Why isn't writing Jin Yong's Doujinshi considered as an act of copyright violation?

2024-09-16 06:56

1 answer

2024-09-16 11:22

There was currently a dispute over whether writing Jin Yong's doujinshi would constitute an copyright violation. Some people believed that Jin Yong's doujinshi was a doujinshi work, and it was not an act of copyright violation if it was created under the premise of respecting the original work. There were also some people who believed that Jin Yong's doujinshi novels might be considered as an copyright violation because it involved the copyright of the original author. Mr. Jin Yong was one of the founders of modern Chinese martial arts novels. His works were widely spread and praised. However, Mr. Jin Yong also had his own copyright protection measures to restrict and censor works of the same genre. Therefore, writing Jin Yong's doujinshi required one to abide by Mr. Jin Yong's copyright protection measures or to create it after authorization from Mr. Jin Yong. Creation based on respect for the original work can be considered a doujinshi work, but you need to be careful not to violate the copyright of the original author. The creation of doujinshi works had to follow the relevant provisions of the copyright law, such as fair use, adaptation, translation, and other principles, and on the basis of respecting the original work. If writing Jin Yong's doujinshi was in line with these principles and did not violate Mr. Jin Yong's copyright, then it would not be considered an copyright violation. Whether or not writing Jin Yong's doujinshi would be considered as a violation of copyright would need to be analyzed according to the specific circumstances. If copyright protection measures were followed, the original work was respected, and the creation was done within a reasonable range, then generally speaking, it could be considered that the violation had not occurred.

Isn't Jin Yong's Doujin novel considered as copyright violation?

1 answer

2024-09-18 18:31

Jin Yong is a famous Chinese martial arts novel. His novels have been translated into many languages and are very popular around the world. Jin Yong's novels were widely adapted into movies, TV series, comics and many other forms. Many of his works were widely praised and discussed. There are different opinions on whether Jin Yong's novels constitute copyright violation. Some people think that the original work of Jin Yong's novel is already protected by copyright as a literary work. Therefore, any unauthorized adaptation, translation, creation, etc. will constitute copyright violation. Others believed that Jin Yong's Doujinshi novel was an innovative creation based on the original work. Although the content might have been influenced by the original work, the creative method and style could exist independently, so it did not constitute copyright. To be specific, whether Jin Yong's novels constituted an copyright violation needed to be judged according to the specific circumstances. If the content of a Doujin novel was completely based on the original work and there was no form of adaptation, modification, or reduction, then it might not be considered an copyright violation. However, if a certain percentage of the content of the Doujin novel was adapted, modified, or deleted, or if a new storyline was created based on the original work, it might constitute copyright violation. Whether or not Jin Yong's novels constituted an copyright violation was a complicated question that needed to be judged according to the specific situation. When writing Doujinshi, one had to pay attention to respecting copyright protection and avoid any acts of copyright violation.

Is Doujinshi considered an copyright violation?

1 answer

2024-09-12 12:12

Doujinshi referred to a second creation based on the original work, which usually included some elements related to the original work. There had always been a debate about whether doujinshi was considered an intellectual property right. On the one hand, some legal experts believed that doujinshi was based on the original work, and the creative ideas and content were consistent with the original work, so there was no problem of copyright violation. In addition, they believed that the creators and readers of doujinshi were both inheriting and developing the original work, so there was no copyright dispute. On the other hand, some legal experts believe that doujinshi actually violates the copyright of the original work because the content and ideas of doujinshi are different from the original work, but they are creative adaptation and re-creation. They believed that the copyright of the original work should be protected, and any unauthorized re-creation should be regarded as an copyright violation. Therefore, whether or not a doujinshi was considered an copyright violation depended on the specific circumstances. If the content of the doujinshi is similar to the original work and it is not authorized by the original work, it may be considered as copyright violation. However, if the content of the doujinshi is different from the original work and the original work is authorized, then it will not be regarded as copyright violation. When creating doujinshi, it is recommended to carefully consider whether you have violated the copyright of the original work and comply with relevant laws and regulations.

Writing a martial arts novel that borrows the world of Jin Yong's novel, is it considered copyright violation?

1 answer

2024-09-07 18:50

Borrowing the world characters or moves of Jin Yong's novels to write martial arts novels may constitute copyright violation if they are not explicitly authorized by Mr. Jin Yong. Mr. Jin Yong was a famous martial arts novelist. His works, such as Eight Dragons, Smiling Proud Jianghu, and Deer and Cauldron, had become classics. The characters, moves, and plots in his works were widely quoted and used for reference. Although Mr. Jin Yong has passed away, his copyright rights are still protected by law. Borrowing and adapting without his authorization may constitute copyright infringement. Therefore, when writing martial arts novels, if you want to borrow the world, characters, or moves of Jin Yong's novels, you need to ensure that you obtain the explicit authorization of Mr. Jin Yong. If they could not obtain authorization, they would have to bear the risk of copyright infringement.

Was publishing a movie clip considered an act of copyright violation?

