in innovation. There were also some limitations in the shooting techniques and image quality of the old version of 'Dream of the Red Chamber'. It was difficult to shoot at that time, and it required a lot of time and effort. At the same time, in order to restore the scenes and atmosphere in the novel, the filming team used some special equipment and techniques that could not be fully realized today. Although the old version of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' had some artistic and aesthetic limitations that were difficult to surpass, its contribution to cultural heritage and historical value was immeasurable. It was a classic novel with a profound cultural background, which had a profound impact on the development of Chinese literature and culture.

Why did the author of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' make the noble and virtuous Miao Yu's ending so tragic?

1 answer

2024-09-10 19:39

There were many reasons why the author of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' made the noble and virtuous Miaoyu's ending so tragic. Miaoyu was a very unique character. She was born into a noble family, but due to the decline of her family or personal encounters, she gradually lost her value and status, becoming lonely and helpless. In the novel, Miaoyu's image was portrayed as lofty, independent, and confident, but her heart was filled with loneliness and helplessness. She did not want to interact with the secular world, nor did she want to share her feelings and heart with others. This kind of character made her a very difficult character in the novel, and it was difficult for readers to like and recognize her. Miaoyu's ending also reflected the author's thoughts and reflections on reality. Her image was similar to many women in reality, who faced similar difficulties and challenges in modern society. Through Miaoyu's story, the novel expressed her thoughts on women's status and self-worth, and also reflected the necessity of social changes and historical development. To sum up, there were many reasons why the author of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' had made the noble Miaoyu's ending so tragic, including the uniqueness of the character's personality and the necessity of fate.

The Ending of Dream of the Red Chamber

1 answer

2024-09-19 03:46

'Dream of the Red Chamber' was one of the classics of Chinese classical literature and one of the most magnificent, representative, and influential novels in the history of Chinese literature. The novel narrated the love story of Jia Baoyu, Lin Daiyu, Xue Baochai, and the rise and fall of the Jia family. At the end of the novel, Jia Baoyu died of grief and Lin Daiyu and Xue Baochai also committed suicide. The Jia family eventually declined and perished. The entire story ended with "Story of the Stone". The stone became the Jia family's heirloom treasure box. Jia Baoyu placed it in the box with Lin Daiyu, Xue Baochai, Jia Baoyu, and the others, and placed it in the Grand View Garden of the "Jia Daishan's Home in Rong Mansion". After that, a series of stories happened while Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu lived in the Grand View Garden of Jia Daishan's family in Rong Mansion. Eventually, the stone was inherited by the "Story of the Stone" and became the symbol of love between Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu. The ending of the novel,"Story of the Stone", expressed the author's deep thinking about human nature and his helplessness and emotion towards fate. It also showed the problems and thoughts about family, love, fate and other aspects in ancient Chinese culture.