1 answer

2024-09-10 00:21

Releasing a film clip may be an act of copyright violation, especially without the authorization or permission of the film copyright owner. Movie editing is usually a step in the film production process that can be used to create one's own work or used in combination with other works. However, when releasing a film clip, you must ensure that it does not violate any works or intellectual property rights protected by copyright law. If a film clip uses copyright-protected film material or any other material, then publishing it may be an act of copyright violation. In order to avoid copyright abuses, film editors need to study copyright laws carefully and use copyright-protected material or sources of material or use material that has already been authorized. In addition, they also need to comply with other legal requirements such as copyright transfer agreements or license agreements. If you publish a film clip and wish to avoid copyright abuses, please always ensure that it does not violate any copyright-protected works or intellectual property rights.

Was writing a novel based on the story of the Nine-Tailed Cat considered an act of copyright violation?

1 answer

2024-09-21 16:48

According to China's copyright law, the creation of a work must meet certain conditions before it can be considered as an copyright violation. As for the story of the Nine-Tailed Cat, if the author only created it out of personal inspiration and imagination without authorization or copyright from any third party, then the act of using it to create a novel and spreading it publicly may constitute copyright. However, if the story originated from a fictional myth or legend, or from an external source such as an anime or movie, and was authorized by the relevant copyright owner, then using the story to create a novel would not be considered an copyright violation. The specific situation still needs to be judged according to the actual situation. If you have any questions, it is recommended to consult relevant professionals.

Was writing a novel based on historical figures and the era as the background considered an act of copyright violation?

1 answer

2024-08-28 15:32

Writing a novel based on historical figures and the era of the time could be considered an copyright violation without any copyright protection. This was because, according to the provisions of the " copyright law," no one was allowed to create works, including novels and other literary works, using fictional characters, plots, or locations without authorization. If the name, image, plot, etc. of a historical figure appeared in the novel, or if the story or speech of a historical figure was directly quoted, then it might be considered as copyright violation. In this case, the author's behavior was to use the intellectual property rights of historical figures without authorization and violate the copyright of historical figures. In order to avoid copyright violation, it is recommended to understand the relevant laws and regulations when writing novels. Try to avoid using unauthorized characters and content as much as possible. At the same time, they could also consult the descendants of historical figures or copyright owners to obtain authorization before creating.

Is continuation an act of copyright violation?

1 answer

2024-09-11 03:00

Sequences to novels were usually considered as an act of copyright violation, especially when the content of the continuation was directly related to the original work. For example, he could copy the plot, characters, and locations of the original work directly into his own work or add his own imagination and creation on the basis of the original work. Continuing to write a novel may violate the copyright of the original work, so you need to obtain permission from the copyright owner. Without permission, the act of continuing to write a novel was an act of copyright violation. In addition, a continuation of a novel may also be considered plagiarism because the content of the continuation may directly copy or draw on some elements or plots of the original work. This kind of behavior also violated the relevant provisions of the copyright law and required the corresponding legal responsibility. Therefore, if one wanted to continue writing a novel, it was best to understand the relevant laws and regulations and ensure that their actions were legal.

Why isn't Jin Yong writing martial arts novels?

1 answer

2024-09-13 16:04

Mr. Jin Yong has been writing martial arts novels for decades. He has created many unforgettable classic characters and plots in his novels. However, he was also aware of the changes in the wuxia novel market and the needs of readers. Mr. Jin Yong once said that the wuxia novel market began to decline in the 1980s and 1990s because readers began to pay more attention to other types of literature such as modern novels and detective novels. In addition, Mr. Jin Yong's works have also been adapted into movies and TV series many times, which also affected his enthusiasm for writing martial arts novels. Mr. Jin Yong also realized that his novel had reached a certain bottleneck and it was difficult to create more unique storylines and characters. Therefore, he decided to turn to other fields such as writing essays, novels, scripts, etc. to express his artistic pursuit and creative inspiration. Although Mr. Jin Yong had left the creation of martial arts novels, his works were still deeply loved by readers and became one of the classics of Chinese literature.

Was writing doujin novels considered copyright violation?

1 answer

2024-09-05 19:04

Writing doujinshi is often seen as copyright violation because doujinshi is a novel based on the story, image, or plot of another person (usually a fictional character). This was because Doujinshi novels copied the content of the original work, including the characters, plot, and worldview, without obtaining the authorization of the original work. In many countries, including China and the United States, copyright laws prohibit the creation of second works, including doujinshi, without the authorization of the copyright owner. This meant that if you wrote doujinshi, you would have to comply with copyright law and could face legal risks. Even so, doujinshi novels were still allowed in some countries and in some cases considered a legal form of creation. However, if you want to write Doujin novels, you must first understand the relevant laws and regulations and try to obtain the authorization of the copyright owner of the original work.

Was writing doujin novels considered copyright violation?

1 answer

2024-09-03 07:41

Writing doujinshi in itself does not necessarily constitute copyright but using someone else's work (such as manga, novels, movies, etc.) as a source of inspiration for one's own creation and creating one's own original doujinshi work may constitute copyright. This is because copyright laws in many countries, including China, protect the author's original works regardless of their origin. If a doujinshi novel is based on someone else's work, the author may have the right to protect his original work and refuse to share or adapt other people's copyrights. Of course, the specific situation still needed to be judged based on the type of work, the source, and whether it involved the core content of other people's works. Therefore, when writing Doujinshi novels, it is recommended to first understand the relevant laws and regulations to avoid copyright violation.